6 ms·
Candidate Insists Google Blocking His Website; He Requested It Not Be Indexed
- rippercushions 4y agoOr, you know, he had his campaign website built by the lowest bidder, they for whatever reason accidentally included or forgot to remove the noindex tag, and the candidate wasn't aware of this and genuinely thought he was getting censored by Google. But it's awfully hard to generate outrage on either side of the aisle with such a boring explanation.
- hericium 4y agoTherefore "option two is that the guy who might soon be in charge of Arizona state elections is so incompetent and so stupid that he accidentally blocked Google from searching his website" "Blocked" or "hired people who blocked" is the same thing in relation to a guy who wants to be elected to run things.
- bombcar 4y agoIf stupidity was a disqualification from political office we’d run out of politicians quite quickly. Google Search Console is pretty good on digging into this, we discovered that a portion of our website was unsearchable because a plug-in was adding a meta tag to those posts.
- stavros 4y ago> If stupidity was a disqualification from political office we’d run out of politicians quite quickly. And that would be bad how?
- rapind 4y ago> If stupidity was a disqualification from political office we’d run out of politicians quite quickly. Nah, we’d have smarter politicians. Maybe with a bit less charisma, but clearing out the blow hards would bring them to the top.
- belltaco 4y agoSo the first step would be to ask them why it isn't showing up on Google right?
- bigiain 4y ago“Because as we told you when your invoice became overdue, we do not take the noindex tag off until the invoice is paid in full.”
- csydas 4y agoI think the point is less about the technical acumen of a given candidate and what their tech team may or may not have done. It's about that the result of what probably was an innocent mistake is a deep-state conspiracy theory being pushed as a huge censorship narrative. The situation itself seems stupidly simple to me and I would concur the likeliest explanation is someone just made a mistake. But the questions I have are: 1. How did the candidate notice that their site was not being indexed/shown? 2. What did they check once they realized it? Did they ask the team behind the site or anyone how this might happen? 3. If the candidate did, what did the team respond? What investigation was done? 4. What specific elements led to the conclusion of "Deep State Algorithm"? What specifically brought about this as a conclusion to publicly post about? It's possible the candidate was misled and told "everything was fine" from the site side, but I guess for me it's still a huge leap to go from "Everything with the site is fine but it's not showing in searches" to "there is a conspiracy to censor what I am saying". It's not about what technology _might_ exist to accomplish such a thing, it's about what was actually checked and done before this conclusion was reached. That a conspiracy theory was the only promoted conclusion from the candidate is the frustrating part for me, as checking their other tweets and publications, there's no indication anything else was considered. The article itself is being catty and while it's funny to think it's just a case of a politician staging outrage, the core problem I have still exists even if I assume completely benign actors leading up to the tweet.
- chatterhead 4y ago
- stavros 4y agoI think your questions assume too much. It seems to me that the candidate saw the website not being in the search results, and either thought "a conspiracy will appeal to my voter base" and spun it as a conspiracy, or is just like his voter base, and "this is a conspiracy by the deep state!" is the only explanation he came up with.
- JohnFen 4y agoIt's either the former, or the guy is a complete idiot. A normal person, on discovering this, would have contacted whoever is administering the website and asked them what's going on before simply assuming any particular cause.
- sophacles 4y agoMaybe the contractor did that. It's still quite sad and very telling of a delusional mindset if he didn't first try to find out if his contractor can fix the problem and instead his initial response is full on conspiracy nonsense.
- croes 4y ago>Or, you know, he had his campaign website built by the lowest bidder, they for whatever reason accidentally included or forgot to remove the noindex tag, and the candidate wasn't aware of this and genuinely thought he was getting censored by Google. Well that sounds like option #2 with extra steps.
- theow7384iri 4y ago
- erostrate 4y agoOf course now that he's aware that the mistake was on his side, he has apologised and amended his Twitter posts. Because he wants his followers to get accurate information that allows them to make informed decisions based on rational thinking, not emotional outrage or base tribal instincts exacerbated by misleading information propagated by echo chambers. Because he understands that preserving a well functioning democracy and dialog is more important than advancing his own interests. Of course.
- chatterhead 4y ago
- blowski 4y agoIn the horseshoe model of politics, those two are not far apart from each other. They both oppose the competent centrist.
- hoity 4y agoThe "competent centrist" is a myth though. The centrists, who basically advocate business as usual, are who have given us so many financial crises, wars, poverty and suffering over the decades.
- batch12 4y agoThe "incompetent extremist" is not a myth, unfortunately.
- glitchc 4y agoAnd yet consistent growth, overall better standard of living for all humanity, increased longevity, better quality of life, resuced human diseases, more than sufficient food production to feed every human on the planet (if we can figure out logistics)… yeah. Those unreasonable centrists. All of the events you mention can be attributed to the politics of the extremists.
- 4y ago
- gulpp 4y agoReminds me of that guy from the other day who insisted that Apple was spying his private QR codes: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33100130 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33100130 Politics seems to attract the type of people who speak first and think later.
- myko 4y agoInteresting that this guy retracted his complaint and very publicly alerted folks to his error, and deleted the disinformation he initially spread. I scanned Finchem's Twitter feed and all I see are more lies about the election having been stolen. Did he post a retraction or anything? edit: looks like he still has the disinformation up https://twitter.com/RealMarkFinchem/status/1578072346149150722 https://twitter.com/RealMarkFinchem/status/15780723461491507...
- sva_ 4y agoThe way they're using this as promotion, it could be assumed that they did this on purpose. But that's probably giving them too much credit.
- jmull 4y agoWow... the deep state conspiracy changed the files on his server! This goes even deeper than we suspected. (/s, hopefully obvious)
- batch12 4y agoThis article posits two theories. He is incompetent in setting up his website or he faked oppression. Does the author really think this guy set up his own domain, built his own website, and went back in July and edited the HTML himself to not be indexed? Is it possible there's a third option that the person he hired is either malicious or incompetent? The tone of this article is cheap and overall it's terrible clickbait. The point of it is to either anger one side for clicks[0] or seek nods from the other. I don't know anything about this guy or his politics, but if we are judging people's ability to run a government office by their web development skills, let's do a full review. With that said, this guy was either screwed by his technical team, or is quick to stir the pot without checking-- and is equally guilty of the same pathetic attempts at emotional manipulation used in the article. Maybe both. [0] Or, option two is that the guy who might soon be in charge of Arizona state elections is so incompetent and so stupid that he accidentally blocked Google from searching his website:
- karaterobot 4y ago> The tone of this article is cheap and overall it's terrible clickbait. Agreed, and what's worse to me is that it's all entirely speculative. The author didn't do any original research to, I dunno, email the guy's campaign about his website and ask if he made it? Having not done any research that didn't involve reading Twitter, he decided it was okay to write an article about it, and just pad that article out with wild-ass guesses and invective.
- KingOfCoders 4y agoYou assume the "noindex" was a mistake, it wasn't.
- batch12 4y agoI assumed nothing. I added another, more plausible, cause for this. You assume a lot in an authoritative tone. Point me to the evidence you've found to make this definitive statement.
- KingOfCoders 4y ago
- mellosouls 4y agoWhile the candidate appears to have shot himself in the foot here, and some on the Right seem to be particularly susceptible to conspiracy explanations; in the context of repeated Big Tech overreach in deplatforming and "accidentally" de-indexing conservative voices in the last few years, censorship is not an unreasonable hypothesis to assume. Knee-jerk mockery is maybe a complacent response here from those of us on the liberal side.
- ProjectArcturis 4y agoIs there any actual evidence of "repeated Big Tech overreach in deplatforming and "accidentally" de-indexing conservative voices in the last few years"? Seems like a conspiracy theory to me.
- KingOfCoders 4y agoYou assume the "noindex" was a mistake, it wasn't.
- KingOfCoders 4y agoThat's the whole idea: 1. set noindex tag, don't get indexed 2. cry "conspiracy" 3. get elected
- pessimizer 4y agoYou have to feel sorry for him. Pretending both to be a free speech candidate in order to not lose the libertarian-leaning base and also trying to get some cred in the oppression Olympics using the Christian-values base's mythology of persecution at the same time is a tough road for somebody who also desperately wants things censored. edit: It's going to be a problem for a lot of conservatives this cycle. A lot of candidates in general. Claiming to be for free speech and free expression, with long lists of books to be burnt.
- toss1 4y agoThat move alone should be disqualifying for any public office Google should now refuse to index the site for the reason that he's unqualified, not the reason that his own website told indexing robots to go away.
- lbriner 4y agoThe whole conspiracy thing is very worrying, not just in the US or about Elections but about everything. 5G causes cancer, Bill Gates is chipping everyone, the Rothschilds/Soros's/Whoever runs the whole world. There will be some pieces of truth but mostly this is about confirmation bias. "I believe Bill Gates is chipping everyone", therefore an article that ties him to an electronics company "proves" its true and his links to "Coronavirus" companies is the icing on the cake. The worrying thing is that this is taking over so many areas including intelligent normal people. I guess the only way to make it go away is for our Leaders and Betters to have slightly better ability and morals so there is less reason to accuse them of corruption. Apologies to Bill Gates who is surely intelligent - not sure how he became the poster boy for Conspiracies.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]