3 ms·
> So why is it better to be harmful and unfixable than harmful and fixable? In terms of the harm, it isn't better; harmful is harmful. A non-programmable devi
by kazinator 4y ago
> So why is it better to be harmful and unfixable than harmful and fixable?
In terms of the harm, it isn't better; harmful is harmful.
A non-programmable device is more freedom-respecting than one that is only programmable by a vendor. It causes users to have some blackbox whose future behaviors are controlled by third parties.
The situation with the non-programmable device is a vacuous truth. Like why is it possible that "all crows in set X are black" if X is an empty set? Yet not if X is a set containing one white crow?
"Nobody can program this device" implies that users are just as free to program the device as the vendors and their cohorts.
The statement "any firmware that can be flashed onto this device is allowed to be a nice, clean-smelling piece of GNU software" is a logically true statement, if the set of what can be flashed is empty. The statement becomes false when the set of what can be flashed becomes nonempty, and excludes free software.
It's a waste of time to try to fix your definitions in order to eliminate "weird" vacuous truths.
It's like trying to change the definition of what is a black crow so that not all crows are black in an empty murder of crows.