4 ms·
On detailing the contents of the test to his business peers: "Not a single one of them said that the math I described was necessary in their profession." Close
by petercooper 15y ago
On detailing the contents of the test to his business peers: "Not a single one of them said that the math I described was necessary in their profession."
Close to none of the history, RE, French, geography, music, phys ed, or even science (heck, nearly every subject) I took in high school has proven directly necessary for my profession. But the standardized tests aren't for adults, they're for students. (Should we expect to pass their agility/phys-ed tests too? :-))
Being able to learn these things, and developing the skills necessary to learn them, is a worthwhile experience and hopefully provides a lot of the inspiration, brain-shaping, and knowledge exposure necessary to get by as an educated adult, even if you can't pass the tests to some arbitrary standard.
I barely remember any of the French I learnt, but I can't help but feel the exposure has given me a better insight into, and a better ear for, my own language. It's a similar story for most of those other subjects.
- jerf 15y agoThe problem is that math education is not only not relevant to your career, it's also not relevant to your future education! #include <lockharts_lament.pdf> Students are correct and so is this board member, math education as it stands today really is worthless. It is of no value. It has no practical value and it has no theoretical value. And if you think otherwise it is likely because you managed to escape from the system, possibly with a four-year degree in computer science or other relevant field, with little more than a glancing introduction to actual mathematics, which are arguably one of the most valuable things mankind has ever produced. There's no need for the cognitive dissonance necessary to insist that math as learned in school is incredibly value even as you, if you search your heart, know better. All you've got in its favor is that you've been told its valuable, so by golly it must be. It's not. It's taught terribly and all the value has been sucked out of it. http://www.maa.org/devlin/LockhartsLament.pdf http://www.maa.org/devlin/LockhartsLament.pdf
- dpark 15y agoWhat math did you learn in high school that you believe is so worthless? My school taught algebra, trig, and calculus. Some of these are useful for everyday life and some are useful for academia.
- jerf 15y agoRead the linked PDF. Schools teach calculation, not mathematics. Some of the calculations occasionally manage to be useful, but if you developed a mathematically mature mind it sure didn't come from your schooling. If you did not take multiple classes that consisted almost entirely of writing many proofs per week, you never took mathematics. If all you did was problems 6-32 evens due next Tuesday, that's not math.
- dpark 15y agoPutting kids through years of proofs would not improve the situation. They would still call it dumb. They would still hate it. They'd probably hate it even more, because it's harder. Moreover it's necessary to teach kids the basics before you teach them advanced concepts. Despite what the article might have you think, we do teach musical notation first. Kids learn that as they are first learning to play. Composition is reserved for the university. Also, the inefficiency of math education in schools does not mean that what they teach is worthless. Certainly they could do better. And maybe making teenagers do hundreds of proofs would be better. But at the end of they day, the student who took calculus in high school is better prepared for college (and a scientific career) than a student who did not.
- jordan0day 15y agoI think jerf isn't really phrasing his position in a palatable way, even though he's right. Since he's referencing Lockhart, I'll go with that. The crux of Lockhart's argument is that math is actually really beautiful, intriguing, and exciting, and the legalistic, browbeating manner in which it is currently taught basically takes all the beauty and excitement out of it. Assuming your high school was like mine, when you learned algebra, trig, and calculus, you were probably taught a few of the whats, some of the hows, but almost none of the whys. It's only in upper-level undergrad and graduate courses that the beauty really starts to be taught in earnest. You're absolutely right to say that putting kids through years of proofs would probably make them hate math even more. Again, that's largely due to the way proofs are taught, especially at the secondary school level. They're all just a bunch of rules listed one after another, "doing a proof" is basically like explaining all the rules of chess to someone who's never played before, and then asking them to put the board in a particular state, thirty-two moves into a game. It ends up as a bunch of trial-and-error guessing... it's frustrating and it's boring. Sure, there are a few savants or folks whose brains are wired in such a way that it's either easy or interesting, but it's just painful for most folks, because there's no intrigue. It's not until three or four years into college that most people are exposed to proofs as an intellectually stimulating game, where intuition plays an even bigger role than "looking at a list of rules and deciding which one fits". But we don't get that in high school. We're not taught how to intuit something and then map the rules to our intuition. In fact, we're usually taught that this is wrong!
- rdouble 15y agoWhat I found weird about Lockhart's lament is that my music theory classes were pretty much like the "nightmare" he describes in the intro. I didn't really consider them such a nightmare, so I never read the rest of the essay.
- jerf 15y agoThe difference with music theory is that you've listened to music and you already know the magic. Now you can take the time to take it apart and study it, and you probably won't forget the magic. To understand Lockhart's metaphor, you must also understand that in his metaphor, this is the student's only exposure to music. They don't listen to music three hours a day, it's not in the background of every movie they watch, etc. And instead of only interested people seeking out the theory, as in your case (and as it turns out, mine, I took 2 years as well), it's forced on everybody. For more than two years in college, too. You can't possibly have been in his nightmare.
- absconditus 15y agoUnfortunately I do not think that the author of the article nor the board member who is its subject wants to replace current mathematical education with something more useful. They likely just want to dumb it down so that more students pass.