EA adherents can use rigorous reasoning to reach different conclusions, just from having different values that they start with. Case in point: One person might

EA adherents can use rigorous reasoning to reach different conclusions, just from having different values that they start with. Case in point: One person might want to maximize quality of current lives; another might want to maximize quality of future lives. Reasoning validly from there, they can reach wildly different conclusions on how to most effectively give.