3 ms·
I think that is asking too much. Absence of certification from a licensed surveyor should be enough. If a schematic needs to be from a licensed professional, t
by s1artibartfast 4y ago
I think that is asking too much. Absence of certification from a licensed surveyor should be enough.
If a schematic needs to be from a licensed professional, the burden is to demonstrate that it is.
Sometimes it is appropriate to require a license professional to certify something, other times it is not
- toss1 4y agoI've no idea why you're getting downvoted, as your comment is spot-on. Currently going through a permitting process for small modification in my yard, and the town is very explicit about what needs a certified engineer's stamp and what does not need it. It is a very specific requirement and specific thing to produce. If it does not have the official stamp and signature, it is NOT a certified/stamped/approved drawing. End of story. Perhaps it works differently in different states, but this has been the routine in every state in which I've lived. the bottom line is that the presumption is that it is NOT an engineering drawing NOR is it certified, unless the certification/stamp/signature is explicit. Also, thinking about it a second, the stamp/certification/signature is literally the engineer putting their reputation, license, and career on the line over the accuracy of the drawing. No engineer is going to want that to happen as a default operation — it must be explicit.
- mcherm 4y ago> No engineer is going to want that to happen as a default operation — it must be explicit. I would go so far as to say that it would be unconstitutional (first amendment; free speech) to restrict the act of "making a map" (although restricting the use of an official seal would be fine).
- toss1 4y ago>> it would be unconstitutional (first amendment; free speech) to restrict the act of "making a map" Excellent point — go file an Amicus brief!
- s1artibartfast 4y agoIt is already one of the primary claims in the lawsuit
- mannykannot 4y ago> I think that is asking too much. It is not a big ask, and it would not interfere in any way with any of the reasonable uses that are being suggested here. I suspect there is something of a Chesterton's fence here, dating back to a time when the use of false documents in swindling people were not uncommon. Many comments here are premised on the assumption that the acquirers of such maps should be under no illusion as to their legal status, but that does not necessarily extend to those to whom the acquirers might present these documents. The average HN reader may not be fooled, but they may have elderly relatives who might be. While I have no reason to believe the person here is in any way abetting any such scheme, a simple disclaimer on the maps themselves might offer a reasonable compromise between disparate concerns.
- maxsilver 4y ago> I think that is asking too much. Absence of certification from a licensed surveyor should be enough. I don't. As someone who has actually worked in compliance and accreditation, fakes and frauds happen constantly, and regular laypeople have no reasonable way to know whether they're being defrauded over this or not. Web startups that claim to offer "Guaranteed Acceptance" (like his does) without having actually done any of the compliance work to earn that acceptance, are common -- the field is ripe with abuse. "Absense of certification" is how you end up with food that's poisoned (it didn't promise not to be poisoned) or products that electrocute you (it didn't promise not to zap you) or fake land surveys (it didn't promise not to hold up in court) You shouldn't have to be an expert in every single field on the entire planet, to not get scammed 24/7/365. It's one major reason why we require licensed professionals in the first place. A regular person might only see a land survey once or twice in their entire life, they can't be expected to know that these random website ones are fakes. This person is selling drawings he knows are commonly used in place of land surveys, that are fake -- he's not a land surveyor, he's not licensed to sell these. (He could just get licensed, it's not that hard, every other surveyor in my state has done so, there's no cap or limit on licensing of these, it's not difficult to perform them legally). -- His argument is no different than a fellow selling fake Drivers Licenses trying to get out of their consequences by claiming the board wants to "make printing photographs illegal" > Sometimes it is appropriate to require a license professional to certify something, other times it is not Sure, but property lines are a pretty clear place where a licensed professional needs to certify it. If you let laypeople do it without knowledge, then property rights start to lose the ability to get enforced fairly.
- rahimnathwani 4y agoWhen you say "that are fake -- he's not a land surveyor, he's not licensed to sell these" it seems to me that the fakeness is based on who is providing them, not on what he's selling. Have I understood your point correctly? I mean, if he were to obtain the relevant credentials, but did not change a single thing about what he's selling or how they're produced, would that mean the things he's selling are no longer fake?
- maxsilver 4y ago
- _fat_santa 4y agoIt is and it isn't. While not technically required by what you said, it would be trivial for the business to add a small watermark at the bottom of the page, and would add an extra layer of CYA for the business.