4 ms·
> It takes ~100x as much water to grow a tomato as ends up in the final tomato. Is that a problem? If it takes 100 times as much water to grow as ends up in th
by yjftsjthsd-h 4y ago
> It takes ~100x as much water to grow a tomato as ends up in the final tomato.
Is that a problem? If it takes 100 times as much water to grow as ends up in the final tomato, then that implies that the other 99 parts went back into the local environment, doesn't it? I would have naively assumed that the local ecology was really only upset when people export water containing products across the country
- Cerium 4y agoExport is one issue, but pumping from an aquifer and then rejecting into the atmosphere is another.
- thehappypm 4y agoNope, most of the water just evaporates. Plants are great at moving water from the soil to the air.
- lhorie 4y agoIsn't that water vapor still going to be in the local environment? Is the argument here that farm plants somehow prevent water from reaching aquifers (at that 100x magnitude) that would otherwise reach them? If so, how?
- Manu40 4y agoI think the problem with evaporation being made a point of by the GP is that ultimately the water cycle isn't definite on where it will put that water back. Water vapor can travel great distances to the point where the vapor in the breath you exude right now could end up in someone else drinking water some days or years from now, on another continent. But ultimately no, the water doesn't just disappear forever. It just moves to a new location. That is, unless you are doing things that literally split the bonds of the molecules and revert it from being water at all. But that's a whole other level of discussion. (And it's why I am against any form of energy that requires splitting water to create hydrogen. I would much rather we just put our efforts into going to space to collect the hydrogen there instead. Taking it from sea water is, in my honest opinion; extremely foolish.)
- space_fountain 4y agoWell anything you do with the hydrogen turns it back into water
- Manu40 4y agoI mean, assuming you are combusting it in a oxidizing reaction maybe, sure. But then, hydrogen peroxide isn't exactly water. Too much oxygen added isn't exactly what we want, I would assume.
- puffoflogic 4y agoIn air, the combustion product of H2 is considered to be water, not hydrogen peroxide.
- Manu40 4y agoSorry if I was confusing, but I was implying that just adding oxygen doesn't = water always. 5 oxygen = Hydrogen Peroxide, not water. Yes, I understand that if you combust hydrogen in just a basic oxygen reaction you will get water; but not everything is as basic as that. Plus, the atmosphere itself is not "just oxygen". There is also nitrogen, methane, and more I am not sure of which to list here; but they are there. In fact, I am so sure of my opinion on this, I just did a quick google search on the idea of "does combusting hydrogen always produce water" to be as fair as possible to all parties. And the answer is no. At least according to these people, and other links can be found as well if you use the same search term. https://www.cleanegroup.org/hydrogen-hype-in-the-air/#:~:text=%E2%80%9CUnlike%20fossil%20fuels%2C%20which%20emit,Answer%3A%20false https://www.cleanegroup.org/hydrogen-hype-in-the-air/#:~:tex.... Sorry if I seem pedantic, but I am used to these sorts of things being the case, because society has a bad habit of misleading the public to get them on board with 'new' ideas. Hence my commentary. Here is an excerpt: "The bad news is that H2 combustion can produce dangerously high levels of nitrogen oxide (NOx). Two European studies have found that burning hydrogen-enriched natural gas in an industrial setting can lead to NOx emissions up to six times that of methane (the most common element in natural gas mixes).[17],[18] There are numerous other studies in the scientific literature about the difficulties of controlling NOx emissions from H2 combustion in various industrial applications." I highly suggest every single person who supports Hydrogen as a fuel source to consider what they are claiming in the link provided. They provide many sources for their claims, and I might add... it makes sense. Unlike "All hydrogen combustion in atmosphere produces only water." Now to be fair to you all, I would have been better off to use the Nitrogen Oxide example, but to be quite honest, I kind of missed that part too. Hence my example using hydrogen peroxide instead, since technically a oxygen rich environment could theoretically produce it (i think). And just in case that's not a good enough source for whoever: https://pubs.rsc.org/en/content/articlepdf/2021/ea/d1ea00037c#:~:text=The%20burning%20of%20hydrogen%20can,the%20combustion%20of%20fossil%20fuels https://pubs.rsc.org/en/content/articlepdf/2021/ea/d1ea00037....
- daniel-cussen 4y ago
- Aperocky 4y agoNot really, once it evaporates into the upper atmosphere it goes where the weather cycles it to. That's why you have places with incredible evaporation and far less rainfall over water, if the water stayed local you'd expect that rainfall and evaporation to be roughly the same over large lakes and ocean, however that is not the case locally.