3 ms·
Ah hydro... Explains most cases, not really realistic in others. Though there is some interesting cases, but likely even those are hard to replicate.
by Ekaros 4y ago
Ah hydro... Explains most cases, not really realistic in others. Though there is some interesting cases, but likely even those are hard to replicate.
- ceejayoz 4y agoSure. You do hydro in Norway. Solar in Spain. Wind in the North Sea. Geothermal in Iceland. Different places, different forms of generation. Trade regionally for redundancy. The question was “why isn’t anyone doing it”; the answer is “they are”.
- Ekaros 4y agoBut other than hydro and geothermal do those run 24/7/365? And is the storage in place? Or do they rely on some others to fullfil those? What if that isn't an option lets say middle of desert?
- natch 4y agoYes, wind runs 24/7/365. And cars have their own storage, so that's solved for cars at least. Let's say in the middle of the desert… Well, if there are no people there, then perhaps there is no need for power. And if there are people, they can choose to live a primitive lifestyle, or they can buy batteries and solar panels and wind generators, or (shocker) they can continue to use petroleum products for energy, that is also an option even if the world switches to renewable energy.
- ceejayoz 4y agoWind runs at night. Solar doesn't, but demand is correspondingly lower at night, too. Storage will evolve as the need evolves, just like cell phone batteries did.
- dublin 4y agoI call B.S. There is NO reason to believe this. Unrealistic confidence in the progress of battery technology is not new - it's been the state of things for well over a century now. (See Edison's Nickel-Iron battery, for one...) Sometimes real breakthroughs are required in science, engineering, or both. In the case of really useful batteries, which we do NOT have today, it's definitely both. These BREAKTHROUGHS (not incremental improvements!) are REQUIRED to do the things envisioned in the article. These breakthroughs may come tomorrow, OR we may be in the same situation with battery technology that we are with nuclear fusion: It's the energy of the future, and always will be - We've been "only 30 years away" from a fusion breakthrough and "power too cheap to meter" for at least 75 years now!