3 ms·
Here is a question for everyone who agrees with this editorial: Suppose that this man is correct - that the material being taught/tested is useless and unneces
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
Here is a question for everyone who agrees with this editorial:
Suppose that this man is correct - that the material being taught/tested is useless and unnecessary for a successful career. In that case, shouldn't we stop teaching it, remove the material from the curriculum, allow students to graduate a year or two earlier and fire a bunch of useless teachers?
If not, why not?
- esrauch 15y agoThere are almost certainly people (laborers?) who are successful without having any knowledge taught in school at all. Modern schools explicitly aren't vocational, they don't even claim to strive to teach skills that can be directly applied to jobs, the point is that it is useful to understand how to learn and think about things well. They also provide exposure and opportunity; there are plenty of jobs that do require these skills (or more accurately, require skills for which learning these skills is a prerequisite), and if we didn't teach them to everyone then the children of laborers would end up as laborers even when they are capable and interested in being rocket scientists.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoYou are disagreeing with the premise - that the skills being measured are not necessary. I nominally agree with you. But I'm asking people who agree with the premise whether they also agree with the logical conclusion - if the tested skills are unnecessary for most/all, why not stop teaching them, fire teachers and reduce spending on education commensurately?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- esrauch 15y agoI did make a claim about how it makes sense even if the skills aren't directly applicable to any profession. I understood the claim to be "the skills being measure are not necessary" to mean "you don't need the skills to be successful" which I do agree with. That is a completely different claim than the idea that that the skills are useless, the skills are only useful to some (significant) subset of the population, and I argue that we should teach them even to people that they will be useless for to force feed them an opportunity that they might otherwise have ignored as a possibility.
- tptacek 15y agoNo, we should fire the people who design the curricula, and design better ones. It doesn't follow from the fact that we're imparting only two useful years worth of knowledge in (say) 4 years of high school that students are only capable of benefiting from 2 years of high school.
- tensor 15y agoNo. Teaching breadth of topics involves more than just teaching obviously useful information. The problem stems from our ability to evaluate what is actually useful. Let me give a direct example you may not have considered, and an interesting hypothesis. Perhaps most importantly, we live in a democracy. This means that people vote for the direction of our government. When doing so, many different issues are considered. Of these, most are probably outside the area of ones expertise. How can we expect good decisions made by people ignorant of the subjects in question? So we teach basic science, basic math, history, english, and the arts to everyone. This way our population has at least a small amount of knowledge to fall back on when needed. On a less concrete topic, there is much speculation about the effects of learning on brain structure. Despite not remembering much mathematics, for instance, how do we know that learning mathematical concepts did not leave a lasting effect on the brain? What about the lessons we learn from history class? We might not directly associate with them when making everyday decisions, but is it not possible that learning those lessons contributed to our current thought processes? In summary, it is very difficult to quantify exactly what you retain from education and even harder to identify specific ways in which it helps you or helped to shape your mind. Thus, it is best to err on the side of caution and teach as much as we can.