5 ms·
I think two things get mixed up (not by you)... a lot of sites, especially American ones, only started showing any kind of notice/request for consent once GDPR
by throwaway821909 4y ago
I think two things get mixed up (not by you)... a lot of sites, especially American ones, only started showing any kind of notice/request for consent once GDPR came in. But there was another wave before that, which everyone called the "cookie law" but which is apparently the ePrivacy Directive.
A couple of interesting bits from https://www.privacypolicies.com/blog/eu-cookie-law/ https://www.privacypolicies.com/blog/eu-cookie-law/
"On the other hand, providing your customers with a customized user experience or tailored product suggestions is not a requirement for an online store, and cookies that enable these features do not fall under the "strictly necessary" category. You'll need to get consent before you use them."
"Depending on your country's interpretation of the law, you may only need to get a user's "implied consent." Rather than forcing every user to click "accept" ... you can instead display a short message informing them that cookies are being used, typically through a header bar or some other non-obstructive method. After a predefined period of time ... the announcement can disappear."
I think what happened is that a lot of sites went for non-compliance or implied consent until the GDPR came in requiring proper consent for most cookies and harsher penalties (?) and everyone went from 0 to 100. But people were complaining about & blocking even the implied consent banners when they first came in. Now everyone thinks the GDPR is about cookies but it's really about tracking.
- hnbad 4y agoAdditionally the ePrivacy law was revised to e.g. mandate that if an "accept all" button is present it can not be given more visual weight than a "deny all and continue" button. Most (especially American) sites are currently in violation of this requirement as they try to get away with making it annoying to not opt-in to everything.
- denton-scratch 4y ago> typically through a header bar or some other non-obstructive method. Those are obstructive too. Just respect my DNT header; if you don't want to serve me the page after seeing what my preference is, don't show me the page, and I won't read it. I know when I'm not wanted. There are plenty more sites on the web.