8 ms·
Yeah, no one uses plain sms messages across the pond any more. And sms group chats? I only know about sms group chats from US posters. You can just assume eve
by nottorp 4y ago
Yeah, no one uses plain sms messages across the pond any more.
And sms group chats? I only know about sms group chats from US posters.
You can just assume everyone has Whatsapp here, and just message them over that.
- ericmay 4y ago> You can just assume everyone has Whatsapp here, and just message them over that. Yea but that's a problem too.
- scatters 4y agoWhatsApp doesn't have anywhere near the same lockin as Apple. You can run multiple messaging apps even on a low end android phone.
- kube-system 4y agoLock-in through the network effect is lock in. The fact that it’s the de facto standard outside the US is quite a network effect. SMS by contrast is an open standard.
- ericmay 4y ago> Lock-in through the network effect is lock in. Exactly. If your complaint is about being locked in but the platform you use is the one everyone has to use because of network effect or otherwise you yourself are locked in with that platform.
- scatters 4y agoThe network effect only results in lock-in if there's an obstacle to using multiple networks at the same time. Obviously no-one is going to carry around two phones, so that's how Apple achieves lock-in. By contrast, keeping two or more messaging apps running is trivial. And SMS is irrelevant.
- kaba0 4y agoSMS is just terrible though, and is just not worth using. It is plain text, limited in size and simply has less features.
- kube-system 4y agoWhat anyone means when they say SMS post ~2010 is SMS/MMS
- kaba0 4y agoIt didn't get better.
- kube-system 4y agoThat's just like, your opinion, man. SMS/MMS is decentralized, open, and works on every modern mobile phone out of the box. No other text messaging technology does this yet.
- kaba0 4y agoOpen for Verizon to read/modify, you have no way of knowing the other half’s identity (was their number given to someone else in the meanwhile), no encoding is specified/due to non-ASCII characters taking more SPACE (in 2022) so auto-SMSs still today will just force ascii text, making it often unreadable. Like, it is literally a single digit number of bytes difference. Also, you need like.. a carrier plan to access, wouldn’t really call that open. Any network based messenger can work over my home or even McDonald’s wifi, without any third-parties
- peapicker 4y agoI get what you’re saying but your home or McDonalds wifi is decidedly a third party, although encryption may mitigate that.
- ericmay 4y agoDid you mean WhatsApp doesn't have anywhere near the same lock in as the Messages app? I don't know what you mean by "same lock in as Apple". I also don't know what you would mean by lock in with the Messages app. What's locked in? I can use WhatsApp, Signal, Telegram, WeChat, or any number of communication apps on my iPhone effortlessly.
- scatters 4y agoApple's messages app isn't really an app; it comes preinstalled on the phone, you can't remove it or substitute it with another app, and you can't install it on non-Apple hardware. The lock-in is obvious: if you're part of Apple-oriented chat groups you can't switch to Android without losing access to those groups, degrading the experience for everyone, or convincing each one of those groups to make the switch to a multi-platform alternative. Claiming not to see this is disingenuous.
- ericmay 4y ago> Apple's messages app isn't really an app; it comes preinstalled on the phone, you can't remove it or substitute it with another app, and you can't install it on non-Apple hardware. I'm not sure, but I don't think you can actually uninstall the default SMS from Android phones either without having another app installed at a minimum and then I bet similar to Messages if you were to somehow uninstall that app then the default app would appear since it's probably part of the core operating system (similar to other basic functionality like settings or a phone app to receive calls). I don't know what you mean by you cannot substitute Messages with another app. If I didn't want to use Messages I would just disable all settings and remove it from the home screen and use whatever I wanted instead just fine. You are correct that you cannot install Messages on non-Apple hardware. Not all software is open source or available for all platforms. For example I cannot install Playstation software on my Xbox, nor can I buy a Nest Thermostat and install a competitor's software on it (without hacking both of course). There are games that are made that aren't created with support for macOS. Etc. > if you're part of Apple-oriented chat groups you can't switch to Android without losing access to those groups What is an Apple-oriented chat group?
- checkyoursudo 4y agoI can run WhatsApp on my iPhone. I cannot get my kids' school parents-group not to use WhatsApp. It was a pain to get even my best friends in Europe to use anything except WhatsApp.
- stevedzreams 4y agoWhat did you propose as the alterntive?
- scatters 4y agoWell done that parents' group. Obviously something like Signal would be better, but that'll happen once there's enough social consensus.
- ls15 4y agoMeanwhile, I am lighting a candle for every poor soul that has been pressured into installing Meta products.
- criddell 4y agoIs WhatsApp open? Are there alternative clients?
- scatters 4y agoEven better: it's a player in a competitive market. So you can switch your chats one-by-one to Signal, Telegram or whatever floats your boat.
- criddell 4y agoWhat do you mean by switch your chats. You can’t have the chat in more than one client at a time?
- scatters 4y agoYes, that's why it's switching.
- ls15 4y agoI am glad that the EU actually has another definition of letting people use what is floating their boat: Force big-tech player to open up protocols, so users can send messages from any messenger to any other messenger. https://techcrunch.com/2022/03/24/dma-political-agreement/ https://techcrunch.com/2022/03/24/dma-political-agreement/ As a user I cannot see any downsides.
- taylodl 4y agoUsing Facebook to do messaging? No thanks! Sure, when communicating with international friends I use WhatsApp because that appears to be what the rest of the world uses, but here in the States? No. We don't trust Zuckerberg. And yes, iMessage group chats are very much a thing here in the States and SMS group chats in general. And also yes, there's always that techie friend with an Android and makes your whole conversation go "green." Thing is, only middle schoolers really seem to care. I just know it means the communication isn't secured end-to-end.
- brokenkebab2 4y agoI didn't like FB well before it became fashionable, but I don't understand your logic here: what is that exactly that you can't entrust WhatsApp to send, but you can trust Apple, or your mobile carrier?
- ar_lan 4y agoI'm not really answering your question, but in the States, there is a lot more trust placed in Apple over Facebook. This isn't that surprising - Apple has a much stauncher stance on privacy than alternatives. I wish Signal would be more popular, but it's just not. I can't really ask new people I meet to communicate over Signal because it's a burden to get others to install some new application.
- nottorp 4y agoIm tired of super secure apps that ask for your phone number and even publish it to your contacts. Wake me up when Signal doesnt depend on a phone number any more.
- Dma54rhs 4y agoDMing on Instagram is super popular in USA. Most of the people don't give a shit about privacy to begin with.
- mmmlinux 4y agoFacebook's goal is to extract as much information from you as possible. Apple wants to sell you a new phone.
- alistairSH 4y agoHow do you message when you don't have wifi/data? I can SMS from more remote places than I can any internet-based service.
- coldtea 4y agoIn most of the world you do have either wifi or data coverage. Usually, if you don't have data for signal (as opposed to run out of data in your plan) reasons, then you don't have signal at all, even for SMS, either...
- bmicraft 4y agoI've never been anywhere where I legitimately had signal but no data. When it seems to be connected buy isn't, sms mostly also won't go though. I also think there are less "remote" places in europe in general.
- joecot 4y agoYou don't. But in the US I'm rarely in a place where I have no data but SMS still works. And Europe has more effective telecom service.
- culturestate 4y ago> Europe has more effective telecom service Some of Europe has very effective telecom infrastructure, but that's far from universal.
- dghughes 4y agoCries in Canadian :(
- culturestate 4y agoIt could be worse. Service is so famously bad in Germany that they invented a word for it - Funklochrepublik, which basically means "radio hole republic."
- reaperducer 4y agoYou can just assume everyone has Whatsapp here, and just message them over that. Trusting your private conversations to ~Facebook~ Meta is also a signal.
- nottorp 4y agoId rather not exclude people who dont have an iPhone, either because they cant afford it or believe Samsung marketing.
- mmcnl 4y agoEven iMessage is barely used. In The Netherlands, WhatsApp is king. And WhatsApp doesn't discriminate.