2 ms·
Advertising does not require tracking. Remember over the air television and all it’s free news broadcasts.
by Retric 4y ago
Advertising does not require tracking. Remember over the air television and all it’s free news broadcasts.
- nalaz 4y agoAdvertising with tracking barely covers costs, imagine without it.
- Retric 4y agoCompetitive markets reach equilibrium. With or without tracking it’s going to barely cover costs because otherwise more people enter the market due to minimal barriers to entry.
- wavefunction 4y agoSometimes equilibrium is 0.
- Retric 4y agoWe had ad supported websites well before tracking, so that seems like a non sequitur.
- happymellon 4y agoIt think that means that advertising is not going to save content, and people will have to think of alternative revenue streams, because revenue from advertising is only going to go down.
- naasking 4y agoAdvertising without tracking would arguably cost less. Even if it makes less, it's not clear that the margin would be worse or non-viable.
- modeless 4y agoOh, I remember. They sucked! Both the ads and the news they funded.
- Retric 4y agoFeel free to link to all these advertising supported websites better than Seinfeld. I could use a good laugh. News was hit or miss. They did a lot of serious investigative reporting, but newspapers where simply a better medium for personalized in depth coverage.
- modeless 4y agoIf I had to choose between network television and YouTube, I would choose YouTube every day of the week and twice on Sunday. I mean, I enjoy Seinfeld too, but on the whole YouTube is both more entertaining and vastly more useful and educational than network television. Not because the content has the highest production values, but because the content matches my interests and needs. That's the true power of targeted advertising. It allows creators to focus on niches that can't be served by content produced for a mass audience. Even large 'niches' get dumbed down to the lowest common denominator for network television. Case in point: Here's Jay Leno interviewing Elon Musk about SpaceX Starship for network television [1] vs YouTuber Tim Dodd [2]. Leno's program is fine for people who don't follow space. For my niche Dodd is vastly better, but he can't draw a wide enough audience to make money on non-targeted ads like Leno can. And the thing is, everyone has their niches. There is no large population of people out there who are average in every way and need the network television version of everything. The average person doesn't exist. [1] Leno: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wluBlr1j4qk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wluBlr1j4qk [2] Dodd: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t705r8ICkRw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t705r8ICkRw
- Retric 4y agoDodd got 6 million people watching a 1 hour segment. That valuable even without advertising targeting beyond estimates of viewership based on content. Now, you can quibble about how much targeting increase revenue but the funny thing about total advertising is it’s fairly consistent through time. Tracking failed to significantly increase worldwide advertising spend, it only redirects it.
- johannes1234321 4y agoJust look at Google. They became big by ads on the search site. Analysing the intent, not the history. If I search for a pen I want to buy a pen, thus an ad for buying a pen might be effective. If I bought a pen a day ago it is unlikely I am interested in pens for next few weeks. Look at the context of where the ad appears and match that. To some degree that is how ads worked in print: In a magazine about horseback riding you will find ads about riding equipment, as readers are into that while reading.
- wavefunction 4y agoGoogle bought doubleclick early on which is definitely ad tracking and not intent. It's important to remember the full history.
- Retric 4y agoGoogle launched in 1998 and didn’t buy double click until 2008 when they could afford to spend 3.1 billion on it. So that was hardly an early purchase or required for extreme profitability.
- wizofaus 4y ago"If I bought a pen a day ago it is unlikely I am interested in pens for next few weeks" And yet whenever I buy anything online I'm inundated with ads for said item. In fact I almost wish there were an officially sanctioned/ standardised way of updating your status as a tracked user on various products you might be interested in or have in fact now purchased with no need to buy another soon. As it is I still see ads for baby formula on YouTube despite having had no need to purchase it for over 16 years (and I honestly would expect Google should know that about me, though when I ask Google Assist how old my children are it refuses to tell me...)
- belorn 4y agoGoogle ad became big, television and news papers advertisement became small. The reasons were very obvious. Google don't need to follow local law and regulations. Google don't need to employ people to verify content or take legal responsibility. Google can track users and thus categorize users in much more fine details than television and news papers ever could. A magazine about horseback riding might have a vague idea about who their readers are, but google can find out that a pregnant teenage girl has yet to tell her parents.