3 ms·
I can easily believe that this is a grassroots group (we see many examples of that, in many areas, even in childhood), but this did prompt a few questions: 1.
by neilv 4y ago
I can easily believe that this is a grassroots group (we see many examples of that, in many areas, even in childhood), but this did prompt a few questions:
1. Is there any advantage to nation having cyber attack deniability via being able to at least semi-plausibly claim that, although an attack appeared in the interests of the nation, it was by an independent grassroots group, out of the nation's control? If so, would they establish identities for those supposed independent groups ahead of time?
2. Let's say you're a nation with cyber capabilities that are advanced but spread thin. If you're filling the human resource deficit with lower-skilled workers, and not giving them access to your advanced tools for their tasks, would you be concerned that that looks like cyber weakness? If so, would you distinguish the lower-skilled workers from your main brand, and if so, how?
3. Is there any worthwhile external-PR or internal-morale benefit, to appearing to have the active support of independent groups?
- nonameiguess 4y agoI'm sure there are plenty of reasons it can be advantageous to be able to attribute covert action to some independent group, but at least one comes from fairly recent US history: the Iran-Contra Affair. Different parts of a government don't always agree with each other, and one might want to be able to act without approval from another. Not all countries are one-party dictatorships where warfighting departments can just do whatever they want.
- neilv 4y agoI meant no offense by those thoughts, I thought they were in the spirit of HN curiosity, and I apologize if I caused any offense. Since I posted my parent comment, it seems that at least one party has been trying to hack my accounts (including phishing attempts, and trying to social-engineer my phone carrier). As an individual, I'm not hardened against attacks, and can't afford them, so I hope they will stop. (If the parties want, they can go look at my publicly-shared open source software projects and community support, and see that I'm not an adversary.) Hacking an individual is threatening and harmful, and not what I think any of us wants this Hacker News facilitated global community to be about.