4 ms·
It might not even be legal to ship motherboards with fully open-source firmware, especially if it has WiFi/Bluetooth baked in. Once you add anything related to
by smoldesu 4y ago
It might not even be legal to ship motherboards with fully open-source firmware, especially if it has WiFi/Bluetooth baked in. Once you add anything related to networking in your stack, the chance of running FOSS firmware goes out the window. It's all very lock-and-key stuff, according to... <squints at piece of paper> ...the United States Government.
- paulryanrogers 4y agoWhy? Because of FCC requirements around radio emissions?
- runnerup 4y agoYeah the firmware can control the gain/broadcast power and exceed FCC limits. It can be open source still, but modifying it and running the modified version would invalidate the FCC certification and running non certified transmitters is generally frowned upon, often illegal, depending on precise circumstances.
- RF_Savage 4y agoNot even the running, but sale of. If it's too easy to modify then FCC will make it's sale illegal. Nobody wants that risk for their product.
- mmis1000 4y agoActually linux distro package repo have the list and the way to compile and load into system for obvious reasons. (Otherwise how do they compile the wifi drivers for themselves?) But no one is even going to say how to actually do it publicly because it is illegal to do (and probably also unsafe to do).
- somat 4y agoAnd yet I can buy an sdr 400mhz-6ghz no problem? sigh, whatever, things are never fair. I will say the thing that pisses me off about thinkpads is their use of a whitelist to limit radios. their justification for this was the same. "it's certified as a radio antenna pair, the fcc will not let us let you install whatever radio you want" which is bullshit.
- wildzzz 4y agoThe price of an SDR is usually much more than a basic WiFi card so that's kind of the justification for why an SDR doesn't require an FCC license since it's for experimental purposes and that you probably have a good reason to be using one. If you use one outside what you are licensed to do so, then expect the FCC to come down on you. The FCC license for consumer goods is a way for a manufacter to say that the product conforms to the applicable rules so that the FCC doesn't have to worry about every end-user fucking around with the spectrum.
- AngryData 4y agoAnd yet I can buy a Microtik router that just has dropdown boxes for selecting options that would get the FCC to bust down my door. I think it is far more likely that they just don't want to expose what would then be obvious security vulnerabilities and/or built-in backdoors.
- Nextgrid 4y agoIf that's the only problem, it shouldn't be too hard to limit either in hardware or have the HW run the user-provided firmware in some rudimentary VM that essentially passes through everything except the commands that set TX power; that way you maintain compliance without restricting people from running their own software. I think however it's just a matter of time before these restrictions become obsolete anyway: 1) I'm not sure whether the possibility of violating FCC regulations is something that will be used in practice by enough people to be a problem (you might get the odd one out here and there, but see the point below) 2) People who intentionally want to violate FCC regulations can already do so in plenty of ways - SDRs are becoming cheaper and cheaper and there's basically no way to prevent their import, so I'm not sure why they'll even bother with a wireless card if their aim is to truly cause mischief and shit on restricted radio bands.
- yakak 4y agoTivoization features have to prevent you from running other code. Anyone relying on preventing the reading of source to avoid modifications is living on the knife's edge with regulators.
- dylan604 4y agoWould there be any traction with a mobo that did not have any of that stuff built-in? There's a lot of advantages to no longer needing expansion cards for networking, so I seriously doubt anyone wants to go back to that. A laptop with a bunch USB dongles connected to a hub could be a doable solve to keep that gear off the mobo.
- p1necone 4y agoCould you leave an empty socket for a wifi controller chip but still build in the antennas? Although that would likely lock you into whatever chip had the right pin out which seems a bit pointless.
- derefr 4y agoWhy not just have the wifi-controller hardware already there, but strip out the software required to make it do anything? I.e. modularize the BIOS firmware such that you flash "the BIOS firmware" and "the wifi/bluetooth stack firmware" separately, to separate chips. Then ship the motherboard without the wifi/bluetooth stack firmware pre-flashed — with the NAND that the wifi controller initializes from, just empty, such that the wifi controller immediately halts on boot, and the CPU doesn't find it on the bus. Make sure the rest of the BIOS works without the wifi controller "up". And then have an open root key of trust for the BIOS (= you can sign your own BIOS), but a closed root key of trust for the wifi controller (= only the OEM can sign the wifi/bluetooth stack firmware.) It doesn't seem like it would be all that hard, given that we already have this kind of hardware firmware (+ firmware storage) modularity in modern devices in other ways — e.g. most trackpads have their own isolated firmware, that the host can flash to update, but which isn't otherwise accessed by the host CPU, rather only the trackpad microcontroller itself; where the trackpad firmware flash lives inside the trackpad, not in the host.
- dylan604 4y agoSeems like this kind of radio chip would be standard pin out in 2022. Could you not just put one of those chips like Broadcom makes that has all the radio formats on it? Even sell it as a "kit" so that it comes with it but you have to install yourself to meet "regulations" or licensing terms. The first gen of Thunderbolt add-on came as PCIe due to some sort licensing issue instead of on the mobo directly
- tenebrisalietum 4y agoI've never understood this because I can attach any USB adapter I want and it works.
- pabs3 4y agoDespite that, the Atheros WiFi vendor released source code for their WiFi firmware at least twice: https://wiki.debian.org/Firmware/Open#Radio https://wiki.debian.org/Firmware/Open#Radio
- KingMachiavelli 4y agoIt would still be significantly better if mobos ran coreboot (or some open source firmware) with some binary blobs for WiFi/Bluetooth. It's not out of the ordinary to have this arrangement; the newer Nvidia GPUs support open source kernel modules because they use encrypted binary blobs to lock down actual functionality. The WiFi/Bluetooth chips could even have open source firmware but require a signed hash of that firmware binary.