But they didn’t only give loans to business who were shut down. That’s the point. You claimed businesses got loans because the government forced them to close.

But they didn’t only give loans to business who were shut down. That’s the point. You claimed businesses got loans because the government forced them to close. I am saying that plenty of business that didn’t close (and saw record demand) sought and received loans. Nobody made them take out PPP loans. Once you acknowledge that, it looks a lot like student loans.