3 ms·
Anyone else find it weird they used a ML classifier to mask peoples' identities? It doesn't do a good job at constantly masking any of the bystanders. Which the
by godelski 4y ago
Anyone else find it weird they used a ML classifier to mask peoples' identities? It doesn't do a good job at constantly masking any of the bystanders. Which their identity is probably more important than the researchers?
I totally thought this was going to be about something completely different.
But I don't suspect these kinds of methods to work in the long run. Honestly maybe someone can convince me otherwise. These kinds of attacks are always going to be extremely difficult. Your attack (the sweatshirt) changes as you move and walk through different lightings, etc. It just doesn't seem like a good direction for real protection. Plus, a model can always be tuned to correct for the attack. It just seems like the research is more about robustness which it feels like this is just flashy presentation. I can get that tbh, but these always seem like they are being presented as ways people can attack these systems in the real world (I don't buy this).
So privacy ML people, can you explain to a CV researcher why this is a useful direction?
- TheMiddleMan 4y agoI don't think privacy is the only application. Imagine a bank using an algorithm like this with their security cameras to reduce the number of guards needed on premises. I could imagine thieves targeting their system with something like this. Or maybe I've been watching too many heist movies...
- Semaphor 4y agoI’m pretty sure GP didn’t mean the actual project, but their presentation and the anonymization of it.
- godelski 4y agoI mean the entire premise of wearing something that fools the classifier and not the camera. I see visual attacks as a cat and mouse game except the cat can see you when you move the wrong way or someone shines a light on you. I get that security always has been and always will be a cat and mouse game, but this seems like a path where the cat is always going to have huge advantages.