6 ms·
Far-ultraviolet LED designed to kill bacteria and viruses without harming humans
- mattnewport 4y agoThis might be useful but I wish they'd stop tying this sort of thing to covid when we now know it was never transmitted via surfaces and the society wide obsession with disinfecting everything was a complete waste of time for covid.
- dzhiurgis 4y agoAmazing even a16z fell into this trap, even 2 years later patting themselves on the back for inventing elbow bump
- fifteenforty 4y agoThis is not only about surface disinfection. 222nm UV is showing great promise for air disinfection. It’s an alternative to traditional filtration and ventilation. Of course, being a COVID-19 related electronic thing, there are lots of sham products being sold, but the underlying principle seems sound.
- gus_massa 4y agoThe part about the new LED loks legit, but the claim that it's safe for humans is very hard to believe. I never heard something like that, and the claim is not present in the abstract of the research paper. (Can someone read the full paper?) So I guess it's a misunderstanding/exaggeration/fabrication in the press release of the university or the press article.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoMy mother was a geologist, so I grew up, around "shortwave" UV lamps. These trigger much brighter fluorescence in rocks and minerals (and blacklight posters) than your average blacklight bulb, but they can give you a nasty sunburn, and damage your eyes (we had to wear special goggles, when we used these lamps). I never heard about "altering DNA," but maybe that's where the sunburn comes from. It's pretty easy to get "standard" blacklight LEDs (about 400nm), but less easy to get "shortwave" blacklights (250nm). The 250-300nm lamps are the "sterilizing" lamps. Maybe there's some band in there that is "safe." I dunno. I notice that wavelengths are not mentioned in the story.
- sprior 4y agoNot that hard to get them, your big box store has them in the pool filter section. In 2020 these instructions came out how to build a UV sterilizer for cheap: https://makezine.com/projects/build-a-diy-uv-c-sterilization-cabinet-to-fight-covid-19 https://makezine.com/projects/build-a-diy-uv-c-sterilization... And no, not safe without precautions.
- gus_massa 4y agoThe research article says "228-nm UV" Looking at https://ehs.lbl.gov/resource/documents/radiation-protection/non-ionizing-radiation/ultraviolet-radiation/ https://ehs.lbl.gov/resource/documents/radiation-protection/... that was linked in a sibling comment, it says > UV-C 220–280[nm] Corneal injuries Photokeratitis Erythema, skin cancer When the wavelength is shorted, each photon has more energy and as a rule of thumb they are more dangerous. "Altering DNA" is the usual way to get cancer. One of the photons hit the DNA, it has enough energy to break one of the parts. Sometimes it can be repaired, but other times it cause a small mutation. If you are unlucky and get enough mutations in some of the "correct" spots the cell gets mad and start reproducing uncontrollably and you get cancer. (Sometimes the alteration is caused by a chemical substance, or other thing. Sometimes it's just a bad copy during normal cell reproduction.)
- jschveibinz 4y agoHere is a link to hazard vs. frequency: https://ehs.lbl.gov/resource/documents/radiation-protection/non-ionizing-radiation/ultraviolet-radiation/ https://ehs.lbl.gov/resource/documents/radiation-protection/...
- m-p-3 4y agoThere are some research into 222nm UVC. https://phys.org/news/2020-04-repetitive-irradiation-222nm-uvc-non-carcinogenic.html https://phys.org/news/2020-04-repetitive-irradiation-222nm-u...
- rapjr9 4y agoThere is some research saying 222nm is safe, yet still disrupts viruses and bacteria. And you can buy lamps at that frequency on Amazon (for like $1700). However it's not like it's been proved safe by a decades worth of testing and use. The LED's at 222nm just became available in the last year or so. I don't think anyone knows the long term consequences. Some web sites selling these lamps disclaim all responsibility. Also remember WE are made of a LOT of bacteria and viruses. Might not be such a good thing to sterilize your skin daily. Some of that stuff protects you from nastier stuff.
- dzhiurgis 4y agoYeah. You probably don’t wanna kill your bacteria, but prevent spread. Sanitize your kitchen, groceries and all public spaces I guess. I really hope we as society start take ventilation of public spaces more seriously… there has been some effort to fix schools, but I’m still holding my breath (haha)
- gus_massa 4y agoFrom the article: > One is that efficacy for formation of CPDs, the main photo-induced DNA lesion which is closely associated with photocarcinogenesis, is highest at approximately 260 nm and decreases at shorter and longer wavelengths, and generation of CPDs at 222 nm is approximately 70% of that at 254 nm, as previously shown in the action spectrum for the formation of CPDs (29). The second is that the 222-nm UVC is too short to penetrate the stratum corneum to reach the basal cell layer, where cancer stem cells are considered to reside (30, 31). That make sense, and looks like a good explanation. They used 9 mice in each group, but the difference was big enough, so it doesn't look like a problem caused by using a small number of mice. Definitively interesting, but I'd be careful with humans skin (my skin!) anyway until other groups reproduce the result.
- eternityforest 4y agoI've heard similar claims for excimer lamps but I'd still prefer not to stand under one. It's still a great thing if it's even just safer than the usual 254nm ones, if it allows for designs with brief incidental exposure.
- gus_massa 4y agoUV-B and UV-C are dangerous. As always, the dose makes the poison, so low exposure is safe. My guess is that they claim is safer for the environment or safer if they broke, but the language is confusing and they seam to claim they are safe in normal use. From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Excimer_lamp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Excimer_lamp > Mercury lamps are the most common source of UV radiation due to their high efficiency. However, the use of mercury in these lamps poses disposal and environmental problems. On the contrary, excimer lamps based on rare gases are absolutely non-hazardous and excimer lamps containing halogen are more environmentally benign than mercury ones.[citation needed]
- eternityforest 4y agoI assume they are referencing this, which claims it might be safe to directly expose people to: https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/477264#:~:text=Main%20Points-,Provided%20proof%20for%20the%20first%20time%20in%20the%20world%20that,for%20human%20skin%20and%20eyes https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/477264#:~:text=Main.... But I'd be worried about what it does to abraded or pre damaged skin, and whatever bacteria shows up when you kill the ones on your skin with it.
- gus_massa 4y agoI replied to that in a sibling comment. It looks promising, but I'd wait to try it in my skin until other groups have reproduced it.
- Maursault 4y agoMercury lamps just happen to emit light at 253.7 nm, very close to the wavelength of UVC that best kills microbes, 254nm. 185nm is also regarded as a wavelength that kills microbes, but this is by proxy of it being the wavelength best at producing ozone, which then kills microbes. It has been possible to purchase LEDs with a peak wavelength of 255nm (250-260nm) and other wavelengths of UVC and UVB for a decade at least, but they cost about $300/pc iirc, making them very expensive for building a one-off microbe-killer flashlight or disinfecting multi-LED array. Comparatively, Mercury lamps are cheap.
- adrian_b 4y agoI assume that this is a bad translation and the meaning was that the sterilized food is safe for humans, not the ultraviolet light. The part about the LED looks indeed right, the aluminum gallium nitride LEDs can emit ultraviolet light, but at short wavelength their efficiency was very low, while the new LED with a more complex multilayer structure has improved the efficiency about ten times, allowing them to replace mercury lamps for sterilization purposes.
- gus_massa 4y ago> I assume that this is a bad translation and the meaning was that the sterilized food is safe for humans, not the ultraviolet light. That makes a lot of sense. Usually it's not 100% false, just a bad interpretation. I was not able to imagine the source of the claim, but this makes a lot of sense.