6 ms·
New York changes gun buyback after seller gets $21,000 for 3D-printed parts
- rahimnathwani 4y agoThis reminds me of the cobra effect: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perverse_incentive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perverse_incentive
- ckk175 4y agoThe term cobra effect was coined by economist Horst Siebert based on an anecdote of an occurrence in India during British rule. The British government, concerned about the number of venomous cobras in Delhi, offered a bounty for every dead cobra. Initially, this was a successful strategy; large numbers of snakes were killed for the reward. Eventually, however, enterprising people began to breed cobras for the income. When the government became aware of this, the reward program was scrapped. When cobra breeders set their now-worthless snakes free, the wild cobra population further increased.
- elromulous 4y agoExactly! I came here to post this.
- tromp 4y ago> He called the idea of buybacks “ridiculously stupid”, adding that “the people running this event are horribly uneducated about guns, gun crime and the laws surrounding the regulation of guns”. I can see that offering more money than the cost of production is ridiculously stupid, as it just leads to unlimited production. But how is it stupid when all offers are below cost?
- happyopossum 4y ago> how is it stupid when all offers are below cost? That was his point - in this age of 3d printed and CAM'd gun parts, the cost of production is extremely low. He was getting $450 for a sear - a very small part. Even their rule changes don't fix this - for that kind of $$ I could have hundreds of those CAM'd or even 3d printed in metal, and use the $$ to pay for a decent chunk of a production shop.
- itsyaboi 4y agoJust a heads up: those are wildly illegal to manufacture. The few sears grandfathered in (legal to own/sell) are worth $20k+. This man risked a life sentence in federal prison driving around with a ziploc bag full of those things. Trivial to 3D print, or file down a piece of scrap metal into the right shape. Just goes to show how inane gun laws can be.
- scottiebarnes 4y ago> This man risked a life sentence in federal prison driving around with a ziploc bag full of those things. How do you get the parts to the buyback program if you can't drive to them?
- jahnu 4y agoUnder the speed limit I assume
- MichaelCollins 4y agoIt's not the driving part. He risked federal prison for even making them.
- hajile 4y agoWhich is ridiculous. You can carve one out of sheet metal in a couple minutes. This won’t stop evil people. Even worse, a self centering punch and 5 seconds can turn your AR-15 into an illegal automatic weapon as far as the ATF is concerned (just punch approximately where the auto pin would go). The only people affected by these garbage laws are the ones who aren’t interested in harming anyone.
- prvit 4y ago> You can carve one out of sheet metal in a couple minutes. This won’t stop evil people You can murder a person with the same level of effort. The only people affected by these garbage laws against murder are the ones who aren’t interested in harming anyone.
- LorenPechtel 4y agoThe reality is that buybacks only get worthless guns and the occasional gun that has been sitting around for ages. Crime guns only go to the buybacks if they're in such poor shape they're not worth the buyback amount.
- incahoots 4y agoSo the guy who sold these ghost guns drove from a different state to sell these guns, in an attempt to "gotcha" the buyback program? I mean fine, you don't care for the buy back or support the idea of forfeiting your firearms but what did he intend to prove by doing this? I'm more surprised he was allowed to sell firearms with an out of state license or no proof of living within the state.
- apwheele 4y agoThe way that these programs work, it is no questions asked (intended to get even criminals to turn in firearms, to prevent them from using in future crimes/suicides). So a "show ID to turn in" policy is a non-starter. Shameless promotion, but even absent such gaming I am quite skeptical these are cost-effective, https://andrewpwheeler.com/2022/08/21/gun-buy-back-programs-probably-dont-work/ https://andrewpwheeler.com/2022/08/21/gun-buy-back-programs-.... Making it so they only take working handguns, and if the gift cards were more on the order of $25-$50 makes it a more palatable to me from a cost-benefit perspective. But still evidence they actually work is pretty slim.
- incahoots 4y agoI won't argue with you on the effectiveness of a gun buyback because when Australia did it in 03 the follow up report determined that whilst yes, 70k firearms were removed from the population this didn't seem to curb gun crimes to a lower level prior to the buyback. https://www.ojp.gov/ncjrs/virtual-library/abstracts/australian-firearms-buyback-and-its-effect-gun-deaths https://www.ojp.gov/ncjrs/virtual-library/abstracts/australi...
- lithos 4y agoAustralia's gun buy back could be considered a real political compromise, if you're willing to consider no one is happy with the results. IE total gun owners lowered from 6 percent something to half that. Number of guns per owner went considerably up, and total guns imported each year is higher than it's ever been. Basically when you see an extreme (American) view on gun control trying to use Australia as an argument for their policy, you should just laugh at them. The numbers are so "inconclusive"/"manipulatable" that such a view can use the numbers to say whatever they want to their own uncritical base.
- MichaelCollins 4y ago> James’ office said it responded to the loophole by giving buyback personnel more discretion to determine the value of weapons being handed in, [...] Paying fair market value for the guns is the solution. Asking for gun donations without paying for them is another. If they do either of these, then the shenanigans stop. > and setting a standard that all 3D-printed guns accepted by the program must be capable of being fired more than once. This is dumb and will be ineffectual at stopping shenanigans. If they did even a minute of research they would know this new rule won't help. The people 'pranking' these buyback programs can and do make extremely cheap guns that are made out of metal pipe and can fire more than once: https://www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2014/12/22/5-homemade-shotguns-handed-100-gun-give-back/ https://www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2014/12/22/5-homemade-sh... If you want to stop that, pay fair market value for the guns. Homemade guns have essentially zero market value, so stop paying people to make them.
- mizzack 4y ago> pay fair market value for the guns. Seeing a P38 on the table next to a $100 HiPoint in the article photo drives this home. That's a $1k+ relic that the seller probably got $150 for.
- tablespoon 4y ago> Paying fair market value for the guns is the solution. Asking for gun donations without paying for them is another. If they do either of these, then the shenanigans stop. But both of those suggestions may undermine the real motivations for these programs, especially the second one.
- chomp 4y agoYep. You want to pull guns out of the population that people don't care about enough to where they're willing to trade them for a cheap gift card. The people who'd actually participate in this program likely do not covet the weapons enough to protect and keep up with them, which are more likely to be stolen, or mishandled.
- MichaelCollins 4y ago
- lemcoe9 4y agoAs federally-licensed firearms manufacturer (FFL07/SOT02), I can attest to how straightforward and even downright "easy" it is to create numerous firearms and firearm parts of varying legality. On the "not so illegal" side you have pistol slides, custom triggers, accessory railings, etc. that are all completely-legal to make, possess, sell, use, etc. It would be like 3D-printing a new case for a desktop computer. On the other hand, you have things like removable drop-in auto-sears (RDIAS) [1], Glock selector switches [2], MP5 auto-sears, AR15 -> M16 conversion jigs, handmade silencers (suppressors) [3], and numerous other components that not only require a federal license to create/possess/use, but also require a special taxpayer status called an SOT (Special Occupational Taxpayer) [4] because all of the aforementioned items are construed as machine guns (even if the device merely converts a firearm to a machine gun, and of course silencers) under the National Firearms Act of 1934 [5], and later clarified with the Gun Control Act of 1968 [6]. In addition to those items, NFA also deals with short-barrel rifles (rifles with barrels under 16 inches in length) and short-barrel shotguns (shotguns with barrels under 18 inches in length) which are incredibly easy to "accidentally" own. However, the largest firearms loophole in the country is that by attaching a "pistol brace" to an otherwise regulated short-barrel rifle, you are in compliance. Hundreds of thousands of Americans are currently in violation of the National Firearms Act of 1934 because they possess these short-barrel AR-15's. The differences between these two configurations are strikingly and laughably small [7]. Especially with the machine gun parts, the idea of governments/municipalities expecting citizens to simply surrender them - even for "fair market" value - is simply absurd and altruistic. Fun Fact: You yourself (in most states) can own a fully-automatic firearm! The only catch is that it has to be manufactured before May 1986, be registered under NFA, and transferred to you on an ATF Form 4 (which requires a $200 tax stamp [the same as it cost in 1934] and around 210+ days of waiting). These are known as "transferable machine guns" and are quite valuable despite their almost-identical resemblance to their semi-automatic counterparts. Here are some for sale: https://otbfirearms.com/nfa/transferable-machine-guns/ https://otbfirearms.com/nfa/transferable-machine-guns/ [1] https://www.recoilweb.com/turning-your-ar-15-into-an-m-16-150631.html https://www.recoilweb.com/turning-your-ar-15-into-an-m-16-15... [2] https://buybestguns.com/product/semi-full-auto-glock-handgun-switch/ https://buybestguns.com/product/semi-full-auto-glock-handgun... [3] https://solventtrapsdirect.com/ https://solventtrapsdirect.com/ [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_Occupational_Taxpayers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_Occupational_Taxpayers [5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Firearms_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Firearms_Act [6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_Control_Act_of_1968 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_Control_Act_of_1968 [7] https://www.guns.com/news/reviews/ar-pistol-vs-ar-rifle-what-should-you-pick https://www.guns.com/news/reviews/ar-pistol-vs-ar-rifle-what...
- prvit 4y agoBrave, the federal government could go down on him hard for manufacturing and transporting those parts.
- not_really 4y agoTransporting? Maybe. Manufacturing? Nope. He has the right to do so.
- donavanm 4y agoNo. Manufacturing NFA items without a completed and approved form 1 is a felony. IIRC most NFA items also need ATF preapproval before crossing state lines. This was Bad Idea City.
- hellojesus 4y agoYeah, but those are unconstitutional laws to begin with. Feds are probably smart to let this go, least they end up with a new Supreme Court precedent.
- countvonbalzac 4y agoThese sorts of ineffective programs are what we get when we can't pass common sense gun safety measures in this country.
- spicyusername 4y agoWhat about gun buyback programs makes you view them as ineffective?
- primax 4y agoTo add to this, when we did our gun buyback in Australia plenty of homemade guns were handed in to rort the system. But it worked
- LorenPechtel 4y agoThe problem is that the "common sense" gun safety measures are either stealthy gun bans or useless. Or both.
- hellojesus 4y ago2A all day
- IYasha 4y agoThanks a lot, mysterious man! For being such a dick.