I agree. I'm in an applied computational field, that attracts a lot of computational and mathematical researchers that don't have knowledge of the applied syste

I agree. I'm in an applied computational field, that attracts a lot of computational and mathematical researchers that don't have knowledge of the applied system. I've learned from experience that often researchers new to the field make a whole lot of poor assumptions and modeling decisions, even if the mathematical part is fine. For better or worse, I'm going to more heavily scrutinize the details of a paper from a lab I haven't heard than I am one that I believe has a strong track record. That doesn't mean I'll give a pass for the latter, I'll still read it with a critical eye. But certain types of trust build up over time.