12 ms·
> the gov has to step in and bring real estate price under control No government has ever managed to repeal the Law of Supply & Demand. Because it's The Law. C
by WalterBright 4y ago
> the gov has to step in and bring real estate price under control
No government has ever managed to repeal the Law of Supply & Demand. Because it's The Law. Communist countries never succeeded at that, either.
- WalterBright 4y agoDenial of the Law of Supply&Demand is about as effective as denying the Law of Gravity, or passing a law that π=3. A couple of obvious examples of failure are rent control and anti-gouging laws.
- uup 4y agoCommunist countries did succeed because they controlled demand. Although I don’t think people would like the solution that much, e.g. three families living together in a 3 bedroom apartment, one family per bedroom.
- WalterBright 4y agoNo, they didn't. They just had supply&demand based on how long you were willing to wait, the black market, barter, privilege, and a market of favors and counter-favors.
- nickpp 4y agoAlso waiting lists. Everybody gets their own apartment… in 20 to 30 years.
- geysersam 4y agoReal estate prices today have little to do with supply and demand. Why else have real estate prices grown hundreds of percent all over the developed world in the last 3 decades, despite relatively low population growth?
- WalterBright 4y agoLike claims of perpetual motion, if it looks like Supply&Demand is not applying, then something is being overlooked. In this case, I suspect your facts overlook the fact that population growth is not even across a country. Population growth has grown a lot in places that are more attractive to live in, and declined in areas that are less attractive. For example, in Spain, I read about many abandoned villages going for a song because the population moved to the big city. In the US, population declined in Detroit and rural areas, and grew in the cities. Housing prices followed those trends.
- geysersam 4y agoYou bring up a good point. But there are other important reasons. Particularly the availability of cheap money for speculation in the housing market. The reason for this is the historically low interest rates.
- bamboozled 4y agoWhat happens when the interest rates go back up? Let's say they go from < 1% to > 10%?
- geysersam 4y agoIf we're lucky, the market recalibrates on a more affordable level. Workers start seeing real wage increases. Speculation and stimulus gives way to real economic development. If we're unlucky, the interest rates are not allowed to increase for fear of falling house prices.
- astrange 4y agoThat just means construction has been made illegal. There's no reason "cheap money for speculation" would be easier to get than "cheap money for construction" otherwise; speculation is riskier! And when interest rates go back up, it gets even harder to finance construction.
- vore 4y agoIf it had enough political will do, the government could build more supply and reduce prices, no, like in Hong Kong and Singapore? There are a whole spectrum of government-directed solutions to try keep prices down that comply with supply and demand.
- WalterBright 4y agoBuilding more supply in order to reduce prices is not repealing Supply+Demand, it is acknowledging it.
- vore 4y agoI was backing up the OP talking about the government stepping in and bringing prices under control, which for some reason you assumed must have meant violating supply and demand.
- WalterBright 4y ago"bringing prices under control" with the government usually means price controls of some sort, which is denying S&D.
- monetus 4y agoI always felt like calling the communist countries communist was like calling our republic a direct democracy. Maybe in spirit I guess, but not exactly in practice. You're in California right? What is the rent control/housing like where you are, if you don't mind my asking?
- WalterBright 4y agoI live in Wa state. While we don't have specifically rent control, there are all kinds of other regulatory interferences with landlords. For example, one is that the tenant is not responsible for damage to the rental from domestic violence, the landlord is. Seattle will provide free lawyers to tenants who want to sue their landlords. Seattle made a lot of extensions to the rent moratoriums. There are requirements that someone building a new apt building must also build some "affordable housing" units. All these things do is force rents higher. https://www.seattle.gov/housing/renters/know-the-law#rentersrightsresponsibilities https://www.seattle.gov/housing/renters/know-the-law#renters...
- tmnvix 4y agoRegulation can influence supply and demand. Raising interest rates lowers demand (I would say most significantly it lowers speculative demand).