6 ms·
FirefoxOS was one of those hail-mary longshots that you always thought would be destined for failure but you had to respect the fact that they had the guts to a
by kibwen 4y ago
FirefoxOS was one of those hail-mary longshots that you always thought would be destined for failure but you had to respect the fact that they had the guts to attempt it anyway. (Though to be fair, Rust was the same sort of project, so sometimes long shots pay off.) It showed that Mozilla understood the existential risk of ceding control of the platform itself to your direct competitors. I'd love to see it come back and I'm sad that I never got my hands on one of the original phones.
- frozenport 4y agoLot of people got pissed off they wasted resources on it
- mumblemumble 4y agoAlthough, in fairness, that could be said of literally every project Mozilla has launched that isn't either a Web browser or MDN.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Gigachad 4y agoI think they have a pretty good future in web services. I'd be happy to pay for a mozilla password manager/vpn/email hosting/cloud storage. But for some reason they only sell the VPN and not in Australia.
- coffeeblack 4y agoThat’s a rebranded Mullvad VPN.
- OJFord 4y agoIf you want the VPN in Australia, you can get it directly from Mullvad - they do have servers there.
- Gigachad 4y agoYeah that's what I do. But I'd be happy to pay an all inclusive subscription to Mozilla for a full set of web services and drop my subscription to google and mullvad. But they just don't offer a product I can buy.
- ksec 4y agoThat is missing a lot of context. They wanted everything to be Javascript and running on a $50 Smartphone. ( I think initially it was even lower than $50, but they rise it to $50 a bit later ) If there was ever anything that show how Silicon Valley and Tech, the modern meaning of "Software people" with little to zero understand of hardware and supply chain. This is it. And Mozilla wasn't the only one, even Bill Gate said all hardware will eventually cost zero and be subsidised by running software and services. The lack of understanding of hardware and Supply Chain, even after COVID and in 2022 still greatly baffles me.
- leke 4y agoYep, that's why I grinded my teeth a bit when I read the post title. As a broke ass student back in the day, I counted my pennies to buy one of those devices. Even shilled it to my peers, some of whom also bought devices.
- throwaway559 4y agoInside Mozilla too. Some execs thought Firefox OS would never be competitive because Google could always make a cheaper Android phone that still supported the whole Android ecosystem. Others wanted to move desktop Firefox to maintenance mode and bet everything on Firefox OS.
- nicoburns 4y agoThey should’ve built a cross platform UI toolkit based on Servo, and built Firefox OS on top of that. That would have given it the efficiency it needed to be successful. They’d have taken a lot of market share very quickly if their apps could run on android/iOS too.
- mtrycz2 4y agoI owned a Firefox phone and it was awesome. It had understandably few apps, but it worked really well. One thing I really appreciated was that it was conceived as an appliance rather than as an attention grabber. We tolerate our phones being attention grabbers, but unrightfully so, it doesn't have to be this way. The default UI even had the saturation toned down, to not be so much in your face. It was pretty capable for an 80 Euro phone. It was the only smartphone I owned that I could feel vibrate in my pocket. I concede that Android ran better on it, but it's not like FirefoxOS ran bad, on the contrary. I unfortunately lost it, and it was about the time it was being discontinued. I would probably get another one. Heck, I would get one now, if they were still around. Anecdote: friend had a KaiOS and it was pretty aweful.
- hajile 4y agoKaiOS is based on FirefoxOS and sells more phones than Apple does.
- Bilal_io 4y agoThat's interesting. I went on their website and it was nostalgic browsing these phones.
- Tagbert 4y agoWhich phones use KaiOS?
- toast0 4y agoThere's a list on Wikipedia[1], not sure if it's complete; the company behind KaiOS has a list of devices too [2]. Important ones include the JioPhone, which was part of Jio's large push into the mobile market in India. There's also a nostalgic Nokia 8110 4G (Banana Phone); there's even some with modems appropriate for the US market. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KaiOS#Devices https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KaiOS#Devices [2] https://www.kaiostech.com/explore/devices/ https://www.kaiostech.com/explore/devices/
- Syonyk 4y agoAnyone want a Bananaphone? I tried to use it for a while, but AT&T shut down their 3G calling network and it doesn't have the radio for VoLTE, and AT&T isn't doing 4G calling - they jumped straight from 3G to VoLTE. It also doesn't do MMS for group texting. I'm easy enough to find, I can toss the thing in a box. On the plus side, I got a Flip IV out of it. I ran with it for a year or so before the keyboard got so bad I gave up - when you can't dial a phone number without having to correct multi-presses and such, texting is damned near impossible.
- BenjiWiebe 4y agoIsn't 4G calling and VoLTE the same thing? A 4G phone without VoLTE uses the 3G network when placing/receiving calls, hence why the 3G shutdown is causing pain even though non 4G phones are really rare these days.
- behnamoh 4y agoI miss Windows Phone. Used to have a Lumia 920. Sleek, rock solid phone that rarely crashed and always gave the impression that it will be there when I need it. Apps weren't great but still I was quite happy with a few. And I started to like the Tiles UI. Then the Microsoft-Nokia joke happened.
- blondin 4y agoi miss the Zune and its UI. was the Windows Phone's UI similar?
- behnamoh 4y agoNever used Zune. WinPhone's UI was similar to Windows 8 at the time (I think the term is Metro design language).
- chronogram 4y agoA little bit, yes. The scrolling menus were in the style of Zune, and the home screen was like that of Windows 8. It was fast and lag-free, no loading of UI elements, and all that on a dual core ARMv7 (I used the Samsung Ativ S).
- neoberg 4y agoA different generation of windows phones but I used HP Ipaq 514 back in the day and oh was it terrible to use.
- behnamoh 4y agoI think that was Windows Mobile which is different than Windows Phone.
- GordonS 4y agoI used to like the Windows Phone UX too, I had it on a few phones over a period of time back in the day. But, all of the phones I had used to crash pretty regularly, rock solid it was not! Still, I miss it!
- 4y ago
- warinukraine 4y ago
- mattl 4y ago> I'm sad that I never got my hands on one of the original phones. I was at Mozfest in London and they gave everyone a phone, that was in 2014 or 15, so I would be surprised i nobody still had one kicking around.
- mattl 4y agoWould love to know why this of all things was downvoted
- nibbleshifter 4y agoI had one of the original phones, used it for over a year because I was broke, it was free (work gave it to me), etc. It wasn't terrible, but it had a LOT of bizarre bugs and couldn't compete with even the cheapest Android (the kind that phone providers basically gave away for free at the time). It was better than the old Nokia Symbian S40 device I had though. I ended up moving to a super low end Android device that I got for free from a provider for porting my PAYG (prepaid) number to their service (also prepaid). I also used one of the Nokia Windows phones for about a year as a student. It was good for calls and SMS, but fuck all else worked. Ended up lending that to someone who lost it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- torginus 4y agoIt's strange to me that people would build a budget phone OS on top of web technologies - after all, web-based desktop software can grind full-fat tower PC to a halt. I can't imagine it working out for low-end mobile hardware.
- littlestymaar 4y agoFirefox OS was arguably bad (especially when they redesigned everything, breaking half of the features I used in the process) but it was surprisingly snappy given how underpowered the hardware was: I actually had two phones running Firefox OS, the GeeksPhone which ended up broken after a year and a 15 meters fight in a staircase, and then the Motorola one, both with very limited hardware and yet it never felt slow. My experience with Android always felt sluggish since then (given that I never buy expensive phones).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rockdoe 4y agoNothing forces you to write slow websites.