4 ms·
So why is deception wrong in an interrogation? I can see some of the other tactics as problematic, but not that directly.
by giantg2 4y ago
So why is deception wrong in an interrogation? I can see some of the other tactics as problematic, but not that directly.
- lupire 4y agoWhy is deception right? Even the 10 commandments oppose it. Deception leads to false convictions.
- giantg2 4y ago"Deception leads to false convictions." How?
- viiralvx 4y agoI can't tell if you're being willfully dense or serious. If you're deceiving people and pressuring them to lie in order to close a case, they will say anything to be released, potentially not knowing the implications.
- giantg2 4y agoI'm only talking about deception. The other pressures I can understand. Why is deception without the other pressures bad?
- Dove 4y agoPeople make plea deals and write confessions to reduce the punishment if they think they will be convicted. That motivation remains entirely the same even if they think they will be falsely convicted.
- giantg2 4y agoWith access to a lawyer (one of the other issues) this shouldn't be a problem. And there are ways the police are supposed to verify the confession (changes to ensure that could be better).
- qngcdvy 4y agoYou seem to argue strongly in favor of deception, but justifying that it's ok if all the other measures against false convictions are in place (lawyers, police who work by the book...). To me, it's like wearing a safety belt. I mean, if all your driver assistance systems work and all the other drivers pay attention and drive perfectly, you shouldn't need it, right?
- giantg2 4y agoI think the court reviewing the confession and tape of the interrogation would be the safety belt. There are ways to verify confessions even with limited evidence. These false confessions are sloppy work. It seems the courts don't care much for safeguarding against abuses, so maybe the verification steps need some codifying. There also needs to be some utility left to the interview. Sure we don't want to have long, aggressive, or abusive interviews. But how useful would suspect interviews be if you just asked questions based on real information? Sometimes you might get some info, but the smart ones won't be that easy. Sometimes it would be good to use some deception just to gauge what they know, even if you don't get a confession. It's a useful tool that doesn't present any downside with the proper safety measures in place.
- danaris 4y agoJust because one is legally entitled to a lawyer doesn't mean one will a) understand that fully at the time of interrogation, especially if one is a minor or a foreigner b) trust that a court-appointed lawyer will actually work for your best interests c) actually get a court-appointed lawyer who does work for your best interests. So your assumption that someone in this position necessarily has an effective lawyer present, absent other police misconduct, is clearly a flawed assumption.
- giantg2 4y agoMinors can't be interrogated without a representative. The Miranda reading should mean they understand the right to a lawyer. You have to trust that any lawyer will work for your best interest since they tend to be paid regardless of outcome. If they don't work for your best interest and you can prove it, you get a retrial. Same for private attorneys. "So your assumption that someone in this position necessarily has an effective lawyer present, absent other police misconduct, is clearly a flawed assumption." Where is that assumption? They necessarily have access to one. We can what-if all day. The fact is, you have the right to an effective attorney. This is even popularized by TV, and thus common knowledge.
- Volundr 4y ago"We have video putting you at the scene and two eyewitness who picked your mugshot out of a line up. Now if you let this go to trial your looking at at least 15 years, but you seem like a good kid. If you work with me on this I'm sure I can talk to DA into reducing the charges. Probably have you out on parole in 5."
- danaris 4y ago...And, to be clear, the deception here can absolutely also be about what sentence the victim is likely to get. Sign a false confession, and suddenly you find that they're actually only offering you a plea bargain with a minimum of 20 years.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Per_Bothner 4y agoDeception can lead to false confessions (people's memories are very malleable) or plea bargains (accept 2 years vs risking 15 years).
- giantg2 4y agoAren't those false confessions usually the result of the other tactics (long interrogations, intimidation, etc)? I'm wondering if there's some data on deception without these other factors. Even plea bargains aren't a bad thing except if they're abused.
- lucb1e 4y ago> usually the result of the other tactics (long interrogations, intimidation, etc)? That is definitely not required for a false confession. I don't have stats handy, but for another comment (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33146157 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33146157) I was reading up on the Dutch Wikipedia article on false confessions. Reasons for false confessions given there (https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Valse_bekentenis https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Valse_bekentenis) are: - Feeling guilty for what happened, even if it's not your fault - To protect the actual perpetrator - To receive benefits such as contact with one's family, stopping the interrogation, sentence reduction, or to prevent a loved one from also being (further) prosecuted - Due to a pathological need for attention or sensationalism - Thinking you are guilty due to memory problems or other psychological issues such as delusions In one case I heard in de podcast Napleiten, someone gave a false confession because the interviewers said they had video evidence, saying something along the lines of "if you have it on video then I guess I must have done it". She was a teenager, been interviewed for hours on end, and had barely slept the night before in the cell (after she came to the police the day before, expecting to clear up this apparent mix-up where she appeared on some wanted list). The public prosecutor brought a signed confession before the court. The Wikipedia article lists as measures that can lead to further pressure for a false confession: long interrogations, interrogations at unexpected moments, preventing rest or sleep, providing gruesome footage of the event, raising one's voice, saying they can prove it anyway so it is useless to deny it, and obviously things like actual torture (which I'd say sleep deprivation should also count as) or threats thereof. Some of these things might happen inadvertently, such as if someone is already dead on their feet due to no fault of the police's, or if they don't know/realize that discussing gruesome footage is a risk factor for a false confession.
- motoxpro 4y agoHuh? I've never been so saddened by a comment actually. "We have a video of you at the scene of the crime with indisputable evidence. It doesn't matter what you say, there are 10 policemen waiting to testify against you. It's your word against theirs. If you don't take this deal you will go away for life." You don't have money for a lawyer and you have no idea if there are actually 10 policemen waiting to testify against you. Do you take the chance? How is that not problematic?
- giantg2 4y ago"How is that not problematic?" Because that's an unrealistic scenario (based on my other points). You have access to a lawyer even if you don't have money. The confession can (and should) be verified. There are ways to do this with safeguards. "Huh? I've never been so saddened by a comment actually." It sounds like you already have your mind made up. Otherwise I strongly suggest looking into proper interrogation techniques (which avoid abuse but can leverage deception, and uses techniques to verify the confession is true/real).
- motoxpro 4y agoWho verifies the confession? Once I have the confession that I wanted to get, whether because I was biased, malevolent or truly believe I was right, I have no incentive to verify what I just did. I feel like you are living in a fantasy world where people are "good" and "legal" all the time. This scenario right here proves otherwise. The sad part is just that people have opinions about things from a theoretical point of view who have never lived out what happens in the real world. I know from close friends that what you are describing just doesn't always happen.
- giantg2 4y ago"I feel like you are living in a fantasy world where people are "good" and "legal" all the time." "The sad part is just that people have opinions about things from a theoretical point of view who have never lived out what happens in the real world." You don't know me or my experiences. It's sad to see someone on HN blindly attack someone. Because from my perspective, you seem to be the one who is uninformed. Please do some research on the methods of taking and verifying confessions.
- pas 4y agothe problem with false conviction is that both an innocent gets punished and the guilty goes unpunished. worst of both worlds.
- giantg2 4y agoIt seems you're skipping the actual question. We know that false convictions are wrong. What I'm asking is why deception during questioning would lead to that (absent the other abuses and with confession verification).