4 ms·
> It’s no coincidence at all that WeChat is the only “everything app” anyone can cite, and it comes from China, an authoritarian regime. It makes sense that it
by robertlagrant 4y ago
> It’s no coincidence at all that WeChat is the only “everything app” anyone can cite, and it comes from China, an authoritarian regime.
It makes sense that it would come from a more authoritarian country first. But Whatsapp, say, could add payments and similar features if they were valuable to users.
This is all commentary on something Elon Musk probably said in the hope that investors would fling cash at him, of course.
- bombcar 4y agoThe internet is the everything app; it's currently somewhat decentralized but it's becoming more and more centralized every day. And the benefits of centralization are immediate and obvious; the downsides are hidden, localized, and not clear.
- newsclues 4y agoThe internet isn’t an “app” but browsers are.
- criddell 4y agoSo if an everything app is terrible for liberal democracies and free markets and the internet is the everything app, then it follows that the internet is terrible for liberal democracies and free markets.
- bombcar 4y agoI would be inclined to agree, though whether that shows more the problems with liberal democracies and free markets or with the internet is still to decide.
- butterfi 4y agoThe internet is to apps what roads are to cars. Don’t blame the road for bad drivers.
- bombcar 4y agoIt's actually an interesting analogy, because road design can have a great effect on the drivers - you can't prevent bad drivers, but you can mitigate issues (see: traffic calming, roundabouts, etc). Similar things that were baked into the internet continue to provide dividends today, but it has to be intentional, and as more and more of the modern internet is designed by groups of companies rather than groups of academics it can shift.
- yamtaddle 4y ago"The medium is the message." - McLuhan
- bee_rider 4y agoThe article is clearly talking about centralized everything apps. I mean most of their complaints are about a private company dominating the whole market. If we want to talk about a generalized idea of an everything app that includes something decentralized like the internet, then I think we'll have mooted most of their concerns.
- nitin-pai 4y agoThe internet is not an everything ‘app’ in the sense that it’s built/controlled by one firm. The reason the internet is good for liberal democracy is that it’s (declining) openness creates very low barriers for entry, free innovation undermines market power and architecture limits state power. Stuff that changes that nature of the internet presents the danger to liberal democracy.
- skohan 4y agoCentralization is a logical result of unregulated capitalism. If money can be used to buy advantages in the market, it follows that any player with an edge can use it to widen their lead over time to the point nobody else can compete. Anti-trust regulation is supposed to solve this, but in the US at least it seems we've settled on a status quo where we pretend having two giant players in a market rather than one is enough to protect the interests of consumers, despite many many examples where that has proven not to be the case.
- bombcar 4y agoCompanies see regulation as just another raw material to be bought and sold and processed for their benefit.
- robertlagrant 4y ago> Anti-trust regulation is supposed to solve this Only if it's provably harmful. And only if you hire people into the anti-trust regulation role who are perfect uncorruptable beings that can see the future consumer implications of each business decision. Given the regulators we've hired so far are neither, we shouldn't be assuming regulations can solve this. In reality, regulations give a big first mover advantage. It's much easier to incorporate regulations when you're up and running than come in as a new competitor and slam into a wall of red tape, which due to years of relationship built up is much more porous for the incumbants.
- hedora 4y agoWeb browsers are an everything app.
- Mordisquitos 4y agoTo be more precise, it is the combination of web browsers, HTML, JavaScript, and adjacent technologies that are the everything app, but your point stands. You are absolutely right. Let's be blunt: the elevator pitch for the 'everything app' as «a smartphone application that will deliver everything to everyone on the planet» has already been solved. The pitch that Elon Musk and other tech oligarchs want to solve has an addendum, which the WebBrowser+ ecosystem does not yet[0] satisfy: «a smartphone application that will deliver everything to everyone on the planet [and is under the control of a single entity for its own benefit]» [0] I say "not yet" because developing a new app from scratch is not the only strategy—see Google trying its best to make Chrome and derivatives the only useful 'everything apps'
- shadowgovt 4y agoTrue, but not in a way that matters precisely for the purpose of this discussion. The issue as described in this article is the control of the single channel by one entity. The browser is an "everything app" in the same sense a television is an "everything communication appliance," but the signal you can put on it is sourced from thousands of different, independent operators (assuming, for TV, you have plugged in more than just a cable line). In general, when companies that create browsers have attempted to reduce the browser to a single-channel tool (by, for instance, constraining the sites it will access), the browser has fallen in general-use popularity.
- hunterb123 4y agoThey are more of a platform as you need web sites / apps for it to be useful. Similar to how you need programs for the OS platform to be useful. Things you deploy to are platforms (web, windows, macos, etc.), the things being deployed onto platforms are apps. But a browser was first (and still is) a document reader, so it's also a limited app in that sense.
- giantrobot 4y agoThey're not though. In context an "everything app" is an application + service that bundles a bunch of disparate functionality. Such an "app" would only provide access to third parties that have some relationship with the app's platform. More like Disneyland than a shopping mall.
- safety1st 4y agoI think Gruber was simply wrong when he said this, off the top of my head, Line and Grab are pretty good candidates for "everything apps." There are probably more. The logic behind the emergence of these apps is pretty simple. An app store is a walled garden everyone is forced to use. An app's popularity on the store is self-reinforcing, it tends to snowball. If you get a really big app going with a lot of installs, why not add more services to make more money from those installs? Then maybe all those services have some kind of referral incentive and you snowball even more... There are different hurdles in different markets but I see absolutely no reason this concept couldn't take off in the West. (Bloat and bad UX would prevent it? That's a joke right?)
- indymike 4y ago> I see absolutely no reason this concept couldn't take off in the West. It could, but it would require the government to require use of the everything app in some way. In the west, there are so many choices for payments and messaging. Yes the snowballing you describe exists, but requires an immense amount of gravity - that at this point only Apple and Google really have.