4 ms·
Note: here is what tokenadult says about using cross-sectional TIMSS scores to make comparisons: "The methodology of the blog post [comparing aggregate TIMSS s
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
Note: here is what tokenadult says about using cross-sectional TIMSS scores to make comparisons:
"The methodology of the blog post [comparing aggregate TIMSS scores] you point to repeatedly is laughable."
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2773391 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2773391
Incidentally, the data tokenadult links to suggests that differences in TIMSS scores are due to differences in ethnicity of the student body, not management practices. He deliberately ignores this data but the rest of us should not.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trends_in_International_Mathematics_and_Science_Study http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trends_in_International_Mathema...
- tokenadult 15y agoI have lived in one of the other countries, know hundreds upon hundreds of people from several of the other countries, and own and have read textbooks from several of the top TIMSS countries, including textbooks written in languages other than English. (I speak, understand, read, and write Chinese to the level of a professional translator and interpreter.) I reject the facile analysis you picked up from a blog post--so far not published in a peer-reviewed journal--by a graduate student who has yet to complete his degree because I have read better research on the subject by authors who have completed their Ph.D. degrees at better academic institutions, and who have published in peer-reviewed journals of high quality. I'm sorry for you if you are stuck on one lame explanation for the phenomenon of underperforming United States schools, but especially if you would take the time and effort to read good-quality dead-tree literature on the subject, http://www.amazon.com/Vision-Elementary-Mathematics-W-Sawyer/dp/048642555X http://www.amazon.com/Vision-Elementary-Mathematics-W-Sawyer... http://www.amazon.com/Learning-Gap-Schools-Japanese-Education/dp/0671880764 http://www.amazon.com/Learning-Gap-Schools-Japanese-Educatio... http://www.amazon.com/Teaching-Gap-Improving-Education-Classroom/dp/1439143137/ http://www.amazon.com/Teaching-Gap-Improving-Education-Class... http://www.amazon.com/Knowing-Teaching-Elementary-Mathematics-Understanding/dp/0805829091 http://www.amazon.com/Knowing-Teaching-Elementary-Mathematic... you could learn something new that could help you better understand the other countries in the world and what the United States might learn from them.
- davidhansen 15y agoSir, your ability to cram as much fallacious argumentum ad verecundiam as possible into a single paragraph is unparalleled. I salute you.
- spodek 15y agoWhen I looked up the Latin phrase I realized probably if I had to look it up, plenty of other people would too, so I copied the first couple of lines from Wikipedia here to save people the effort. ---- Argument from authority (also known as appeal to authority or argumentum ad verecundiam) is a special type of inductive argument which often takes the form of a statistical syllogism. Although certain classes of argument from authority do on occasion constitute strong inductive arguments, arguments from authority are commonly used in a fallacious manner. ----- Since I'm not logically proving anything, I'll refer to an authority, Strunk and White, who say: "Avoid foreign languages: the writer will occasionally find it convenient or necessary to borrow from other languages. Some writers, however, from sheer exuberance or desire to show off, sprinkle their work liberally with foreign expressions, with no regard for the reader's comfort. It is a bad habit. Write in English"
- lambersley 15y ago+1
- yummyfajitas 15y agoYou are attempting to make the logical fallacy of arguing from authority. Hacker news is smart enough to see through this. The only data I've cited is TIMSS data which is published and presumably peer reviewed. It's true that Tino Sanandaji PhD (note: he graduated, not that it matters) pointed this data in a blog post. So what? It's the same data you cite. The data says the groups of people with top math performance worldwide (circa 2007) are: 1) Taiwan 598 2) South Korea 597 3) Singapore 593 4) Asian Americans 582 5) Hong Kong 572 From this data, how do you conclude that American schools underperform? I'm not asking if you speak Chinese or whether "hundreds upon hundreds" of your Chinese buddies agree with you. That is irrelevant to the topic at hand. I'm asking you for a logical argument, based on data (in particular the data that you cited), that concludes American schools underperform. Any such argument needs to control for the quality of students, since student test scores are obviously a function of both the school and the students. If you believe the dead tree books you hint have such an argument, please tell me which book and which pages. Or feel free to continue making logical fallacies. I'm not really posting for the purpose of arguing with you, I don't expect to learn anything from that. I'm just trying to make sure others reading your posts are not misled by vague assertions that hundreds of unnamed authorities might agree with Chinese speakers like you. P.S. To make myself appear smart, while providing absolutely no facts, I'll cite dead trees also: http://www.amazon.com/Harry-Potter-Sorcerers-Stone-Book/dp/059035342X/ref=sr_1_15?ie=UTF8&qid=1323105315&sr=8-15 http://www.amazon.com/Harry-Potter-Sorcerers-Stone-Book/dp/0... http://www.amazon.com/Secret-Diary-Call-Girl-Belle/dp/044654082X/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1323105378&sr=1-1 http://www.amazon.com/Secret-Diary-Call-Girl-Belle/dp/044654... Some more irrelevant facts: I have a PhD, I lived in Asia, I often have sex with Asian women, and I'm a good cook.