4 ms·
Some people believe in the right to doctor-assisted suicide. I don't know anyone who advocates that suicide drugs should be available over the counter to anyone
by lolinder 4y ago
Some people believe in the right to doctor-assisted suicide. I don't know anyone who advocates that suicide drugs should be available over the counter to anyone who's feeling suicidal today.
- guerrilla 4y ago> I don't know anyone who advocates that suicide drugs should be available over the counter to anyone who's feeling suicidal today. Seems like that would fall under basic bodily autonomy. Why should a doctor gatekeep something so important...
- chalst 4y agoBecause teenagers with suicidal thoughts are most often lacking the sense of perspective about their situation they would gain with maturity. This is a case where rigidly-based reasoning about rights fails the common-sense test.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe full set of human rights is for legally consenting adults. Minors have only a subset of those rights.
- chmod775 4y ago> I don't know anyone who advocates that suicide drugs should be available over the counter to anyone who's feeling suicidal today. Chances are on HN you'll find people sufficiently detached from reality to advocate for this.
- x86x87 4y agoWhy is it legal to buy a gun but illegal to decide to end your own life? The hypocrisy is through the roof. How are we free if we are forced to live? Btw: we should not encourage suicide. I think we need to help people that are in a position where they are considering and also there are things that are deeply f'ed with our society to begin with that slowly push people to this (ie helping suicidal people is a drop in the bucket if we don't fix fundamental issues)
- aldanor 4y agoThe point, IIUC, is not in being forced to live - it's that ending your own life may, in this way or another (like in this example with Amazon), explicitly or implicitly, encourage others to end theirs, who would not have went for it otherwise.
- x86x87 4y agoHonest question: how many people do you believe end their life like this because of the recommendation vs actually researching it before and they atr just buying the stuff? If it's because of the reco: how do we ensure that we ban all other possible lethal combos? Disable recommendations? Ban certain things?
- vharuck 4y ago>Why is it legal to buy a gun but illegal to decide to end your own life? AFAIK, in the US, suicide is not a crime. Assisting in another person's suicide is a crime in most states. As the post you're replying to said, we could allow physicians to offer painless and dignified deaths after the patient proves they are of sound mind or will never recover from a horrible condition. Much like the courts recognize there can be reasonable limits to purchasing and possessing guns. Admittedly, I don't know what fraction of those who commit suicide do so because of a temporary mental state they could recover from with help, but I'm guessing it's the majority. If so, it'd be inhumane to remove basic barriers that might save people, even if it'd make it easier for the smaller group of people who "rightly" believe they would rather die. This is a complex topic that touches on so many sore spots in society. But that's when I most doubt all-or-nothing stances. They tend to come from strong emotions rather than reason.
- x86x87 4y agoSo let's be real for one sec. As an adult you will find a way to kill youself if this is the goal. We are hypothesing that people don't want to actually do it and that we are doing the a service from preventing it. This could be the case - but how many people decide to end their life on a whim? Re: recovering with help. That was one of the main things i had in mind. If the factors that lead you to suicide and/or drive you insane are not removed do you actually believe that stopping you from the final act is going to be effective? As a society we don't give 2 shits about people that are struggling. Money is our religion everything else is secondary :(
- moistly 4y ago> I don't know anyone who advocates that suicide drugs should be available over the counter to anyone who's feeling suicidal today. This is how you end up with acetaminophen banned from gas station convenience stores and locked up behind the pharmacy counter. Or, for that matter, prohibition of alcohol, undoubtedly the most popular way to slowly kill yourself.