4 ms·
It's telling that this person posted a job listing, interviewed dozens of candidates, realized they couldn't proceed because they hadn't interviewed any minorit
by paxys 4y ago
It's telling that this person posted a job listing, interviewed dozens of candidates, realized they couldn't proceed because they hadn't interviewed any minority candidate, tried for months and were still unsuccessful at finding a single one, and the take away wasn't that they should fix their broken recruiting pipeline but that the corporate policy was what was wrong.
- thegrimmest 4y agoWhy do you suppose that a non-broken recruiting pipeline would result in more diverse candidates? Do you really think all candidate pools in all professions, and in all locations, are as diverse as the population at all times?
- guhidalg 4y agoI think this really varies for each position, but most SWE positions really don't require special skills beyond a CS degree from a 4-year program. Sure, there may be special industry knowledge that you need to know but I'm not talking about languages, frameworks, databases, etc... if you studied CS, I expect you to have the capacity to learn this shit. You can learn the problem domain in well enough in 6 months and rely on your PMs and boss to fill in the details. If you are truly in a domain where you cannot hire CS graduates, then D&I is going to put a lot of burden on your recruitment team to find candidates to meet slating requirements. But you probably aren't...
- colinmhayes 4y ago> Do you really think all candidate pools in all professions, and in all locations, are as diverse as the population at all times? No but I think you should be able to find a single minority candidate over the course of months.
- thegrimmest 4y agoWhy do you think so? I have a hard enough time finding a qualified candidate of any variety.
- telltruth 4y agoAt our school, 100% of teachers are women. One Hundred Percent. 97% of administrative staff is also women. In all of hair saloons in my area, 100% of staff is women. All of the nurses in our nearby hospital are women. They don't care about diversity and I do not think it is due to bias. I think they simply don't have enough men applying in their pipeline for these jobs. None of their CEOs have insisted in enforcing population statistics on to their employee statistics.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- andirk 4y agoMy friend works at PayP[redacted] and as a white female, _she_ was the minority hire. Somehow, in the SF Bay Area, almost all of their recruits that get to interview are [country of origin redacted]. It sounds like blatant discrimination, BUT if no one's complaining, is there an issue?
- sebazzz 4y ago> BUT if no one's complaining, is there an issue? Maybe no-one dares to complain, because it is easily perceived as racism.
- zozbot234 4y agoThe pipeline is clogged for everyone. Lack of diversity is an industry-wide issue which needs to be addressed throughout the industry and beyond, not a problem with recruiting at any single company.
- outside1234 4y agoI'm surprised they didn't do c) which was to interview an obviously unqualified candidate to get the checkoff on the policy. This is the usual workaround. There is no broken recruiting pipeline. There are simply not enough candidates in the pool to staff every company in a way that is representative.
- colpabar 4y agoI am ignorant when it comes to where companies look when they are hiring, but your comment makes it seem like companies can choose sources that are somehow segregated by race/gender/etc. What/where are these sources? Do you really think microsoft has any trouble finding people who want to work there? Where else should they look? In all my time being a straight white male, I've never listed my resume on a "whites only" job site.
- hardtke 4y agoThe author says he is in AI, and when I was hiring entry level ML engineers I had similar challenges. As much as we blame the recruiting pipeline, I think it is the educational pipeline that is not creating a sufficiently diverse talent pool. Part of it is "weed out" courses that adversely affect students from less privileged backgrounds[1]. An additional (perhaps controversial) opinion I have is that companies are so aggressive about their individual diversity goals that they often pluck students out of the training pipelines prematurely (e.g. courting Ph.D. students before they finish their dissertation). [1] https://www.brookings.edu/blog/brown-center-chalkboard/2021/07/26/whos-getting-pulled-in-weed-out-courses-for-stem-majors/ https://www.brookings.edu/blog/brown-center-chalkboard/2021/...
- csmpltn 4y ago> "they should fix their broken recruiting pipeline" This is trying to treat the symptoms, not the disease. You yourself say "they tried for months and were still unsuccessful at finding a single one". Why do you think that is? Whatever you're trying to solve - the "issue" starts decades earlier, at home. It's about how people are brought up, their access to education, their social environment. Culture actually plays a role, too.
- forgomonika 4y agoThat's part of the problem. The other part is the networks you are tapping into to find candidates. People tend to collect others that look, act, and think like them. That's one reason why people group up into subgroups that all have similar traits, past experiences, and belief systems. When it comes to a recruiting pipeline this is critical. If you are tapping members of your team to help finding candidates from their networks and your team lacks diversity, you are going to just build out your team with more of the same. The same goes for where you are looking for candidates outside of your team. If you are only targeting a small number of schools it's really easy to end up with a homogenized set to pull from. I know from experience working at some of the big tech powerhouses, they'd target a handful of schools and only hire college grads from there - which means they miss out on recruiting from state schools, historically black colleges, and other pockets where things are more diverse.
- csmpltn 4y agoBut here you have a multi-national corporation, with offices globally and ability to hire from any culture on the planet - and despite waiting months, actively searching for a "diverse" candidate, they were unable to find a single candidate who was "diverse" enough. What conclusions do you draw from this? That "people are racist"? That the pipeline is broken? This feels like ignoring the elephant in the room.
- Vinnl 4y ago> months, actively searching for a "diverse" candidate I think it explicitly said they did not do that: > I spent months waiting for a single person to apply who fulfilled the racial requirement. When no one did, I spent hours trying to find people on LinkedIn who I thought might count as black or Hispanic based on their name or resume. It seems like a good next step would be to give the author more tools to find more diverse candidates, rather than having them come up with trying to gauge ethnicity by name on LinkedIn and getting those to apply.
- tablespoon 4y ago> It's telling that this person['s]... take away wasn't that they should fix [Microsoft's] broken recruiting pipeline but that the corporate policy was what was wrong. Why is it telling? He's managing a team, and the policy is the more immediate and fixable obstacle to him solving his business hiring problem. Even if Microsoft was capable of "fixing" it's recruiting pipeline, that could never realistically happen in time for him to fill that role.
- LatteLazy 4y agoI work at a crypto/fintech startup. There aren't many women in tech, in finance or in crypto. Even fewer in all three. It took us months to find a woman to hire when our HR insisted we do so before hiring anyone else.
- freetime2 4y agoWhat part of the recruiting pipeline is broken? What would you suggest as a fix? And what does "it's telling" mean? What do you think this tells us about the author?