5 ms·
> Defamation law has always existed and people can always sue you for libel and slander. But a $965 million dollar judgment for libel or slander would have to
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
> Defamation law has always existed and people can always sue you for libel and slander.
But a $965 million dollar judgment for libel or slander would have to be justified by comparable damages. That isn't the case here.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 4y agoSure it is. The jury literally just found those damages. These aren't punitive damages, they're compensatory. Punitive damages are the next phase of the case.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoI accept that the jury labeled the amount as compensatory damage. But it is obviously the case that that amount of damage was not dealt. Nobody involved had a reputation that was worth $100 million dollars.
- tptacek 4y agoThat's not obvious to me at all. Can a 9-figure media and supplements company inflict 25-50 million dollars on an individual? Sure they can. Selling the memory of a parent's murdered child and defaming them to the point where they are followed into different states by lunatics threatening their lives seems to easily cross that threshold. How disruptive would it be to my life if that happened to me? Over how many years? It's a huge amount of baseline injury, and then it's multiplied by the demonstrable profits earned by Free Speech Systems at their expense. Remember, it's almost a billion dollars because twenty children were murdered at Sandy Hook, and Jones' company managed to target all of the parents. If only one parent had sued, we wouldn't be batting an eyelash at the resulting damages. But Jones built an immensely powerful media machine, and then aimed it very carefully at his own testicles. Play stupid games, &c &c.
- scarab92 4y agoI don't see how a company can inflict $25 million in damages per person. Damages for wrongful death usually don't even go this high.
- tptacek 4y agoPeople seemed to have no problem with the idea that Oberlin could have inflicted $36MM against a family. I didn't either! That's how tort damages work.
- scarab92 4y agoThe Oberlin case had damages of $25 million, not $36 million, and that was the combined award to number of individuals plus a company that suffered a significant loss of revenue. Apples vs Oranges.
- tptacek 4y agoI don't agree. But if you'd like another example: Hulk Hogan got $115MM personally from Gawker, over a sex tape.
- greyhair 4y agoIf I could get $115M for a sex tape, I'd be making one every week.
- tejohnso 4y agoApples & oranges again? Hogan is a public figure who might actually lose out on a hundred mil due to reputation damage. A average middle class USA family, not so much. Anyway if it isn't punitive shouldn't there be some kind of account for how the number was arrived at? I don't see it in the article.
- 9935c101ab17a66 4y agoWell, to be frank, it doesn't matter. Some people probably think any kind of damages for defamation are ridiculous. Others probably think this wasn't enough. It doesn't matter though, because you weren't selected to serve on the jury at the trial. You didn't see the evidence, you didn't get to observe jones' conduct, you didn't sit through days and days of testimony about how horrible and traumatic it was for the families of sandy hook to lose their children and then be called 'crisis actors' by Alex Jones repeatedly. His followers were literally harassing the parents in public. These damages may be above average and the highest ever in a defamation trial, but Alex Jones really took being a defamatory piece of shit to a new level.
- mdp2021 4y ago> reputation Very probably the matter is not with reputation. What seems to be more plausible instead is: -- the victims having had an angry mob risen against them (and of course in the context of having suffered a diremost loss); -- the responsible having financially exploited the situation.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> the responsible having financially exploited the situation. This has nothing to do with the lawsuit. It's not a defamation claim; it's not a damages claim. You'd have to make a claim for unjust enrichment.
- tptacek 4y agoYou sound very sure of this, but I am less sure. Disgorgement is a remedy, in US law, for torts in general. Damages are especially constrained in defamation claims, because of the first amendment, but defamation is just one of five claims against Jones, all of which he was found guilty of --- intentional and negligent infliction of emotional distress, false light invasion of privacy, and, most notably, violating the Connecticut Unfair Trade Practices act. I'm not saying I'm sure these numbers will hold up (punitive damages under CUTPA are uncapped, though!), but I think the story about how the jury could have reached these numbers is a lot more complicated than you're making it out to be. In particular: (1) It's not just defamation. (2) You do not in fact need to make a "claim for unjust enrichment" to recover profits earned through an intentional tort.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> You do not in fact need to make a "claim for unjust enrichment" to recover profits earned through an intentional tort. I would need a lot more than your assertion to be convinced of this. Here's Ward Farnsworth introducing his book, Restitution: Civil Liability for Unjust Enrichment: > Restitution is the mirror image of tort law. You sue in tort to recover for losses that you have suffered. You bring a restitution claim to recover gains that another party has obtained. In some cases it makes no difference which claim you bring, because your losses and the other side's gains are the same. Or you might prefer a tort claim because your losses are bigger than the defendant's gains, as usually is true when you suffer damage in an accident. But sometimes going after the defendant's gains will allow a much bigger recovery, or is the plaintiff's only way to recover at all. > Restitution is the great overlooked topic in American private law. In this country most students can't learn about it even if they want to; few schools teach the subject. Students only hear about restitution as the name of an occasional remedy in contract cases. But restitution is the name of a claim, not just a remedy. So lawyers often overlook restitution and sometimes try to use tort and contract to solve problems that restitution law would handle better. Missing or misunderstanding the right to go after a defendant's gains can be a very expensive oversight. ( https://reason.com/volokh/2014/10/27/restitution-law-interesting-an/ https://reason.com/volokh/2014/10/27/restitution-law-interes... ) Here we see a brief mention of Jesse Ventura's novel (in 2014) legal strategy of including a claim for unjust enrichment in his defamation suit: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2014/11/28/jesse-ventura-v-american-sniper-unjust-enrichment-as-a-remedy-in-defamation-cases/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/201... (From the piece: "The jury awarded plaintiff $500,000 for defamation, and $1,345,477.25 on the unjust enrichment theory.") Why would he do that, if it were just part of how all torts are handled? What would be unusual about it? (And why would Ward Farnsworth introduce the subject by pointing out that "tort claims and restitution claims are opposite things"?)
- darth_avocado 4y agoIt’s not about what the reputation was worth, it is about what he made off it. The point of the justice system is to set a precedent, if the damages are too low, you just set a precedent where lawsuits are just business expenses and you can still make money off these things.
- bachmeier 4y ago> These aren't punitive damages I don't see anything indicating this in the linked article.
- tptacek 4y agoPunitive damages in Connecticut civil cases are awarded in a later phase of the case. The jury recommends that punitive damages be assessed, and the number is worked out later. These are compensatory damages.
- phillipcarter 4y agoThe beauty of the US court system is he has every right to challenge it if he feels it's not appropriate.
- bachmeier 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punitive_damages https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punitive_damages
- tptacek 4y agoAgain: these aren't punitive damages.
- polotics 4y agoComparable damage? Can you imagine your young daughter one days goes to school, never comes back because she bled to death in a corridor there, and then for years you get attacked by strangers claiming you made it all up and are a fake? One thing I really don't understand about the US of A is, while it is abominously violent, still, a pork like Alex Jones hasn't been physically attacked by anyone. It's like there's a complete split in society somehow. In my books comparable damage would be everything and all money he owns, plus any he will, minus maybe $9 per day. Couldn't the jury have voted for such a verdict, why does it have to be an amount, why not an "everything"?
- nazka 4y agoYou forgot maybe the most horrible of all this. You create a website and through ads and sells you make a ton of money out of it.
- voisin 4y agoIsn’t that what it will amount to? He’ll declare bankruptcy and everything he’s got will go to settling some fraction of these lawsuits.
- nextaccountic 4y agoNow, suppose that he tries to hide some assets to not pay what he owes. In this case he can be on the hook even after bankruptcy
- voisin 4y agoI think his greatest asset is his personality and following, and he’ll be able to monetize that post-bankruptcy. The longer he drags out the court cases, the longer he delays that, so hopefully he just gets on with him and pays out everything he has.
- jacobolus 4y agoHe was just on his live show telling viewers to send money without worry: nothing they sent now would ever go to these families because he is declaring bankruptcy. Whatever bankruptcy judge he ends up before might not be amused by such antics.
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoAre punitive damages not allowed in libel cases?
- tptacek 4y agoThey are, they're just usually handled in a separate phase. In CT, judges apparently work them out after a jury recommends that punitive damages get handed out; in TX, the jury deliberates twice, once for compensatory and once for punitive damages.
- kazinator 4y agoOne issue is that the defendant not only inflicted damages, but ran a business which profited from the same activity.