3 ms·
This is such a weird criticism. Before wikipedia you had academics writing things like this. You really think the average wikipedian is more "motivated" then t
by bawolff 4y ago
This is such a weird criticism.
Before wikipedia you had academics writing things like this. You really think the average wikipedian is more "motivated" then the average academic with a PhD who spent their life studying some topic?
- jerf 4y agoAverage, who can say. Modal, by number of contributions/edits, they absolutely are more motivated than a PhD. They may have spent their life studying a topic but Wikipedia isn't where they're generally going to put it.
- bawolff 4y agoIf your counting by number of edits that's basically a tautology: People who edit wikipedia make more edits than people who don't edit Wikipedia. Well no shit. If you want to do an apples to apples comparison, compare how many hours people edit wikipedia vs how many hours PhD candidates spend writing their dissertation. i think on average traditional accademia rewards obsessiveness much more than wikipedia does.