3 ms·
Honestly you seem to just want to hate Signal. That's okay to dislike something but calling Signal a honeypot is a strong statement. That requires strong eviden
by godelski 4y ago
Honestly you seem to just want to hate Signal. That's okay to dislike something but calling Signal a honeypot is a strong statement. That requires strong evidence, not weak conjecture.
It is hard to respond to you in good faith because it does not feel like you want to engage that way. Maybe I am misunderstanding your statement. So I will engage in good faith once more (reminding you that this is a HN rule).
Anonymity is nowhere near as simple as not requiring PII during registration. Even from the provider side. We can agree that it is difficult to maintain anonymity from the user side. But choices made by the provider can make these things impossible. Let's suppose Signal gives me one username that I can use and I must use that continuously. What do I choose? If I use "godelski" then I've made a permanent connection between that identity and my real life identity. After all, I do talk to friends, family, and coworkers on Siganl. If I choose another name and share that name through this name, then those two are linked together. All of this is information leakage and highly valuable to OSINT people. I'm sure someone here has significantly more experience than me and would be happy to expand upon this too. But it is extremely naive to believe/claim that anonymity is provided simply by removing the phone number. It is far more complicated than that. Hopefully you now know that.
- stiray 4y ago
- bboygravity 4y agoThere's quite a few other hints in the marketing and decisions at Signal that reek a little bit of honeypot (by the NSA). Super hard to prove though... For me personally the strongest hints are the fact that it's centralized, there's no getting around connecting to their server(s) for the app/clients to be useful and that it's impossible to know what exactly their server is running (by design?). Oh, and Signal is based in the US. That fact by itself pretty much means all bets are off when it comes to security or anonimity. I don't see how the NSA would not be pwning that server or owning/creating that server and/or organization (indirectly or directly). Or to put it differently: why would it be hard or illogical for the NSA to setup an innocent seeming "good guys" radiating non-profit chat service that is supposedly secure (yet centralized and non-anonymous by design and also a honeypot)?
- tptacek 4y agoPlease don't post insinuations about astroturfing, shilling, bots, brigading, foreign agents and the like. It degrades discussion and is usually mistaken. If you're worried about abuse, email hn@ycombinator.com and we'll look at the data. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=author%3Adang%20%22owe%20this%20community%22&sort=byPopularity&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- dementiapatent 4y agoI always took that rule as "don't post insinuations (accusing other HN users of being) astroturfing, shilling, bots, foreign agents...". Can we not point out when corporate entities are comprised of these things?
- tptacek 4y agoSee the second link. (And, of course, the insinuation made above applies directly to several members of the HN community).
- gruez 4y ago>Oh, and Signal is based in the US. That fact by itself pretty much means all bets are off when it comes to security or anonimity. It has to be based somewhere right? Would you trust it if it was based in China or Russia? Or even mid tier countries like UAE or Singapore? Even "neutral" countries like Switzerland isn't safe, as we've seen with Crypto AG.
- awuji 4y agoThe patriot act clearly compromises every 5-eyes nation. China and Russia have their own equivalents of a Patriot act, so hosting there is no good either. Mid tier and neutral countries can be compromised as in your example above. This is all truly depressing, but why does it have to be hosted on a central server. I hate web3 hype as much as the rest of HN, but this seems like a genuinely useful application for it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]