8 ms·
Calif. Law to Protect Children's Privacy Could Lead to Invasive Age Verification
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- THENATHE 4y agoMaybe we should just parent better. Seriously. If your kid is so young that they can’t figure out if they should or shouldn’t be watching a particular YouTube video on their own, they shouldn’t be on YouTube to begin with.
- phendrenad2 4y agoThis bill accomplishes nothing for the children, but (much like the GDPR) imposes onerous recordskeeping on site owners, which just serves to keep the bar to entry high. Great news for MAANGA! Bad news for startups.
- mintaka5 4y ago
- O__________O 4y agoReally strange to me that given its obviously possible to securely verify someone’s age without requiring personally identifiable information at the endpoint requiring verification (or for the system verifying attributes to know the endpoint requesting verification) that anyone would even want that information flowing through their systems — unless they wanted the information for other reasons. To me, unless the prior technological features I just mentioned are baked into the law, this feels like it’s either intentional or laws are being crafted by people that have no clue what they’re doing. More generally speaking, governments should start seeing the hoarding of data by itself and others as a national security threat, open source any government systems — and offer bounties for anyone able to maintain the objectives of a system while reducing the system’s access to sensitive data. ______________ * EDIT: 100% sure that it’s technically possible to have an endpoint anonymously verify age and a verification system to do so without knowing the endpoint requesting the verification, but unable to find technical explanation of how this might be done using existing technology; might be wrong, but believe it included a combination of differential privacy and zero knowledge proofs. Does anyone have a link to detailed explanation of how to implement such a system?
- readams 4y agoIt's the last one. It's just very poorly drafted legislation that hasn't been thought through. this is our one party rule in action. With no meaningful opposition, laws are not scrutinized and unintended consequences never considered.
- jeffbee 4y agoThere are 29 members of the state legislature who are not in the "one party" and exactly zero people voted against this bill at any stage. It passed 72-0 in one chamber and 33-0 in the other.
- wrayjustin 4y agoArguably, "one party" in this sense could mean "rulers."
- jeffbee 4y agoIt could mean that, if you're juvenile or just stupid. It's a democratically-elected, bicameral, proportionally representative legislature with an independent executive elected in a non-partisan race.
- tick_tock_tick 4y agoJust look at AB5 for a perfect example.
- loeg 4y agoIt’s poorly thought out legislation, but it’s not like the GOP is known for writing good law.
- sandworm101 4y agoSimple questions: CD or vinyl? That will identify everyone old enough to remember. Then the classic: how do you tame a horse in minecraft, which identifies everyone under 18.
- sul_tasto 4y agowhy can’t we just protect everyone’s privacy?
- LegionMammal978 4y agoI'm surprised how little this issue has come up in the past, given how much many here are focused on privacy. This issue can be seen even today on YouTube. When I browse videos, I usually do so in FF's private browsing mode, primarily to prevent the recommendations from spilling over into my main account. However, videos marked as age-restricted cannot be viewed without logging into a Google account. Even yt-dlp couldn't download age-restricted videos without credentials when I last attempted it! (I hear there has since been a patch to fix this, but I have not tested it to see if it still works.) And apparently, EU users are sometimes required to upload their government ID to YouTube to prove they are over 18. I get that privacy issues can be most sensitive to those under 18, but it's important to recognize that enforcing far stronger privacy restrictions alongside strong age-verification expectations (no more "are you 18+? yes/no" or "what is your birthday?" questions) can only come at the expense of anonymous browsing.
- kybernetyk 4y agohttps://github.com/zerodytrash/Simple-YouTube-Age-Restriction-Bypass https://github.com/zerodytrash/Simple-YouTube-Age-Restrictio... https://greasyfork.org/en/scripts/423851-simple-youtube-age-restriction-bypass https://greasyfork.org/en/scripts/423851-simple-youtube-age-... Works fine for me on FireFox + Greasemonkey
- 14 4y agoI want to come back to this comment later and try these out. Thanks
- O__________O 4y agoNote that you have to trust the proxy injecting age verification on behalf of the user is not logging data, being malicious, etc; if they are running targeted attacks, this would be very hard to detect; for example, say the proxy was run by China and user requests a video that’s clearly anti-China; to be clear, NOT saying this is the case, just that it does require trusting a proxy, which generally speaking are hostile to users.
- O__________O 4y ago
- cscurmudgeon 4y agoOnce again good intentioned but bumbling idiots make things worse: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/09/opinion/democrats-blue-states-legislation.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/09/opinion/democrats-blue-st...
- deathgripsss 4y agoThis was floated around in the UK for porn websites and was an absolute disaster for the government: https://theconversation.com/amp/why-age-verification-is-another-flawed-attempt-to-regulate-online-pornography-in-the-uk-176762 https://theconversation.com/amp/why-age-verification-is-anot...
- kybernetyk 4y agoGermany did this for porn sites and there's 0 German porn sites anymore. At least 0 that do officially business out of Germany.
- thebooktocome 4y agoCzechia is a very nice country and is right across the border.
- 4gotunameagain 4y agoIn Germany you have to verify yourself with google to download dating apps. They only accept credit cards (debit cards being the norm in Europe), effectively forcing you to send a photo of your passport to Google. Very nice. Bravo. And Germans supposedly pride themselves for their privacy concerns.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deathgripsss 4y agoCan you access American porn sites in Germany without verification?
- kybernetyk 4y agoyes. but no one claimed german legislation would make any sense :)
- jjluoma 4y agoGoogle provides two alternatives for age verification, a credit card payment and sending an electronic copy of a valid government issued ID. This explanation seems to be quite terse, "If you use a credit card, any temporary authorization will be fully refunded. If you use an ID, Google will delete the image after verifying your age." Both methods would require me to provide them (or some other entity) new personal data. In the case of credit card payment, credit card number (and thus what bank I am using, maybe also what kind of card I have) and my home address. My government issued ID has also other information like a photo of me, my signature, social security number, all my given names and card number. I wonder if they would accept an electronic copy that would have all those covered.
- lisper 4y agoThe Right Way to do this is to develop a standard for web pages to identify themselves as not suitable for children, and then build clients with a setting that locks out those pages (which could be disabled only with a passcode or some such security measure). Then it becomes the responsibility of parents to insure that the lockout is enabled no the devices their children have access to.
- EarlKing 4y agoNo, the right way to do this is to stop trying to use legislation to do the jobs of parents. Stop expecting the world to nerf itself so you can be a lazier parent.
- mjevans 4y agoReverse that. All things should be considered UNRATED (adult) by default. Adults that want to should set a flag in the OS account, which should be passed along (or optionally also set as a child account) by browsing software. In child safe mode such software would then follow a set of local policy decisions and refuse to operate with content not declared child safe. Such an account feature might also forward the data to other accounts for review (parent, guardian, teacher, etc). THEN, the enforcement, sites which incorrectly claim to be a given rating should get hit with the charges that enables.
- jvalencia 4y agoI really like this. An industry enforced standard with consequences would stop most problems.
- out-of-ideas 4y agoAgreed; the ISP is paid by an adult, adult paid for computer/tv/ect, and its the adult to state when said child can operate such equipment. Last I'm aware said adults dont let children watch TV completely unrestricted (having an adult locking adulty-content). It should be up to parent/guardian to oversee what kid is doing and lock them out, with younger kids getting more supervised attention. Keep our IDs/PII/phonenumbers out of browsing the web. We could go a step further by banning highly accurate fingerprinting and make things nice n generic; hopefully making ads as generic as the wonderful ads as-seen-on-tv.
- exabrial 4y agoKyc can easily be done with provable privacy, but that’s now how it’ll be implemented because SV and the people that work there do not value consent nor privacy.
- gtirloni 4y agoWhat I don't like about these news is how abstract they are. Sure, it could lead to age information leaking but my imagination isn't working to figure out how that would impact me in a concrete way. Anyone could share possible bad outcomes?
- novok 4y agoIt forces internet usage to be attached to real identities, in order to make sure your not breaking the laws with children, and all the bad, bad consequences that can come from that. And if you don't see how that can be an issue, you have lived a blessed life where you or your family & friends were not prosecuted by violent authoritarian governments arms, that exist in liberal democracies today or discriminated against for minority attribute X, both of which exist even in Scandinavia today.
- gtirloni 4y agoOK, so the theory is that age will be another signal in profiling users for $purpose. Thanks.
- novok 4y agoIt wont 'just' be age, it will be hard verified identities vs. vague fingerprints dependent on the user playing ball with their browser software and not using VPNs. Otherwise how would they actually know the user's age?
- mwint 4y agoMore that the process of verifying age leaks a lot of unrelated information.
- ars 4y ago"The law also mandates that businesses make it obvious to children when they are being monitored or location-tracked (by a parent, guardian, or any other consumer)" This just horrifies me. Silicon valley companies have already made it incredibly hard to parent children, with things like disappearing photos, and locked down phones given even to young children. Like I get 16 years and up needing stuff like that, but younger than that? Parents should be able to see what's going on their kids life. These days 90% of their life is in the phone, which is the one place blocked from parents. In the past children had a limited circle of people in contact with them, and for the most part parents knew who was talking to their children. These days? It's the entire world who has access.
- YeBanKo 4y agoIf you live in a state, that allows ballot measures, then get involved. Looking at whats happening in legislature in the US it is unlikely they will produce anything with sensible approach to privacy. California had couple of iterations of CCPA and so far it is not looking that good either, but worth trying.