4 ms·
In an ideal world, yes. Blind signatures and all that. But that isn't how collection-maximizing surveillance companies work. Right now, the lowest friction is
by mindslight 4y ago
In an ideal world, yes. Blind signatures and all that.
But that isn't how collection-maximizing surveillance companies work. Right now, the lowest friction is to ask for birthdays where they can get away with it, but never really verify. If the law gives them a reason to verify, then the incentive is to expand their plaintext-based all-knowing systems to perform verification.
Sure, we'd likely see a startup that promises to do privacy-respecting age verification, but it would go nowhere. What incentive would there be for Google et al to adopt it, as opposed to say just requesting your driving license number with a message implying that California "made" them to do this ? The companies without the cloud to demand personal info would then outsource the verification to the bigger surveillance companies.
- mistrial9 4y agounfortunately, there are Thiel-like support services in the wings actively building business bridges at every step. Some elements in society really do try to get paid to surveil others, and that will continue. I predict only hard-won litigation, meaningful laws with enforcement, and public discussion like this, will slow the slide on the slippery slope.
- mindslight 4y ago"Some" ? The entire market cap of modern Silicon Valley is based upon monetizing surveillance. This topic demonstrates one of the main pathologies of the US model of governance. Instead of pushing constructive actionable privacy restrictions for everyone, the government is poised to create another hook that merely emboldens corporate control. What we need is a US GDPR with an analogous definition of consent - if implementing functionality to examine and delete my data is too hard, then just don't store surveillance records about me in the first place! But what we'll end up getting is ineffectual nonsense to be nullified with more clickwrap legalese that nobody reads.
- mistrial9 4y ago> The entire market cap of modern Silicon Valley is based upon monetizing surveillance. no, its not.. but a bulk of FB/Google dollars that are, dwarfs a lot of other things.. its a sick situation, I can agree with that.. important to speak out