8 ms·
Saudi Arabia sentences tribesmen to death for resisting displacement
- iancmceachern 4y agoI will protest this, and their other human rights abuses by never traveling there, for any reason, ever.
- Gene_Parmesan 4y agoAt this point, who would want to? Genuinely. I haven't any idea. I'm a huge F1 fan and F1 racing there feels like such a bizarre move, and it's one that has almost put me off the sport. Dirty money and F1 go together like mac and cheese but this feels like a new low for them.
- UncleOxidant 4y agoI don't think that not traveling to Saudi Arabia will effect them at all. It's never really been a tourist destination unless you count Muslims on the haj. If you really want to protest then stop using oil. Sure most oil sold in the US isn't from SA, but if we started using a lot less of the stuff prices would go down and that would effect SA.
- newsclues 4y agoIf we stop buying oil, if you want to hurt the Saudis, we also need to convince everyone else (China) to buy the oil. If you want to replace oil, make the alternative undeniably CHEAPER.
- lambdasquirrel 4y agoWhy the sudden China bashing? China has more EV uptake than the U.S., in fact they pretty much invented the electric micro-car as a market, because of the density of their cities. The reality is that U.S. is more dependent on oil than any other major industrialized economy. We consume more than the EU, and we consume almost as much as Asia, despite being some small fraction of that continent's population. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_oil_consumption https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_oil_consu... The Saudis just flipped us off. We should get off of oil.
- nashashmi 4y agoBut if you don't want to hurt the other oil exporters, and just hurt SA, THERE IS NO way to do that
- einpoklum 4y agoI'd say if you really want to protest them, then petition the US government to... 1. Stop selling KSA and UAE weapons. 2. Reduce or cancel sanctions sanctioning on Iran, Syria and Lebanon (regimes the KSA has tried to undermine). 3. Make public arguments against the Saudi occupation of Bahrain. 4. Yemen: 4.1 Arrange a weapons embargo on KSA while their Yemen campaign continue 4.2 Ensure safe passage to naval and air vessels to Yemen 4.3 Send some humanitarian aid to Yemen (they need it at least as much, and probably more, than Ukraine) 4.4 Recognize the Houthi grievances in Yemen and support peace talks and a federated resolution of the Yemeni civil war. 5. Join the ICC and sue MBS' ass for chopping up Jamal Khasokgi. (Ok, the US will never do that, it has too much culpability of its own.)
- fakedang 4y agoYou're wrong on a number of points: 1.) While the UAE and Qatar were initially in the Saudi camp at the start of the war, they have both since left the field - Qatar because their plan was a token response from the start, and the UAE because of significant casualties (and a petition from the mother of a slain soldier). 2.) Iran is currently beating up and killing their own population for protesting. Syria used chemical gas against their own population for protesting. Lebanon is basically Iran's little Mediterranean bitch. You would like us to unsanction these regimes?? 3.) Saudi Arabia hasn't been occupying Bahrain - KSA and the UAE "monitor" it on behalf of the Emir of Bahrain. A better way to rephrase this would be: force the Emir out and let the people of Bahrain decide for themselves. 4.) Yes, the West should embargo the Saudis on weapon sales. Not that it would affect them much since they'll just buy from Russia and China, but that is the moral path. 5.) Ask the Houthis for safe naval and air passage in Yemen. They're the ones causing disruptions in the area. 6.) Any humanitarian aid to Yemen somehow ends up with the Houthis. 7.) Houthis don't have any "grievances". Yemen has been divided between a Sunni half and a Shia half since the start of Islam. For the most part historically, Yemen was largely Sunni-dominated. It's only recently that the Houthis are able to put up a fight, and that's largely due to Iranian support and funding. 9.) Leaving the Houthis alone will only let Iran's theocracy impose their own puppet in the area. That is not something the world needs. 10.) Sure, sue MBS, but that's just opening a whole other can of worms. Like it or not, Iran is just as bad as Saudi Arabia. Both countries rely on a modus operandi of training terrorists and spreading them abroad to cause chaos and fear, and ultimately acquiescence. On that front, Saudi Arabia is still a better ally, since most of the Gulf monarchies have come to the realization that supporting religious fundamentalists abroad has been a retarded thing to do because they'll return to fuck up their monarchical systems later on.
- yamtaddle 4y agoI've been practicing this form of protest for nearly every country, my entire life.
- nonrandomstring 4y agoThey're cooked. Quite literally. Let's see how long that regime stays together when the daytime temperature hits 55 degrees Celsius.
- klyrs 4y agoSaudi Arabia will continue to be an oasis no matter the change in climate, as long as they have enough oil to burn for air conditioning. Construction projects can be protected with inflatable tents, for example.
- smegger001 4y agoor build at night
- deworms 4y agoSo in other words, by doing nothing in particular. A protest where you don't change your behavior in any way and don't have to bear any cost is not much of a protest.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoActually, the best protest of Saudi Arabia was carried out by Mayoshi Son of SoftBank. He working with such people as Adam Neumann of WeWork lit billions of dollars worth of Saudi money on fire. A few more years of this, and Saudi won't be able to afford to do stunts like this.
- jshorty 4y agoEspecially sad given that, in my opinion, this project is doomed to fail anyway— a 21st century Tower of Babel. The plans for a year-round ski resort seem especially ridiculous given the relatively mild climate in the Sarawat mountains.
- hinkley 4y agoThe tricky thing about calling something a Tower of Babel is that it’s one thing to build the first one, it’s quite something else to build a second knowing about the first. This linear city idea is worse than the planned city they built in, Brazil? That was more 2 dimensional at least. So this one goes up instead of out, but you’ll notice for instance the gap for the stadium. Stadiums are a bottleneck in regular cities. All traffic in the whole city has to drive past the stadium if they want to get somewhere on the other side, and with the gaps it’s a double choke point. The Architect’s Sketch, Monty Python: “Are you proposing to slaughter our tenants?” “… does that not fit in with your plan?” “[…] no it’s just that we wanted a block of flats, and not an abattoir” “Yes, well of course, that’s just the sort of blinkered, philistine pig-ignorance I’ve come to expect from you lot of non-creative garbage.” The other candidate’s scale model breaks twice, and catches fire and then explodes. They decide that thin, sedentary tenants should avoid those problems.
- h4n1 4y agoIt wouldn't be the first linear city. The idea was popular in the early 20th century for industrial settlements. Magnitogorsk was orginally planned as such. None of the planned linear cities have stayed linear, to my knowledge. It only makes sense for when the whole point of living there is to operate a massive production line.
- hulitu 4y ago> Neom: Saudi Arabia sentences tribesmen to death for resisting displacement Whatever they do, they are still our friends and that's all that matters. /s
- selectodude 4y agoThey're really stretching that friendship right now by cutting output to bail out Russia.
- beloch 4y agoThey're actually importing Russian oil for domestic use to free up more of their own for export. https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/exclusive-saudi-arabia-doubles-q2-russian-fuel-oil-imports-power-generation-2022-07-14/ https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/exclusive-saudi-arab...
- hondo77 4y ago> They're actually importing Russian oil for domestic use to bail out Russia. FTFY.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> they are still our friends If you care about this, now is the time to call your representatives. There is a sea change underway in Congress on Riyadh [1]. It’s on a precipice. This isn’t campaign-issue material. If Americans don’t care to reach out, the status quo will hold. [1] https://www.politico.com/news/2022/10/09/murphy-saudi-arabia-consequences-00061068 https://www.politico.com/news/2022/10/09/murphy-saudi-arabia...
- UncleOxidant 4y agoNot sure calling your congressperson will have a lot of effect. Do everything you can to minimize your use of oil. If enough of us do that then oil prices will go down and that will effect SA.
- rany_ 4y agoThe thing I find most heartbreaking is that I'm 99% sure this will go the way of the Jeddah Tower (too much corruption/dictatorship for clever plans to be made and the project gets cancelled). It's also not the smartest project, a quick look at their website shows you genius ideas like this 170km long line they want to build in the middle of nowhere: https://www.neom.com/en-us/regions/theline https://www.neom.com/en-us/regions/theline Not to mention that Saudi Arabia doesn't even have any issues with population density. They are building these cities like they have some overpopulation issues, such a waste of money. A shame it's not being spent on things that would help Saudi Arabia in the long term.
- rany_ 4y agoNeom might just be the best argument against totalitarianism, such stupid ideas wouldn't even be up for consideration in a free(er) country. Just looking at the website makes me so sad, it legitimately feels like some passion project of a megalomaniac who doesn't care for the wellbeing of his people.
- humanistbot 4y agoI'm going to Godwin's Law this thread and say that the cases at the top of this list are probably the best arguments against totaliarianism: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_genocides_by_death_toll https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_genocides_by_death_tol...
- rany_ 4y agoWell, Hitler had his Germania megacity project to stoke his ego. They aren't too dissimilar;) I guess dictatorships and stupid planning/construction projects go pretty much hand in hand. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Germania_(city) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Germania_(city)
- smegger001 4y agoon the other hand Alexander had Alexandria in Egypt. not all dictator inspired mega project are stupid.
- the_optimist 4y agoBanks and investment managers supporting this megadevelopment are complicit. It’ll be in your pension fund soon, unless you speak up.
- klyrs 4y agoI don't have a pension fund but they hold a major stake in my employer and probably yours too.
- yabones 4y agoThe "line city" is possibly the worst idea of the 21st century. I will honestly be shocked if it goes over any better than the "world islands" they tried to build in Dubai.
- GauntletWizard 4y agoI had not read this concept before now, but it really sounds as if someone played too much halo and didn't understand the real-world math that makes that a "good idea" in space.
- edmcnulty101 4y agoTheir leader MBS completely got away with murdering Kashoggi in cold blood and having absolutely no repurcussions not even politically. The USA treats them as a first class political ally. Most of 9/11 hijackers were from Saudi Arabia. Between murdering reporters, hosting terrorist groups, and horrible human rights abuses....There's literally nothing Saudi Arabia can do to get any repercussions for anything.
- aerostable_slug 4y ago> Most of 9/11 hijackers were from Saudi Arabia. Yes. Similarly, Pakistani intelligence knew where Bin Laden was. Oh wait, SOME Pakistani intelligence knew. The issue we're seeing is internecine conflict and a lack of effective governance. Saying the hijackers were Saudis so therefore the entire House of Saud is liable is reductive at best. I'm not defending said House, but OTOH blaming the most public power base for everything associated with the country ignores the fact that they don't have control over their own power bases (much like Pakistan, a total s-hole that I can't wait until we're disengaged from).
- throwaway2203 4y agoI'm Pakistani, it's not a s-hole. It's a lovely country full of lovely people who are helpless against the burden of colonial legacy, corrupt landowners and a way-too-powerful army.
- rayiner 4y agoIt’s possible for people to be “lovely” but also the reason for why the country is in bad shape. I’m Bangladeshi, and folks there are very kind. My dad has stories of traveling through rural parts of the country and a villager walking miles out of his way to make sure he got back to his car without getting lost. But they’re also a big part of the reason why things are the way they are. From the tolerance of corruption, to the lack of organization. You can say the exact same things about parts of the US that other parts of the US would regard as “shit holes” (rural Georgia or Mississippi). People are very nice! But that’s not sufficient for a developed civilization.
- deworms 4y ago
- Abderrhmane 4y agoI have lived in this country for over 10 years, they do the most craziest things ever.
- SimianSci 4y agoIn my eyes this appears to be further evidence as to why a combination or extreme wealth inequality and centralized authority is counterproductive to a nation's continued prosperity. For all its concentration of wealth and authority, Saudia Arabia is clearly squandering its power in favor of misguided projects of ego. I do not see a long-term future for a government such as this which has decided to behave in the same manner as a spoiled mewling child.
- tibbydudeza 4y agoI wonder if they will be cut up into pieces with a saw ???.
- ethotool 4y agoAnd the West supposedly stands for human rights..
- hey2022 4y agoThe West stands for many things. The West also prioritizes different things at different times. Getting into a conflict with UAE while Europe is on the brink of a massive energy supply crisis would potentially weaken the West even more. I am sure the West is not loving the situation with human rights in UAE, but picks its battles wisely (albeit at the cost of human suffering in UAE).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- etaioinshrdlu 4y agoI'm wondering why the USA hasn't used its military muscle to force regime change in Saudi Arabia. They have valuable resources, and I don't think any major country would stand in the USA's way. The people already live under a brutal repressive dictatorship. Why not replace it with something more tolerable? My best guess is that doing so would dramatically increase terrorism in the region. Venezuela would be another area in need of intervention, IMO. Update: I'm as anti-war as it gets, but consider: when is there a moral imperative to act? If you could stop the Khmer Rouge in Cambodia, should you? If you can stop your neighbor from going on a murdering spree, should you?
- kingofpandora 4y agoWhy would the USA care? They get everything they want from Saudi, with some bad press as the only downside. You don't actually think regime change is ever about how repressive the government is.
- dontlaugh 4y agoWhy would the US destroy one of its two major allies in the area and the very source of petrodollars? The US does regime change only against countries that resist exploitation. The rhetoric about human rights or dictatorship is just that.
- etaioinshrdlu 4y agoIf we install a puppet regime there, they are still an ally by definition.
- dontlaugh 4y agoMaybe, it wouldn’t be guaranteed to be functional. And why invest any effort and the considerable risk to change the situation? The US ruling class already has the best ally they could wish for.
- coffeefirst 4y agoThat was the plan for Iraq. It turns out nation building is a lot harder than killing the bad guys.
- lnsru 4y agoSounds like normal day in Belarus or other less democratic country. I really don’t understand why these people choose death over other alternatives. It’s not that they didn’t know what is awaiting them. Killing some protesters is absolutely normal is less democratic country. While Neom project is cool for sure I am not so sure if it’s clever one. But let’s see how this car-less city in a desert experiment ends. It’s better in my eyes than stealing all the oil money and buying yachts for the buddies like russian government did it.
- seer-zig 4y ago
- nickpinkston 4y agoIf you ever get invited to the "Future Investment Initiative" aka "Davos in the Desert", NEVER GO THERE. More like "Despots in the Desert". I feel for the Saudi people, but fuck their corrupt, useless monarchy. They could at least aspire to be Singapore, but I guess 100 gold-plated Rolls Royces and stupid giant infrastructure projects strokes the ego more - lame as fuck... Sic Semper Tyrannis
- gremlinsinc 4y agoSo long, I've awaited this honor... * Looks longingly at my invite to Davos in the Desert. * * Let's it gingerly slip from my fingers into the fire pit, as a single tear falls in the flames. * /jk. Sarcasm aside, I don't understand why the West kowtows to Saudi's. I feel like maybe they were more culpable in 9/11 than previously thought, they are constantly doing shit, that even China would think twice about (they'd reeducate and do concentration camps, but perhaps not straight up executions). I know it probably involves money, etc - but we need to put our partnerships with others to a smell test, if that country that wants to partner up, or do business with Americans has a horrible human rights record, they should be on the banned countries list like NK and Iran. If only politics weren't legal organized crime, perhaps we could instill some values in our nations leaders and businesses to cease supporting despots.
- nickpinkston 4y agoOur whole Middle East policy is based on oil price stability, but with the Saudi's recently decreasing production, we're not getting that either, so fuck 'em. https://www.npr.org/2022/10/05/1126754169/opec-oil-production-cut https://www.npr.org/2022/10/05/1126754169/opec-oil-productio... I'd prefer we worked with Iran, a far more broadly educated / liberal society (not gov't) that we can work with and who can be productive beyond oil production. But even better I really like the Venezuelan oil production plan. https://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-plans-to-ease-venezuela-sanctions-enabling-chevron-to-pump-oil-11665005719 https://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-plans-to-ease-venezuela-san... Long-term, I'd love to see an energy independence bill come out that would allow short-term US oil/gas production, sourcing from allies, and a rapid de-carbonization of our society. The IRA is a good start: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation_Reduction_Act_of_2022 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation_Reduction_Act_of_202...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- burntbridge 4y agoThis should be a reminder that the U.S. cares nothing for human rights violations and whenever it voices such complaints it does so for other selfish Geopolitical reasons that are maybe not revealed. This goes for any of the other Geopolitical powers as well. Let's not be useful idiots.
- the_optimist 4y agoThe US is not monolitic. People who characterize it thusly do so do not capture the intentional-by-design unstable nature of the system. It remains, nonetheless, up to to 'us' to be not useful idiots.
- devoutsalsa 4y agoNeither is Saudi Arabia. Most people from most countries are pretty decent. You just don’t hear about them.
- hey2022 4y agoA better way to look at this is to recognize that geopolitics involve a multitude of political, economic, cultural, etc aspects. It's not that the US cares nothing for human rights violations, it's that we often prioritize different aspects. Caring does not imply a specific action. Absolutely not trying to justify the relationship between the US and UAE. However, a maximalist position rarely leads to a positive change when so many parties and interests are involved.
- dirtyid 4y agoPersonal guilty pleasure: love me some stupidendously wasteful ego driven mega monuments. A mega city in the desert even better. Not enough grand architecture by liberal world order. There are insideous human costs to everything, and all things considered, rare hubris mega construction projects are pretty good generational cultural value. Even after they fall into to ruin.
- angry-tempest 4y agoHere is what ACT had on Neom: https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/model-city-monday-8122 https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/model-city-monday-8122