3 ms·
My "telling me what I want to hear" cognitive alarm bells are going off. On the other hand, this is simply the flip side of the frequently-heard argument aroun
by jerf 15y ago
My "telling me what I want to hear" cognitive alarm bells are going off.
On the other hand, this is simply the flip side of the frequently-heard argument around here that technology is driving people who can't cope out of the ability to hold a job at all, because they become unable to produce value in excess of what they cost. If that is true, then it follows that as the supply of people who can still be productive in the new economy drops, then they must also go up in price.
- shasta 15y agoI don't think that's right. If 50% of people became replaceable by robots, the other half doesn't become more valuable. Rather the value shifts to the robot owners. The article paints a simplistic picture, which is probably not correct even to first order, but it may be a useful viewpoint. The stratification should only increase, with the super devs obsoleting the ordinary code monkeys, but the time frame on that might be large.
- jerf 15y agoYou hypothesize an either-or where it's a both-and. The robot owners need somebody to program the robots, too, or they're expensive-yet-worthless hunks of metal. And if that talent is scarce compared to demand, the price is going to go up.
- shasta 15y agoMaybe I'm nitpicking, but I'd say that effect is due to an increase in demand for robot programmers, not due to a decrease in the supply of the productive workers.
- brc 15y agoThe value shifts to the robot developers. They are the ones that capture more of the value originally pooled by the entire workforce. The robot owners get value in that they can lower their prices because of the replacement of labour with robots, and overall, society benefits because whatever the robots are making is now less costly (ie, takes less of your own hours working to purchase). The key to understanding all of this is productivity. Most people tend to think in terms of raw job numbers, rather than productivity numbers. Employing robots results in a more productive economy because the same (or greater) amount of output is achieved with less human input. This does release labour from that activity, but it also creates opportunities in other areas, as the savings people make on purchasing the robot-cheaper goods can now spend in other areas, which should create jobs in other areas. Of course rapidly advancing technology produces lumps of unemployed which take time to retrain and redeploy themselves elsewhere, and it sucks to be that person. But eventually they will find employment, assuming something else isn't working against that (like oversized debt accumulation, which works against new enterprise creation by causing a negative investment flow, but that's another story)
- Djehngo 15y agoI had the same response w.r.t "telling me what I want to hear". After thinking about it there is an interesting notion in there. If you consider how the author may benefit from writing such a piece (as opposed to any other piece which would have resulted in him receiving the same payment). If we assume that hypothetically he is simply writing what developers like to hear, then it is likely that he is trying to curry favour with either a specific developer or developers in general. If he was trying to do that then it implies he sincerely believes what he wrote and therefore wasn't just writing what people might want to hear. Admittedly it does fall apart if it transpires if his motives were 100% financial, however I found the concept of a self-negating idea to be an interesting one.