3 ms·
I'm going to be somewhat direct here. I allege that what Paypal is doing here (holding funds over 10 days) is illegal. In order to do what Paypal does in the
by TheAmazingIdiot 15y ago
I'm going to be somewhat direct here.
I allege that what Paypal is doing here (holding funds over 10 days) is illegal.
In order to do what Paypal does in the USA, you need licensure. They point out that they are not a bank. Indeed, they aren't: in many states they are classified as a money transmitter. In 8 states, they have no license to operate.#1
And, Indiana also requires licensure for money transmission. IC 28-8-4-20 (a) A person may not engage in the business of money transmission without a license required by this chapter.
What is this money transmitter stuff? In essence, the law in all the locales I have checked (I have not gone through every one), indicate only a short holding period (5-15 days) and only allow holding of money of a known crime.
So indeed what they do is absolutely fraudulent. In other words, if you have a patent troll corporation with many lawyers, target Paypal for their illegal behavior.
#1 Source: https://www.paypal-media.com/state_licenses.cfm https://www.paypal-media.com/state_licenses.cfm
- thinkcomp 15y agoIndiana has an unwritten policy of only requiring licenses of companies with a physical presence in the state. Other states (Massachusetts, South Carolina, Montana and New Mexico) do not require licenses for domestic money transmission at all. The other three have likely determined that PayPal does not meet the criteria for licensure in that state. PayPal may very well be exceeding the holding period threshold in some states, but someone would have to bring suit to push the issue.
- jahewson 15y agoHowever, Regretsy are dealing with EU PayPal, which is regulated as a bank in Luxembourg. No idea what the rules are there...