3 ms·
It's not just "saying something is a hoax". It's deliberately lying, for years, for his own profit, in a way that caused significant amounts of damage to the p
by AnimalMuppet 4y ago
It's not just "saying something is a hoax". It's deliberately lying, for years, for his own profit, in a way that caused significant amounts of damage to the people he was lying about. Should that be free from consequences?
No. No, it should not be.
And, since there was profit from the lying, shouldn't the damages be greater than the profit from the lies?
Yes. Yes, it should be.
- carabiner 4y agoKind of an aside, but this theatric style of writing is irritating to read on HN. It also confuses the point here: Jones's payment isn't about what "should" be done based on personal morals, but what is dictated by law, and that is what GP is asking and the question you are ignoring.
- anigbrowl 4y agoLaw is a heuristic, justice still involves moral reasoning.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoWell, the question of law was already decided. And, legally, I'm pretty sure (but IANAL) that "deliberately lied", "repeatedly", "for profit", and "causing harm" were very relevant in deciding how much the fine should be. (Except, as entiex pointed out, that this was only compensatory, not punitive. Still... the harm went on and on and on for the families, as the lies went on and on and on. Is that allowed to be figured into the amount of compensatory damage? I think so.) My overall point: It wasn't just "saying something is a hoax". It was much more than that, and therefore the damage is much more, so the fine is much more, and justly so.
- wara23arish 4y agoare we holding all news to the same account regarding deliberate lying for profit? i hate double standards
- rootusrootus 4y ago"But whatabout..." Yes, we should everyone accountable for slander & libel. Even journalists.
- nobody9999 4y ago> are we holding all news to the same account regarding deliberate lying for profit? >i hate double standards Aren't we? Please provide examples of actual defamation (i.e., lies that were known to be lies, that caused damage to the subject of those lies) that haven't been the subject of legal proceedings? Edit: Changed "libel" to "defamation" to be more inclusive as to give you more opportunity to provide examples.
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoPeople are constantly suing for defamation [1]. The Jones trials entered the public imagination because he's a character and his defense was clownishly incompetent in a way that takes no legal training to laugh at. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-08-05/alex-jones-to-pay-sandy-hook-parents-in-defamation-case-5-other-cases-to-know?srnd=premium https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-08-05/alex-jone...
- jmull 4y ago> are we holding all news to the same account regarding deliberate lying for profit? Yes. You can sue news media companies under the same laws Alex Jones was sued. People do it all the time.
- bsder 4y agoSadly, no. Liars on CNN get fired. Plaigiarists at the New York Times get fired. Let's contrast this to ... say ... Fox "News". Oh, wait, Fox testified in court that they weren't news. Sorry, my fault.
- o_1 4y agoIs this a cable news doesn't lie pitch? Or is this just another 1sideism?
- entiex 4y agoThese are compensatory, not punitive damages. The only relevant factor is how the victims were impacted. Jones' level of wealth or the profit he gained from lying are both improper and injust to consider in the context of compensatory damages.