4 ms·
Whether you are getting a raise/promotion or not is determined by your manager during the year and finalized behind closed doors in calibration meetings. A hand
by paxys 4y ago
Whether you are getting a raise/promotion or not is determined by your manager during the year and finalized behind closed doors in calibration meetings. A handful of paragraphs in your performance review at the end of the year aren't really going to change that outcome.
> So, if everyone hates performance reviews why do we do them?
A formal performance review process is a requirement from legal, nothing more. The only part of it that actually matters is clicking the button stating that you have read and acknowledged your manager and peer feedback. That way if you sue the company later they have a paper trail defending themselves.
- smegsicle 4y agogood to know if true
- rahimnathwani 4y agoThis is not a universal truth.
- ejb999 4y ago>>The only part of it that actually matters is clicking the button stating that you have read and acknowledged your manager and peer feedback. That way if you sue the company later they have a paper trail defending themselves. I think your opinion is weak - if the review you get, doesn't actually outline problems you have in your performance, then how can it be a defense against firing someone? If I sign off on 5 years in a row of 'meets expectations' type of a review, then if anything, it makes it easier for me to claim that I am not being fired for a good reason (lets assume I am over 55 or a minority, or both, for example who could claim age or race discrimination). If you are a manager, and you want to get rid of somebody for poor performance - and you are afraid of getting sued - then you darn well better have a paper trail showing that the employee was warned in writing about specific deficiencies if you want to use that as a legal defense - having multiple years worth of 'meets expectations' that you signed off on, helps the employee getting fired to make the case that it is because of performance - and hurts the company trying to cover their ass. I also hate getting - and doing - employee reviews, but they are only valuable for a legal defense for wrongful termination, if the company did their job and documented everything properly along the way - its not just the sign-off that is important, its the paper trail of warnings.
- vkou 4y agoI disagree. > Whether you are getting a raise/promotion or not is determined by your manager during the year and finalized behind closed doors in calibration meetings. A handful of paragraphs in your performance review at the end of the year aren't really going to change that outcome. Those paragraphs aren't going to change what your manager thinks of you, but they are usually important in convincing the other managers in the calibration meeting that you deserve the rating your manager wants to give you. There's a few reasons for it: * Your manager may want to advocate for you, but didn't actually do a good job of putting their thinking into words. And gets slaughtered during cross-examination (calibration). * They serve as a reminder of all the important things you've done. Your manager may have forgotten some of them. (He's got a million balls to juggle, it's his job to remember, but people forget/make mistakes/prioritise the wrong things.) * They are a good prompt for your peers, when they provide peer reviews. (There's nothing I hate more than writing a peer review for someone who won't write anything about themselves.) In a perfect world where your manager has a photographic memory and an infallable ability to put what he knows about you into words, you wouldn't need to advocate for yourself, but we don't live in a perfect world.
- Volundr 4y ago> They serve as a reminder of all the important things you've done. Your manager may have forgotten some of them. I regularly give this tip to employees, but it applies to managers too: when you (or in this case one of your reports) accomplishes something notable, jot it down. For ICs this is great for resumes, performance reviews, compensation discussions, but it's also great for managers in most of the same areas. The only thing that tells your employees you see what they do and value them more than actually being able to discuss specifically what they've done and how it helped...is paying them more.
- giantg2 4y agoAre the other managers actually reviewing what we wrote? I'd be surprised. It's my experience that it doesn't matter what I write.
- pclmulqdq 4y ago
- kleinsch 4y agoFirst paragraph is true, but then it veers into silliness. I’ve worked at plenty of companies that do peer feedback and never signed anything. If they want to fire you, peer feedback leads to a PIP which is the actual documentation the legal dept needs to make sure you can’t sue. Having been in calibrations - managers need justification for their recommendations, both positive and negative. Quotes from peer feedback are one of the pieces they use. If they’re a decent manager, nothing in peer feedback is surprising, they just pull some quotes to back up what they already know.
- giantg2 4y ago"managers need justification for their recommendations, both positive and negative." But it can be kind of like with the law - if they want to get you, they will find something. The job descriptions are so high-level and aspirational they can find something wrong with anyone. The only real question is what cane to their attention, and if they'll ignore it or use it.
- opportune 4y agoThis is very Google-specific advice/terminology. It can be very different elsewhere
- joshuamorton 4y agoIt's also not true there at least historically.
- opportune 4y agoCorrect, the bit about acknowledging the rating for a paper trail is literally from the last month
- dilyevsky 4y agoWdym? Google didn’t invent this process. It was probably first introduced by the likes of ibm/msft a few decades earlier and then spread over entire industry by the way of mba osmosis
- tbrownaw 4y agoA formal review should just summarize (and record) what everyone already knows. Which is less useless than it sounds, since it's a way to verify that everyone's on the same page. And maybe also to make sure people don't just completely forget to think about things.
- closeparen 4y agoI have been in those calibration meetings. When it is a committee separate from the management chain, it can indeed be rule bound and checklist-driven, looking for evidence in the packet to justify each criterion in the rubric. With an org-level committee it’s less prominent since most people at the table already know the candidate and their work, but evidence from the packet does help to resolve disputes. For example if someone says, “I don’t think this person was doing X” and we can point to documented examples of X in the packet. Not everyone knows everything you do with all your time; the review cycle is partly a way to get credit for less visible efforts.