6 ms·
Performance reviews don’t assess performance
- hprotagonist 4y agoreviews answer two, and only two questions: - Does the company have enough money to give raises this year? - Does the company think you deserve a raise?
- majormajor 4y agoYeah, I've been at companies that did pretty well on continuous 1:1s and feedback, but off-cycle raises and promotions were still very rare because it simplifies a lot for the business to synchronize when budgeting and headcount-planning, etc, happens.
- giantg2 4y agoOff-cycle promotions can be fairly easy, but not in-place. With the constant churn in our line of work, an existing project may have a vacancy that's already budgeted for the higher level that left. Ar my company, in-place promotions are almost non-existent beyond entry to mid level.
- giantg2 4y agoTechnically, the answers to those two questions also answer a third: Should I leave?
- dasz 4y ago... when that question of should I leave becomes repetitive enough then the answer is usually then yes but not yet. The not yet part is really the warning that you need to prepare to leave or prepare to change. If you have doubts about staying then you also have no doubt that something is wrong.
- closeparen 4y agoEquity compensation has built in pay cuts. So they also ask if the company should maintain your total compensation or allow it to fall, in essence quietly and passively showing you the door.
- BlargMcLarg 4y agoMost of the advice only works in a scenario where there is symmetry in the power between managers and those they manage, or asymmetry in favor of those being managed. >There is a way to get quality performance data, on a weekly or bi-weekly basis, in a meaningful way on things that are most important to the organization. I'm very skeptical of this. Performance can very easily be gamed or influenced by the environment. Asymmetry between people even in the same team is a huge factor as to why performance reviews are complete bollocks in most skilled work.
- paxys 4y agoWhether you are getting a raise/promotion or not is determined by your manager during the year and finalized behind closed doors in calibration meetings. A handful of paragraphs in your performance review at the end of the year aren't really going to change that outcome. > So, if everyone hates performance reviews why do we do them? A formal performance review process is a requirement from legal, nothing more. The only part of it that actually matters is clicking the button stating that you have read and acknowledged your manager and peer feedback. That way if you sue the company later they have a paper trail defending themselves.
- smegsicle 4y agogood to know if true
- rahimnathwani 4y agoThis is not a universal truth.
- ejb999 4y ago>>The only part of it that actually matters is clicking the button stating that you have read and acknowledged your manager and peer feedback. That way if you sue the company later they have a paper trail defending themselves. I think your opinion is weak - if the review you get, doesn't actually outline problems you have in your performance, then how can it be a defense against firing someone? If I sign off on 5 years in a row of 'meets expectations' type of a review, then if anything, it makes it easier for me to claim that I am not being fired for a good reason (lets assume I am over 55 or a minority, or both, for example who could claim age or race discrimination). If you are a manager, and you want to get rid of somebody for poor performance - and you are afraid of getting sued - then you darn well better have a paper trail showing that the employee was warned in writing about specific deficiencies if you want to use that as a legal defense - having multiple years worth of 'meets expectations' that you signed off on, helps the employee getting fired to make the case that it is because of performance - and hurts the company trying to cover their ass. I also hate getting - and doing - employee reviews, but they are only valuable for a legal defense for wrongful termination, if the company did their job and documented everything properly along the way - its not just the sign-off that is important, its the paper trail of warnings.
- cgb223 4y agoI get this I’m currently in a situation where my large tech company has clear criteria to be promoted and I am already measurably doing all of the things the next level does Despite this, my manager says I won’t be promoted unless the other two people at the level above me “like” me So despite meeting our company’s exact requirements for promotion that they do to make the process “fair”, I am being held at my level indefinitely until two people decide they like me as a person Just ranting I guess. Not sure if anyone can relate / has advice here
- throwaway5752 4y agoMeeting the criteria for promotion is not an obligation to promote, and as you have seen it the criteria isn't always comprehensive. Maybe you are just leaving some details out, but many places have multiple candidates for promotion competing for a finite number of spots. Often, recommendations and sponsors are needed, and you need to cultivate those relationships. You have to get along well with your peers to get things done, it isn't unreasonable. I've been involved in the process elsewhere and just trying to give constructive feedback, since it's frustrating you. Can you elaborate at all on the type of promotion? If not, I can appreciate the need for venting.
- sthatipamala 4y agoAt big companies, leveling is sold as an objective/descriptive measure of one's skills. An engineer is at level L if and only if they meet the expectations at L. If you aren't at that level, it must be because you lack certain skills from the rubric. What you are saying is true but it contradicts that model. It acknowledges that leveling has extrinsic criteria such as finite number of spots.
- theGnuMe 4y agoIs it Goldman Sachs where everyone is a VP? At some point titles are meaningless. Leveling rubrics are to prevent mutiny and by definition amorphous. "Works effectively with others to deliver outcomes that... Earned the respect of peers who..."
- mustafabisic1 4y agoI love the article and agree with a lot of it, the only thing is that the action steps are a bit vague. It's especially challenging for teams who have a hard time finding measurable targets. Like the brand team and the content team in my company have a bit harder time finding the numbers. And although they have a great reputation and action steps, I can still imagine how it feels when everybody else lays out their numbers. P.S. I'm writing a weekly newsletter for remote-working parents. Check it https://thursdaydigest.com/ https://thursdaydigest.com/
- deepnet 4y agoI like the sound of your newsletter but sadly I am not seeing the pre-signup examples mentioned on the landing page so can't easily assess.
- jmyeet 4y agoThis is the most important sentence: > Performance reviews are riddled with bias. Let me describe the apocryphal big tech company performance review process. Once or twice a year you ask colleagues for feedback. Hopefully they do. They can also choose not to. You generally need 2-8 people to provide feedback. Less for a "standard" cycle. More for a promotion cycle. The specifics of this process vary from company to company (eg some reviewers might see your self-review, some processes just give textual feedback while others require reviewers to rate you in addition to supporting text). Your manager may then distill all this feedback into a single page. Some processes have the full packet. Others do not. Your manager will, based on this total packet, come up with a provisional rating and then go into calibration to argue your case. This provisional rating tends to be reasonably accurate. It may get argued down. It less often gets argued up (but it can happen). In this process you're essentially being stack ranked by similar employees (ie same job ladder and level). To avoid ratings inflation across orgs (typically 100-150+ people), you are graded on a curve. Only a few people can get Greatly Exceeds Expectations. Some will require a percentage to get subpar ratings (eg Meets Most Expectations). This is the tech company equivalent of cutting the bottom 5-10% every year. These people may end up on PIPs or may be effectively forced out of the company because people with subpar ratings can't transfer or new teams just don't want to gamble on them. Promotion decisions may be made by your org. They be made by committees of higher level individuals on your ladder (eg L5->L6 promotions decided by committees of L7/L8s). Promotion candidates are also effectively or actually stack ranked. As a cost-saving measure there are promotion targets. Only the top X% will get promoted. So how does this go wrong? 1. The number 1 most important thing is for your management team to like you. If they do, your failures will be viewed in a positive light (eg "we learned a lot from this failed project that we will take into future projects") as opposed to a negative light (eg same facts leading to "failed to ship project"). 2. If the influential people in your org don't like you, it's going to be an uphill battle to do well; 3. Managers are subject to the same forces so may curry favor by supporting certain candidates for pomotion and higher ratings over others. There is an awful lot of horse trading that goes on behind the scenes. You will see none of this; 4. To curve fit the org, after all calibration is done people will have their ratings changed (generally down). This is more likely to happen if the org doesn't like you or simply likes you less than someone else; 5. Promotion target percentages are a key cost control measure. Reducing it saves significant costs (eg Ruth Porat did this in a leaked memo when she became CFO at Google). This creates a backlog for pomotion. Standards go up. You have to "wait your turn" and this may take years. This limbo will often keep people around who don't want to leave to get more opportunities. 6. Meeting goals, a key issue in defining "impact", is highly subjective too. You may get an impossible task dumped on you, fail and get dinged for it while someone else gets some way easier goal. The whole process is honestly the worst part of working in big tech.
- at_a_remove 4y agoI had a boss who, well, you know how good bosses are supposed to be umbrellas and shock absorbers? He was the exact opposite. Whatever the fashion was in admin, he would go along with it. We got this whole song and dance from him a few years back about the new performance ratings that sounded not entirely unlike stack ranking, and that "five" was the max rating, but you would never get a five, but you were expected to be a five, despite that you wouldn't ever get a five, in this bizarre, self-negating informational tidbit. I saw the hot-shit new-ish hire start revising his resume behind his eyes.
- terramars 4y agoone of the reasons why tech culture has an 18-24 month half life at jobs... it's almost impossible to get a market competitive internal promotion. "not doing performance reviews" and only doing normal 1:1s + an occasional dive doesn't solve this problem at all. i've seen and been at plenty of places that do junior -> mid -> senior pipelines fine, but senior -> exec? it never happens despite external exec hires having extremely high miss rates and very high cost of miss. 100% blame this one on classism + unwillingness to trust people you know vs the shiny outsider.
- dilyevsky 4y agoThe lack of competitive raises is an hr problem (or sometimes some form of zba style budgeting) not a process problem
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bentlegen 4y agoPerformance reviews exist because they are an accountability mechanism by which senior leaders can go, “okay at least twice a year some kind of feedback is delivered to all employees from their manager”. Their effectiveness can be disputed (totally fair!), but my experience when they go away is that every manager does their own thing, and that leads to even worse outcomes because it’s harder to wrangle training, level alignment, and accountability out of ad-hoc periodic feedback (which will surely have varying degrees of frequency, depending on the manager).
- jaimebuelta 4y agoWhen I was in college, there was some surveys that evaluates the professors, by the students, in order to provide aggregated feedback and points for improvement. As one professor put it to us: “it’s pointless, the people that use it as feedback to improve are already good teachers because are using other ways to get better; and the ones that just ignore the surveys doesn’t care about any other way of improving. So the exercise is irrelevant” I think management is the same, good managers take frequent opportunities to give feedback, manage, and care for their managees, and fill a form that it’s already redundant. Bad managers fill a form once a year and ignore it the rest of the year. But, hey, we have a form that’s mostly ignored by everyone.
- bentlegen 4y agoI feel like good managers show up in these as evidenced by the quality of the feedback. It shows in the writing. If the manager hasn’t been doing their job, it’ll be apparent too. That’s been my experience on the other side of this. But I suppose plenty of directors, VPs, etc. can mail it in at this stage and probably do.
- NoPicklez 4y agoI'd say it depends where you work and if your company fosters failure and growth. Where I work I get a formally recorded performance assessment following each piece of work I deliver, which is usually in the range of 6-10 projects a year. Each of these projects is rated with strengths and weaknesses and if I was performing at the level required. This is then rolled up into my annual performance review, which is a review of the aggregate result of those, plus any other non-project related outcomes.
- mkl95 4y agoPeople are constantly joining and leaving my team and requirements change on a daily basis and are vague/fuzzy. If an environment like this, I'm not sure formal performance reviews even make sense. I get my shit done every week but whether it's good shit or not is very subjective. Whenever I get my performance review I will take it as a political statement.
- lsbehe 4y agoI hate this kind of article where something constantly moves. I can't scroll away one funny GIF without the next one appearing. What kind of person does this appeal to?
- teh_klev 4y agouBlock Origin is useful for snipping out these visual turds. But I agree, it's hugely irritating and the GIF's aren't even funny nor add any value.
- aposm 4y agoThe only people who actually do believe performance reviews (as they are practiced in the corporate world) genuinely measure performance... are the Dunning-Kruger'd tech bros who have convinced themselves tech is a "meritocracy" and they really deserve their positions.
- sattoshi 4y agoAre you saying most tech people don’t deserve their positions?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mensetmanusman 4y agoThese reviews provide legal protection in the event of a company being sued for wrongful termination. Once you realize that most things are to appease lawyers, the world seems more understandable.
- uptownfunk 4y agoUgh the moving memes make the article so annoying to read - who thought this was a good idea
- lathiat 4y ago“I’ve got to ding you on something” - Bryan Cantrill Worth a watch: https://youtu.be/1KeYzjILqDo https://youtu.be/1KeYzjILqDo
- fallingfrog 4y agoPerformance reviews are both terrifying and humiliating. They’re just a chance for the boss to remind you that he holds your whole means of survival in his hands and that your absolute obedience is necessary to not become homeless. Want to keep custody of your children? Want to have food? Want to have a roof over your head? Better jump when I say jump, worm. No matter what he might say, even if your performance was fine, that’s the context the conversation takes place in- fear, intimidation, and power. It’s not any fun.
- zimpenfish 4y agoApropos of nothing, that article is difficult to read with the short repeating GIFs. They'd have been better with static meme-format images. Also they take up 50-100% height of my browser window which is just wasteful. Give me words! Shove the memes to a sidebar or something.
- tumetab1 4y agoI think the most important part of the article is this > Spoiler alert: I’m going to try rolling this out at Workweek in the next few months. I’ll be sharing everything I learn with this group! Hoping my hypothesis that more touch points around performance will lead to happier and more engaged employees. Because I think it's easy to notice problems in the current processes but it's hard to create a new process that it's a net positive. In my current situation, I don't care about raises/bonus or my manager feedback, I only care about 360 feedback to get others perspective I think this is better done twice a year. This means that doing one-on-one meetings with ratings would be worse for me, a net negative. Also, I think that HR and executive management gets some good value from those twice a year rushes to fill "performance evaluation" forms so they also might think a different process might be a net negative. So, please experiment and tell us about it.