4 ms·
I would take a different tack on this: the speech was legally unhindered, that is, free. The consequences of the speech are, however, borne by the speaker. I
by dredmorbius 4y ago
I would take a different tack on this: the speech was legally unhindered, that is, free.
The consequences of the speech are, however, borne by the speaker.
I'm not sure this covers all cases of consequential burdening, but it does seem to cover many of them. A future prohibition on speech, gag order, banning from online or broadcast services, etc., might be a harder case to make, though these could still be seen as sanctions on behaviour rather than content.
I'm not defending Jones at all here, his penalties are exceedingly well deserved and have been far too delayed.
- int_19h 4y ago> I would take a different tack on this: the speech was legally unhindered, that is, free. The consequences of the speech are, however, borne by the speaker. If you do redefine freedom of speech thus, then what place in the world doesn't have it? Even in North Korea you can speak freely for a short while before you have to bear the consequences.
- budder 4y agoExactly. Did the Wuhan doctors sounding the alarm about a new virus, without “evidence” have freedom of speech? The CCP tried to suppress them for “inciting a panic” until it became obvious they couldn’t cover it up any longer
- dredmorbius 4y agoPrior restraint and criminal punishment would seem to be two fairly obvious standards. Neither apply in this case. Freedom of speech is never an absolute, it had a long history of far lower significance in the United States prior to the 1950s, and has a long an complex history. I'm not a legal scholar, I'm still researching the background and history myself. Two resources of possible interest and use to yourself and others: Jacob Mchangama's Clear and Present Danger podcast, 40 episodes plus several special installments on the history of free expression. The creator tends rather more libertarian than I, though he's not an absolutist. That said, there's reasonably little bias I'd noted in the overall presentation, which is nuanced. <http://www.freespeechhistory.com/ http://www.freespeechhistory.com/> On texts ... there's a whole heck of a lot. I've not read the Very Short Introduction title yet, but have added it to my own reading mountain/asteroid: <https://www.worldcat.org/title/244062809 https://www.worldcat.org/title/244062809> <http://libgen.rs/book/index.php?md5=8647BBCBFB1AADAC2A4C98ED6A516341 http://libgen.rs/book/index.php?md5=8647BBCBFB1AADAC2A4C98ED...> Looking that up just now, the author, Nigel Warburton, is known to me from other books on philosophy which were good.