2 ms·
> Linux in production as a people org is definitely NOT anarchistic by any definition I can muster because Linus _is_ the head honcho - it is not a freely assoc
by sph 4y ago
> Linux in production as a people org is definitely NOT anarchistic by any definition I can muster because Linus _is_ the head honcho - it is not a freely associated group skeptical of authority
I disagree. This is not my definition of anarchy.
But the problem with anarchy itself is that it's such a vast subject there is no real and singularly accepted definition. So it tends to create a lot of small subtheories anyone can freely subscribe to. That's very anarchic :-)
In fact this underlines my point and my disagreement with you: anarchism is being free to choose. The kernel, being free software, is anarchistic. You're not free to direct and overrule Linus, but you're free to become your own Linus and fork the kernel.
Commercial software does not allow to do that, because of the existence of copyright, patents and intellectual property laws.
I agree that it is fascinating to explore those ideas, especially in a tech and "capitalist" context like this one. Far too much anarchist theory is based upon a rejection of technology and monetary incentives, which I think are not at all incompatible.
- elliotec 4y agoOk, I'm going to mince words here because they're important for this topic. Anarchy does not equal and must not be confused with Anarchism. At the risk of sounding condescending, which truly isn't my intention, I'd strongly encourage you to read the respective Wikipedia pages to get a better sense of the definitions that actually are shared and understood. Nuances abound but the foundations are clear and widely accepted. By these definitions, Linux as a people organization can't be anarchistic. Since Anarchism/Anarchy are states of societal organizations, "software" as a concept also can't really be anarchistic, even if it can be governed as such. Anyway, I completely agree that commercial software does not have the same capability for the reasons you describe, and I also agree that much thought and time are wasted in anarchist thought on the rejection of technology and monetary incentives and more people should talk about the practical application here!