4 ms·
Well, it's not a description, it's a name. Names are allowed to not be accurate to the thing (a girl named Sandy is not necessarily made out of sand, and light
by coldtea 4y ago
Well, it's not a description, it's a name. Names are allowed to not be accurate to the thing (a girl named Sandy is not necessarily made out of sand, and light is not light, it's weightless).
And itself is based on two things: that they're absolutely black as in they don't reflect anything (that's what they believed when then the name came about), and that things can fall into them.
>A hole is not something, it is a cavity in something else
Well, and black holes can behave like cavities in the universe. They bend the surrounding area with their gravity so much that they end up forming a kind of cavity.
- Maursault 4y agoBut a black hole is not a cavity but instead the extreme opposite of a cavity.
- Nevermark 4y ago"Black holes" absorbs light, so they can be reasonably thought of as "black" (despite lighting effects as it interacts with surrounding matter), and anything that gets too close falls in, like a "hole" (or a cavity). Compound names mostly come from associations, not careful logic. Names in general are arbitrary symbols, not definitions.
- Maursault 4y agoMy issue is not with the descriptor, "black," but in calling it a hole. You get too close to a star or planet, you will also fall in, but we don't consider stars or planets as holes. "Gravity well" is a better descriptor, but not when considered a hole, rather only when considered full of water, but here the water is instead gravity, and gravity always implies something massive, not the absence of something else. Black holes, as we think of them as something, are really shadows. It'd be more accurate and less confusing to call them singularity shadows.
- goatlover 4y agoIt's a hole in spacetime in the sense that the inside of the Black Hole is completely cutoff from the outside, with the exception of Hawking radiation. A black hole's interior is causally separate from the rest of the universe.
- Maursault 4y agoThis doesn't solve the problem. Spacetime itself is a hole, so you're saying a black hole is a hole within a hole, and we can designate an infinite number of holes within a hole.
- forgotpwd16 4y agoSounds like something you'll read about in modern physics.
- coldtea 4y agoIsn't the idea that the universe (or the superset of universes) a hole within a hole (or an infinite number of holes within a hole) something physicists already entertain? E.g. there are several theories about how our universe itself is the inside of a black hole, and so on.
- zethus 4y agoThe author does take a wild ride into the world where, via Hawking radiation, the interior is NOT causally separate, yet quantum-ly entangled.
- Nevermark 4y ago> "Gravity well" is a better descriptor, but not when considered a hole [...] But a well IS a hole in the ground and a pretty deep subject.
- Maursault 4y ago> But a well IS a hole in the ground A water well is a special type of hole known as an excavation, meaning, of course, that it was excavated. Wells are not made by accumulating so many things that they just sink into the ground, and nothing is taken out of a black hole to create it.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> a girl named Sandy is not necessarily made out of sand Technically, the meaning of the name is "defender of men".