9 ms·
Gowalla Founders v. Gowalla Investors
- learc83 15y agoWhat's the problem, it appears the company was dead anyway, and had no real assets so the investors get 30 cents on the dollar instead of nothing.
- sturadnidge 15y agoArrington mentions 2 ways to look at it (both from the investor perspective), but there's a third - entrepreneurs raising a stiff middle finger to investors who have fucked them over (or tried to). I'm not saying it was the case with Gowalla, nor am I saying all VC's are assholes. Just saying that it it's another motive for deals like this.
- kloncks 15y agoOne of the highlights of this article was hearing how SV Angel thinks about this. It was sane, pragmatic, intelligent and succinct. I haven't yet had a chance to work with them, but my opinion of them is constantly increasing.
- keeptrying 15y agoCon ways and SV angels marketing strategy is to be extremely pro entrepreneur. It's their inherent differentiation strategy. I love it!
- geofflewis 15y agoThey're constantly supportive, always helpful, never intrusive. The best.
- Shenglong 15y agoParakey investors got ---they’re--- money back and a little more, Arrgh. I have nothing constructive to post about this, but this mistake annoys me.
- danshapiro 15y agoHere's the right way to behave, in two simple steps: Step 1 Company management (in this case, the founders) have a fiduciary obligation to get as much money for the company as possible. In the sale negotiation, they should discuss the price of the company first. If the buyer tries to talk about their compensation, they simply decline to engage in the conversation, saying that their obligation is first and foremost to the shareholders, so the company price is the first order of business. They should negotiate as hard as they can to maximize the value returned to the shareholders. Step 2 Once the company price is set, the management/founders should negotiate the best deal possible for the team - both themselves AND the other employees (don't forget the latter). The company's already locked and loaded. There is no reason for the team to hold the screws to the acquirer at this point for maximum value. There are two classic mistakes that get made. The founder mistake is easy to make, because the company will encourage it: "How about if we lower the price of the company by $X, and add $X to your retention package?" This is wrong and possibly illegal (but it's hard to get caught). Taking this sells out your shareholders and violates your duties as an officer of the company. The second classic mistake is an investor one: thinking the employee compensation belongs to the company. Employee comp is for future services rendered, not past. There's no reason the shareholders should get a percentage of the founder-cum-employee's stock grant unless they plan to do part of their work for them. tl;dr: get the best price for your company, then get the best price for yourself and your team.
- pyoung 15y ago>""How about if we lower the price of the company by $X, and add $X to your retention package?" This is wrong and possibly illegal" It would be good to clarify if this in fact illegal. If it is not illegal, than saying that it is wrong is subjective. In the case of talent acquisitions, the acquiring company has an incentive to focus more compensation to the 'founder-cum-employee' for retention and incentive purposes. I feel that it would be very reasonable for an acquiring company to use this as a negotiation tool (unless it is illegal, of course) as they are merely looking out for their own, longer-term interests.
- jackgavigan 15y ago
- OoTheNigerian 15y agoNo one is taliking about the users. Maybe it is me but my 'moral antenna' says it wrong to leave users suddenly stranded. Yes it was a 'free service', but the free users made it possible to get millions in investments. Users investest time and effort into making your service valuable. Here is how I would do things differently. Depending on the cost, I will have a shut down period of 3-6 months. Longer if possible. I will make it easy for users to export AND import their data into a similar service. In this case 4sq. That is the very least they should do. The data from a users Gowalla account is ppractically useless if it is not put in context of a similar app/service. Telling millions of users "take your shit out by next month, thanks for your time" is not cool at all. FriendFeed did it much better. Etacts is the worst I have come accross. It is not cool for Gowalla, it will also not be cool for gmail.
- ngkabra 15y agoIf you're a user in the modern internet, it is not cool for you to keep yourself so much at the mercy of companies whom you don't pay. I always keep a Thunderbird client running in the background of my laptop, which sucks out all emails from gmail and keeps a local copy. Yes, it would not be cool for gmail to one day suddenly cut me off, and yes, I feel Google, with its "Do no Evil" policy will not do that to me. But still, I prefer to make my copy of important data right now, thank you very much, instead of whining later that this is not cool. Same with my Flickr pics and Delicious links (downloaded using a script). And my Facebook data I really don't care about.
- bravura 15y agoI would pay for a single service that does this across most major internet properties. i.e. pulls my data for me onto, say, an S3 share.
- PedroCandeias 15y agoThere's a few of them: http://www.sitepoint.com/backup-social-media-profiles/ http://www.sitepoint.com/backup-social-media-profiles/
- pyoung 15y agoConsidering that the founders will be taking positions at facebook, these 'side deals' appear to be closer to salary/compensation negotiations than anything else. Just because you invested in a company, it doesn't mean you own the founders. While the company may not have succeeded, these guys are probably very valuable assets and should be compensated by FB accordingly.
- bambax 15y ago> Parakey investors got they’re money back How can one write for a living and spell like this? English is not my mother tongue and yet I now the difference between they're and their, it's vs. its. Or is this the result of poor speech-recognition software?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- 286c8cb04bda 15y agoIt's an artifact of how native learners acquire language, compared to adult learners. Our native tongues are acquired rather ad hoc, and most people 'think' in speech. (As evidence, watch a slow reader. Often times they will sub-vocalize the text as they read. This is a side effect of their brain turning the text back into sound.) So, to somebody who learned English as a child -- and is therefore aurally dominant -- the words "they're", "there", and "their" will all basically occupy an overlapping space in their mind. Somebody who learned English later will use textbooks to support the process; Things like contractions will be give special emphasis, etc.
- bambax 15y agoYou make an interesting point, and what makes it very interesting is that it's testable: are native speakers worse spellers than non-native speakers? And which words do each group have the most difficulty spelling? It doesn't seem likely that non-native speakers are better general spellers than native speakers; but it's possible that some words are especially difficult for native speakers and not for non-native ones. Are you aware of existing studies on that subject?
- 286c8cb04bda 15y agoAye, there have been numerous investigations into it. Among linguists, it seems to be basically taken as a given that homophones, particularly when compared to less skilled native readers, are going to be easier for the non-native, because of acquisition methods. I should've prefaced that with the disclaimer that I am not a linguist, but I have worked in the past with linguists on language-related work, both in L1 (native) and L2 (non-native) contexts. Here are a couple of references I was given on this specific subject: 1. Van Orden, Guy C. (1987). A ROWS is a ROSE: Spelling, sound and reading. 2. Binder, K. & Borecki, C. (2007). The use of phonological, orthographic, and contextual information during reading. 3. Ota, M., Hartsuiker, R. J., & Haywood, S. L. (2010). Is a FAN always FUN? Full texts for all of those are available online.
- mikkom 15y ago> If a founder leaves stockholders behind to take a lucrative side deal, they’re not acting ethically. I’ve mostly taken this position in the past, before becoming a VC. As if VCs are acting "ethically". I have seen many VC cases (and been involved with a few) and be assured, VCs are not "ethical" or think founders AT ALL. All they think about is their money. If they could exchange founders future for a fat pile of cash, they will do it. If the VCs are minority owners (as it seems in case like this), they can just accept what is decided. This is also the case with founders when VCs have majority. They will always do what they want (what's best for their money) without thinking founders best interest or "ethics" of their actions.
- mathattack 15y agoA couple thoughts here: 1) As the article states, Facebook has fiduciary duty to Facebook and nobody else. 2) Same with the VCs. 3) This isn't unique to high tech. Sometimes a CEO will accept a bad merger price to become the CEO of a larger firm. This is called the principal-agent problem and is why boards should be involved in all M and A. 4) Unless there are competing bids it is hard to prove a failure of fiduciary duty. In the end it's reputation. If the Angel and VC feel screwed then the execs won't get money again. If not it is ok. It is lie Prisoners Dilemna - you play nice in a repeated game.
- DevX101 15y agoOn the most recent TechStars/Bloomberg startup reality show, a couple of investors tongue in cheek talked about investing in the career earnings of one of the entrepreneurs whom they thought had a lot of promise. Although the investors probably weren't too serious about this point, I don't think its a bad idea. If Gowalla investors had struck such a deal with the founders of Gowalla then of course they'd be entitled to some of the stock grants that Facebook offered. But they didn't. They invested in the company which failed, so they get nada. And I give absolutely no credence to the argument that the investors funds boosted the profile of Gowalla founders so they wouldn't have gotten great deals from Facebook if it weren't for their investment. If that's the case, then limited partners should be entitled to a share of the profits from a VC's second fund if the first one goes bust. Because, you know, it was the limited partners' money that gave you a name in the VC community in the first place. Of course, no one takes such an argument seriously in the finance community, and neither should you entrepreneurs.
- Jasber 15y agoFYI this actually happened: http://venturebeat.com/2010/03/03/life-investment/ http://venturebeat.com/2010/03/03/life-investment/
- jrockway 15y agoSee also: taxes. The government subsidizes school (in some form) from kindergarten to your PhD, and in return, you pay them back in the form of taxes as soon as you use that knowledge to make money.
- gyardley 15y agoVery odd example, no? While pooled revenue from taxes does pay for collective benefits, any single individual's taxes are only tenuously related to the benefits they receive. If it worked like you described, I'd expect a break from the IRS since my education mostly took place elsewhere, and I'd still be writing checks to the Canadian government for the education and healthcare I got as a child. (That wouldn't necessarily be a bad thing, but it's not how it works.)
- tptacek 15y agoGowalla lost. This is what happens to investments when companies lose. The "side deals" the team makes after their company fails are irrelevant. Nobody is better off going down with the ship; not the founders, not the employees, and not the investors.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- amorphid 15y agoI tend to agree. If the founders shutdown the company and started a new one, there wouldn't be much fuss. So if they shutdown the company and get a nice signing bonus to join Facebook, that seems the same to me. If I were an investor in Gowalla, I certainly wouldn't be thrilled with it, but I would at least try to own the fact that my investment failed. An investor should be most pissed at Facebook. This is the equivalent of recruiting away Gowalla's employees one at a time with big piles of cash. As the last employee is recruited away, Gowalla effectively becomes an empty shell. How much can investors get for the shell?
- vannevar 15y agoGowalla lost. This is what happens to investments when companies lose. Not necessarily. Sometimes they pivot from a failed product to a successful one, in which case the investors are rewarded for sticking with the team (which often requires follow-on investment in such cases). VCs often say that they invest primarily in teams, not ideas. It's not clear that the team really lost here, but the investors obviously did.
- tptacek 15y agoTwo responses. First, when you "pivot" after losing a fight for a market and take an A round of funding, you failed. Not all failures are fatal, but the word "pivot" isn't a magic startup 1-up mushroom. Second, whatever you want to call it, nobody is better off not selling if Gowalla 2012 was destined to fail anyways. It is among other things (very) hard to retain talent at a company facing (at best) a heavily dilutive future round just to keep the lights on for a (very) uncertain new product. Ultimately though, I'm just repelled by the idea that people think operators owe it to financiers to go down with the ship. I think the real issue cuts in rather the other direction: founder-operators who kowtow to VC partners to preserve their reputations and future fundability, come what may to the employees they recruited to their doomed company.
- hkarthik 15y agoThose complaining should look back to 2000 when a deadpooled startup left a gaping hole in the economy with lost jobs, bad investments with ordinary Americans, and a negative impact on every other startup in the space. Given the alternative, I'll take founders selling out and moving on over what we went through 10 years ago.
- jackgavigan 15y agoJust a Point of Information... There's no actual confirmation that Facebook is acquiring Gowalla as a company. In fact, Facebook's statement (as quoted on various news sites) seems to suggest the opposite: ”While Facebook isn’t acquiring the Gowalla service or technology, we’re sure that the inspiration behind Gowalla will make its way into Facebook over time." It wouldn't surprise me if it turns out that what's actually happening is that the core Gowalla team is quitting Gowalla to work for Facebook, and Gowalla will be shut down, with the remaining funds being returned to the investors (i.e. the "twenty or thirty cents ... for every dollar invested" that Arrington refers to). No doubt we'll find out in time.
- notbitter 15y agoThis is why Gowalla's investors are diversified across multiple startups. For them this is just one setback in a much larger game. The people getting screwed here are Gowalla's employees, who put years of effort into a single project and whose options are now worth zero.
- wavephorm 15y agoIs Arrington essentially saying when he invests in a business he wants a cut of all future salaries and compensation of the founders should the company get liquidated? Wake up buddy. A VC invests in the business, not the people. A shareholder is insulated from liability and for that privilege they are not entitled to anything outside the scope of the corporation.
- bambax 15y agoUmm, no. He's saying the exact opposite: > Focus on the winners, and don’t lose sleep over the losers. Seems like a good investment philosophy to me.
- gyardley 15y agoI don't get the reason for this article's existence. Nothing is new or unusual here. In any acquisition, the CEO and senior staff simultaneously negotiate their compensation packages with the acquiring company. This always leads to major conflicts of interest, which is why the board gets to approve the acquisition, and why in larger transactions there's often some outside help brought in to negotiate. If the board doesn't like the proportion of the proceeds going to the employees, they can always block the acquisition. They have that power precisely for situations like this. Since Gowalla's board approved the Facebook acquisition, they're presumably fine with it. As for the minor investors who've been kept in the dark - I'm sure they agreed to drag-along provisions in their investor rights agreements, which meant they didn't have to be consulted. You have the rights you agree to.
- viscanti 15y agoIt makes sense from the investor's perspective. They weren't going to get a better, more lucrative exit. Gowalla would probably just whither and die eventually. Instead, now the investors get to talk about how they had a "successful" exit, which might help them get future deals (most startups would prefer to raise money from someone with several exits). It seems like it was the best deal for all involved.
- kariatx 15y agoI think a more interesting question is what sort of responsibility Gowalla founders had to its employees. I've noticed that a good number of employees aren't staying on with the Facebook transition (by my count, only a small minority are going on to Palo Alto). Maybe they had better offers elsewhere, but considering some people are opting for uncertainty / unemployment, my speculation is that they got the short end of the stick with this one.
- rdouble 15y agoEarly stage startup employees usually get hosed except in IPOs.