2 ms·
If you're working on something super specialized when all your reviewers are the six other people who work on it then sure, it'll be unblinded. Not much we can
by jedberg 4y ago
If you're working on something super specialized when all your reviewers are the six other people who work on it then sure, it'll be unblinded. Not much we can do there sadly. But most people aren't working on something that specialized, and most would probably benefit from having reviewers in adjacent fields and not just the other experts in their field. So at least those adjacent ones would maybe be anonymous.