4 ms·
The instrumental (ha HA) utility of the "kink" seems to me a natural consequence of compounding constraints: some musing: the number of strings is constrained
by aaroninsf 4y ago
The instrumental (ha HA) utility of the "kink" seems to me a natural consequence of compounding constraints:
some musing:
the number of strings is constrained to allow for chord voicing across all the strings,
and to provide range,
open chords with minimal fingering complexity radically increase accessibility,
duplication is critical to support those,
capping with the double octave of the lowest note makes up-and-down strumming work,
if you're going to break pattern to coerce the highest string, it's extremely useful to also provide its dominant (5th) which makes sounding those top strings together just "work" (especially: with a bass note on the lowest string), with the side benefit that it allows learned scale patterns to work across those two strings, where most melodic playing will be up-an-down and third- fourth- or fifth- jumping or stopping,
...add all this up and it's a collection of mild but clear wins that together really strongly entail the current system.
Robert Fripp's 500 page book on guitar playing no doubt explains why this is Wrong and his preferred all-fourths tuning etc. are Better though. :)
- lioeters 4y agoIt's been interesting to learn about the reasoning (or post-facto explanations) of that seemingly anomalous major 3rd gap. I can see its advantages, like it enables certain barre chords. Apparently, the tuning invented by Robert Fripp is called "New standard tuning", based on all fifths. I like the audacity to call it a new standard. :) > C2-G2-D3-A3-E4-G4 (from lowest to highest) > the five lowest open strings are each tuned to an interval of a perfect fifth > the two highest strings are a minor third apart https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_standard_tuning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_standard_tuning
- elsherbini 4y agoYeah, perfect 5ths, or the weird in-between which would be tritone tuning allow for really wide intervalic leaps really ergonomically. Since a lot of progressive music favors melodic lines with wide intervalic leaps, it's a good option for that style.