4 ms·
> Invited or not, if you don't show up to a colonoscopy you don't get one. Which means the study's data on invitations alone cannot be used to evaluate the effe
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
> Invited or not, if you don't show up to a colonoscopy you don't get one. Which means the study's data on invitations alone cannot be used to evaluate the effect of colonoscopies. Seems the study does provide data that allows this so, and shows clear differences in cancer rates and survival rates for those that did get colonoscopies.
This is not an oversight on the part of the study designers. It's called "intention to treat", and studies are done this way to get past the problem that, when you invite a bunch of people to get colonoscopies (or tell them to comply with any medical procedure), the people who go through with it are statistically very different, in all kinds of ways, from the people who don't. This makes the direct comparison of "received treatment" vs "didn't receive treatment" mostly meaningless.
You're here advocating for everyone to ignore the study and do a direct comparison of "received treatment" vs "didn't receive treatment".
Don't do this.
- hef19898 4y agoI am not doing this, I'm saying the study cannot be used to say colonoscopies don't help.
- ricardobeat 4y agoYou just did it again.
- hef19898 4y agoWhatever
- kgwgk 4y agoIt cannot be used to say that the help either, but you wrote “Seems the study does provide data that allows this so, and shows clear differences in cancer rates and survival rates for those that did get colonoscopies.”
- hef19898 4y agoI read it that the invite doesn get you differnces, the colonoscopy itsrlf does. And if that isn't statistically a gold standard, randomization and all tgat, I don't care. What the study says, IMHO, is that invoting people doesn't do any good when people don't show up. Which is an interesting problem, isn't it? Not inviting people might be an option, one that doesn't provide any benefits, except an number of letters not being sent. So I'd say keep the invites, because every single additional person showing up for a screening is a net win. Additional educating efforts will definetly help so, no idea how those can look like so.
- kgwgk 4y ago> I read it that the invite doesn get you differnces, the colonoscopy itsrlf does. Differences with what? Not with the counterfactual where those people didn’t get a colonoscopy! (At least as far as I can tell from the results being discussed here.) > every single additional person showing up for a screening is a net win. Maybe. This study doesn’t tell us much about it.
- DanBC 4y ago> because every single additional person showing up for a screening is a net win We can't say that from this study. Colonoscopy does appear to be one of the screenings that reduces mortality. (That's why this is such a surprising result and is getting a lot of attention). But that does not mean that colonoscopy screening is useful for people in their 40s. There's a lot of discussion about the benefits and risks of colonoscopy screening for people in their 50s. Colonoscopy, especially as it's practised in the US with heavy sedation, is not risk free.
- hef19898 4y agoNow that is a useful discussion. The more I think about the study (the article covering it is just sh*), the more I think it would have been better to compare how many people had an actual colonoscopy between the two groups, compare everything that was compared between a) people with invite who did show up and those without invite that showed up b) people with invite who didn't show up vs. those without invite who didn't show up and c) those who showed up vs. those who didn't (the most important question). The latter can then be used to gauge overall usefullness by age brackets, gender, region and so on. Obviously, as soon as there are risk factors or other test results, we talk a different game all together. As it stands, this study, while statistically very good, doesn't help anything to answer the really important questions and only confuses people by causing discussions about the study methods, then used to derive conclusions about colonoscopies (utter nonsense, but first principle thinking using supporting science /domains is really en vogue at the moment) instead of discussing the usefulness of colonoscopies in increasing survivability, early detection and decreasing probability of colon cancer.