9 ms·
Modeling Starlink Capacity
- aimor 4y agoI'm not understanding why Starlink is limited in terms of how many cells it can serve by beam hopping. What's driving the analyst's choices for the different "TDM split" and "beam spread" values? I naively expected the system to have much more granularity than 10% TDM splits.
- wmf 4y agoBeam hopping adds latency and jitter because packets have to wait for the beam to become available. For example if they use a ~1 ms superframe and they want to limit jitter to 20 ms they couldn't split more than 20:1. Beam hopping also cuts available throughput. If they're promising 100 Mbps they can't slice things too finely.
- aimor 4y agoThanks for the explanation. It raises the next question about how small a superframe can be, which I imagine as they get smaller makes efficient scheduling a more difficult problem.
- TruthWillHurt 4y agoMy brain melted. Amazing stuff!
- vanattab 4y ago>I explicitly do not authorize any organization or entity to cite this article, or the results obtained by the simulation, for inclusion in filings with any regulatory body under any jurisdiction. Would this be in anyway binding? Can you say someone is not allowed to link to my blog?
- lazide 4y agoProbably not, but it does make it clear to anyone following references what was intended use or not. Which can be helpful.
- lettergram 4y agoWhile awesome they should really note the CPU usage upfront before linking to the site lol My phone feels like it may catch fire
- jsjohnst 4y ago> My phone feels like it may catch fire Sounds like a design defect of your phone. Might consider getting something which isn’t a fire safety hazard just by visiting a random website.
- walterbell 4y ago> The calculations required to run a single snapshot can become massive, taking up considerable CPU resources from your computer, and locking the browser for a long time. A large country with 30k cells, served by 150 satellites, each with 48 spot beams, could require up to 216 million calculations.
- jiveturkey 4y ago> 216 million calculations Is that a lot?
- pixelpoet 4y agoIt's a tiny amount of computation for any processor of the last two decades. How well those resources are used is another question...
- nawgz 4y ago216 million functions involving a few FP operands is going to take multiple seconds of CPU compute if the entirety of the CPU cycles were efficiently dedicated to said compute, due to the single thread nature; so I would guess yes, it's a fair amount of compute for a phone or something that will use loads of cycles on other scheduled topics
- lettergram 4y agoThat section was after the link to the site, but sure.
- NotYourLawyer 4y ago> I explicitly do not authorize any organization or entity to cite this article, or the results obtained by the simulation, for inclusion in filings with any regulatory body under any jurisdiction. Interesting. I wonder if you’d actually need the author’s authorization to cite his work in such a way.
- sangnoir 4y agoIf feels a lot like those YouTube uploader disclaimers to me: makes the author feel good, but probably won't mean much in a court of law - if it comes to that. IANAL
- adastra22 4y agoYou don’t and that restriction is toothless.
- icegreentea2 4y agoYou don't need the author's authorization. However, any regulatory body reviewing your filing and following up on your sources might find your choice questionable.
- Rygian 4y agoYou don't need it. You can go ahead and use without authorization. The regulator will then simply dismiss your filing for using unacceptable sources.
- m463 4y agoit seems to be on medium.com so they could do all they could probably do what they want with it. Also, I thought the court said linking to something was ok, no matter what the content.
- yokem55 4y agoSure, but an opposing party could then easily call it out as bad evidence. "Commissioner/your honor, the author themselves didn't this was any good for use in court".
- 4y ago
- jxf 4y agoThis is some really fantastic, detailed analysis. I'm almost always impressed by the synthesis of knowledge required to be authoritative on expansive topics like this one.
- sebsebmc 4y agoOutstanding work, I wrote an incredibly naive simulator of Starlink coverage using H3 over a year ago before we even knew that Starlink was using H3 internally. The community over in r/Starlink wrote some other simulations too and we all stopped short of actually calculating based on gateway reachability and ISLs weren't in use yet either.
- kanbara 4y agoi love H3 and got my last company to use it internally for _something_, will try to use it again now
- ge96 4y agoThis looks great, glad there is that listen feature. I'm interested in the subject but it's a good read. It is amazing the coverage of just one.
- cycomanic 4y agoSomething not covered in the article, but I have wondered about. How does Starlink do the handover? The satellites are in Leo and thus have orbit times of around 90min or so (not sure about the exact number), so every cell must be served by several satellites at the same time no? Otherwise we would see significant interruptions at the handover.
- kanbara 4y agowell, some (or all?) have laser links now, so as another sat gets covisibility with a ground station and user terminal, it can just instantly pass the traffic off without laser link, it's looks to me that most of the time in populated latitudes, there will be more than one sat's beams covering a cell, and if not then there would be interruption in coverage the terminal should handle transmitting to multiple sats that are close by, but i dunno how omnidirectional the dishy is
- wmf 4y agoI assume the satellites are synced so the handoff could be scheduled in advance and done in milliseconds. All you'd notice is some jitter. I don't think it's any harder than driving on a highway where you'd do a cellular handoff every two minutes or so.
- viczsaszbo 4y agoThe beam hopping (TDM) part of the article is similar to satellite handover. There's a lag before a beam returns to a location or a new beam is over a location, and the beams can't overlap (nco=1).
- kidme5 4y agoFunny people think Starlink is mainly a commercial enterprise. Since Teledesic in the 90s, these low earth orbit constellation projects have always been about stepping towards the real goal, which started with Strategic Defense Initiative and now embodied in the Space Development Agency
- tra3 4y agoI’m not in the know…can you ELI5?
- kidme5 4y agohttps://youtu.be/KsPLmb6gAdw?t=55m47s https://youtu.be/KsPLmb6gAdw?t=55m47s But a historical prerequisite is understanding https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_Defense_Initiative https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_Defense_Initiative unless you're old enough to remember. Then carefully read Mike Griffin's career history: https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_D._Griffin#Career https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_D._Griffin#Career
- xwolfi 4y agoYou're unable to summarize ? How d you explain to a child who cannot yet google ?
- diimdeep 4y agoThis is eye-opener, OMFG
- irthomasthomas 4y agoThat whole spacex origin myth is ridiculous. Musk goes to Russia to buy an ICBM? Right. Then, having never touched a rocket, Musk is given $400M to start spacex? Ok.
- adastra22 4y agoMusk wasn’t given $400M to start SpaceX. What are you talking about? He self-funded with money from PayPal until the first successful Falcon 1 launch.
- blobbers 4y agoThis is an amazing simulation. It feels like the type of tool that would be used internally to monitor the entire system. I'm truly impressed / shocked that people have the capacity and will to be build such amazing things as side projects!
- comboy 4y agoMind boggling. If author is around here I'd love to know how much time did this project require. Everything seems so polished. Aesthetics alone are something that many big projects could learn from.