3 ms·
I feel I just read a bunch of words that stand in stark contrast to reality, with me finding the new design confusing, badly laid out, hiding important parts of
by mattmanser 15y ago
I feel I just read a bunch of words that stand in stark contrast to reality, with me finding the new design confusing, badly laid out, hiding important parts of the UI without any scrollbar indication and even more damningly I find it looks amateurish in 'compact' mode, the only practical configuration for seriously using it as a mail client.
I also can't understand how it can feel so awful when using it, they claim to have tweaked timings but this is exactly one of the parts of it that drives me crazy prompting me to keep switching back, UI elements suddenly spring to life unexpectedly. They seem to have got them all totally wrong.
I've been trying my best to like it but I've had enough now. The massive gulf between this botched redesign and something like the iPhone where every action 'feels' natural just shows how hard good design is. There are even UI inconsistencies like the reply/reply all/forward mock 'text' box keeps the mouse as an arrow instead of a pointer or text cursor, I still hesitate for a few seconds over it as my brain hasn't learnt to just go ahead and click it.
It just doesn't feel finished. The whole thing just feels half baked.
On the other hand I have been impressed with the new GMail client in a mobile browser. Apart from a minor quibble that you have to scroll to the bottom to reply, it's really good.
Edit: It's also called GMail, not GChat, why keep pushing the chat functionality, grr.