7 ms·
Papa John's sued for 'wiretap' spying on website mouse clicks, keystrokes
- uoaei 4y agoIf this sets a precedent, I imagine class-action suits against Meta, reddit, et al. follow very shortly thereafter. I remember even 7-10 years ago experiencing numerous bugs where the only reasonable explanation (to me) was that they were storing page and form state server-side and there were syncing issues with the client. Things like typing a sentence, deleting it, and then it re-appearing in weird ways as I wrote a new sentence to replace it in a comment form box. I had just kind of assumed this was par for the course with umitigated surveillance by social media companies but hadn't realized this law exists to allegedly disallow that kind of thing. I remember even back then saying things like "if you give Facebook web access to your camera they will use that to track what you're looking at on the webpage" and sounding paranoid to my colleagues but it doesn't seem so far-fetched now. I'm sure that's a big part of why TikTok works so well too -- many people grant access to the camera because of naivete or because they want to record and upload their own videos from the mobile app. Knowing where attention is in the finest detail is probably a big advantage.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mmastrac 4y agoStoring form state server-side is incredibly common, and users _want_ that functionality in most cases. One of the most common sign-up frustrations is entering everything into a sign-up form, clicking submit and having some or all of that information cleared and having to re-type it. There's no privacy concerns about storing form data temporarily to regurgitate it on reload, and it _should_ be a best practice.
- xboxnolifes 4y agoIs your example not usually solved with local storage, not server storage?
- uoaei 4y ago> There's no privacy concerns about storing form data temporarily to regurgitate it on reload This is obviously wrong, because it doesn't actually address privacy concerns at all. "Storing form data temporarily" says nothing about what other services/programs/people can access that data while it is stored. And anyway, sibling comment has a very good point about local storage vs server storage.
- donatj 4y agoThis is actually super common functionality with a large number of analytics providers. We talked to a company a number of years ago trying to sell us this tool that would let you play back a video of what a user did right up to getting an error on your website. Useful, but creepy.
- Alupis 4y agoThere's many services that provide this these days, including HotJar (paid) and Microsoft Clarity (free). Being able to see users actually use your site, combined with heatmaps and more really lets your team focus on usability issues, or help direct attention to more important features. Things like, do users struggle to find the shopping cart button? Are they confused about how to create an account? Is it frustrating to make changes to something, etc. Engineers are really bad at understanding usability issues unless they see it for themselves. However, it does tend to be something you review/monitor sporadically, not every day. You have to have enough samples to see if changes have had a significant impact or not. The ones we've used have all had the ability to censor what the tool believes to be sensitive information, such as passwords, credit card numbers, etc. In our experience, these tools overzealously censor on-page text out of an abundance of caution - which is just fine. Rarely are you interested in reading the text on screen, rather, you're watching how the user interacts with the page. It's kind of a ridiculous notion that a site operator cannot monitor how users use the site... this is not wiretapping and I assume (hope) it gets thrown out.
- S201 4y ago> It's kind of a ridiculous notion that a site operator cannot monitor how users use the site... this is not wiretapping and I assume (hope) it gets thrown out. Putting aside how many other ways there are to determine how users use a website without needing to resort to this level of intrusion, the issue is that almost always the user isn't aware this level of monitoring of their actions is happening. Sure, it may be buried deep in some privacy policy or terms and conditions no one ever reads, but that's not exactly what I'd call informed consent. This is where regulation to at least require websites notify their uses that there's literally a recording being taken of their screen interacting with the website would be helpful.
- greenthrow 4y agoThis is extremely widely used. I doubt it is going to go anywhere since your interactions with a website have no expectation of privacy from the website owner.
- jeroenhd 4y agoIt is widely used. And that's a disgusting disregard of customers' privacy. I very much doubt that this lawsuit will go anywhere. I hope it does, though.
- 9wzYQbTYsAIc 4y agoHealthcare related websites do have privacy expectations, as do law services websites, I suspect. I wonder how many hospitals and clinics use insecure technologies to do interaction monitoring of patients and prospective patients. I wouldn’t be surprised if some hospital got sued someday for an employee misusing interaction monitoring for personal benefit.
- mwint 4y agoHeh, I could make an argument for Papa John’s being an anti-healthcare website.
- xcskier56 4y agoOne of the big caveats is that the information must be personally identifiable AND include information about the care of that person. Just my going to the website of a healthcare organization doesn't immediately identify me as a patient of that system, just that I've looked at their website. I've done some digging and I've found many health systems using google analytics, which is not HIPAA compliant. But I've found they only use this on their public pages. From what I can tell, they don't use it in their internal systems that will likely contain PHI. All that said, given the state of IT in healthcare systems, it wouldn't surprise me if some system out there is using a non-HIPAA compliant system for handling PHI. Who? No idea. The other part of HIPAA is that its penalties are WAY stronger than normal privacy laws. If someone knowingly obtains or discloses PHI in violation of the Privacy rule, they may face fines up to $50,000 and one year in jail. The fines and jail goes higher for more malicious violations. These penalties are enforced on the person who broke the law, not the company.
- duxup 4y agoProvided it is limited to that site. I'm not sure I have a problem with this kind of situation. If they want to track clicks, data entered, movement on their site... I'm ok with that. If it is confined to that site and declared illegal, I gotta wonder where the line is drawn exactly...
- somebodynew 4y agoShould they be allowed to record your mouse movements while on their site and sell information about how steady or shaky your hands appear to be to health insurance or car insurance companies?
- duxup 4y agoI don’t think that would involve the wiretapping lawsuit.
- cantSpellSober 4y agoIt's mentioned in the lawsuit
- duxup 4y agoYou can mention it in a lawsuit, doesn’t mean it is a violation of the law.
- cantSpellSober 4y agoCool. It involves the wiretapping lawsuit.
- Alupis 4y agoThese smash-and-grab lawyers always way, way, way overstate things in the initial complaint. It's par for the course. I wouldn't be surprised if Papa John's wasn't even doing any of the alleged things (I have not personally verified)... because it doesn't matter for these types of suits. The plaintiff's lawyers will conveniently ask for a settlement payout less than the estimated cost of litigation, and Papa John's will write a check to make it go away. It's how these things work.
- pessimizer 4y agoI'm happy about this, because everyone does it, and when people started tracking what you were typing in a box before you submitted it they silently crossed a line that really bothers me[*]. My browser should be working for me. Not silently giving other people information that I haven't chosen to give them yet. *edit: and they also introduced another annoying layer of latency, and what looks like a boring textarea suddenly can't keep up with how fast I'm typing.
- legitster 4y agoI find this somewhat akin to how people are monitored in grocery stores. You better believe that studies are constantly done on shoppers using video cameras. Or heck, just managers using their own eyes to look at how shoppers behave.
- ridgered4 4y agoK-mart just got dinged for using facial recognition to track shoppers, they claim for loss prevention.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y agoIt seems fundamentally different from a certain perspective (maybe not from the layperson's). As much as one person might think that I'm "visiting their website" I think that I'm just requesting them to serve me some information and they include with that a spying payload.
- alkonaut 4y agoA store is a place where I expect to be monitored both by eyes and cameras. Sending keystrokes from a form I haven’t submitted is like putting the camera inside the fitting room.
- Alupis 4y agoOr, it's like watching you add stuff to your shopping cart, walk around the store, then remove some items, pick different items... and finally walk to the self checkout, scan and buy the goods.
- nigrioid 4y agoI don't like it either, but case law or legislation against this will just end up with the US mandating things like cookie banners. Eventually, building a website will be like getting approval to build a building.
- somebodythere 4y agoI don't think this has materialized in the EU.
- cantSpellSober 4y agoShould we stop requiring approval to build buildings?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tinalumfoil 4y agoIt's hard to imagine the lawyers have much confidence in this lawsuit if they're going after Papa John's instead of, say, Facebook.
- Alupis 4y agoThe likes of Facebook would litigate this issue. Papa John's will write a check and move on... like most of us would actually, despite how wrong these drive-by bottom-feeding lawyer hit squads are. No case law will be created here. It's very unlikely this suit will actually see the inside of a court room. Just a smash-and-grab payout and they'll move onto some other fish small enough to desire writing a check versus litigating. It's the ADA website thing all over again...
- cantSpellSober 4y agoWhat evidence is there that Facebook violated the same specific laws mentioned in the lawsuit?
- datadata 4y agoI think a reasonable strategy would be to pick a target less able to defend itself, in order to more easily win and set a precedent to prepare for a second attack against a bigger target.
- Tozen 4y ago> pick a target less able to defend itself... prepare for a second attack against a bigger target... Yeah, think that's the strategy and what is going too. Good observation.
- rany_ 4y agoIf Papa John's could get sued over this (it's just a pizza place...) then I have no idea how Hotjar hasn't been sued into oblivion, especially considering their analytics tools don't responsibly tell the users they're being recorded. Edit: or rather any website that uses Hotjar without informing their users clearly (basically all of them) ...
- cantSpellSober 4y agoPJ's has 5,500 locations in 49 countries. Hotjar had just $25M in revenue last report.
- Alupis 4y agoHotJar would have a very serious interest in litigating this issue, whereas Papa John's will have a very serious interest in writing a check to make this go away. That's why HotJar is not the named defendant.
- cantSpellSober 4y agoPJ is not "just a pizza place," it's a global brand with a massive litigious legal team that rarely writes checks "to make this go away" https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/papa-john-schnatter-wins-major-ruling-lawsuit-against-ad-firm-to-proceed-301631539.html https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/papa-john-schnatter... Hotjar doesn't have the funds to pay a class action suit.
- Alupis 4y ago> The case, filed in December 2019, revolves around Mr. Schnatter's claim that he was targeted by the Defendants, which then leaked secretly-recorded private comments by Mr. Schnatter to the media – out of context to reverse their meaning – maliciously harming him and the company brand. Defendants' actions resulted in a hasty and harmful reaction by the Papa John's board of directors, forcing Mr. Schnatter out of the company he founded 34 years earlier That is not the same. He was maliciously ran out of his company. This is a technical roadbump, one that does zero harm to PJ or their reputation either direction. They will write a check.
- legitster 4y agoI think people really underappreciate the usefulness of behavior analytics tools. Remove your nostalgia of the old internet, and it was ridiculously unusable. Things like low contrast texts, really bad button placement, confusing layouts, etc. Even if you don't personally use something like Hotjar or Crazyegg, we've spent the last several decades learning best practices specifically through these types of tools. Bootstrap or even Tailwind would not exist today without the lessons learned through constant experimentation. While it's easy enough to steal from prior work, if you make some sort of novel tool or interface and you do not do regular user testing it's going to be a really bad experience. I'm not saying a more privacy-conscience web can't exist here, but you would either be left with a very hard to use internet, or one that was dominated by a few big players who had the advantage of focus group testing.
- blowski 4y agoI suspect we could have learned that low contrast text was bad without tools that track every single interaction. I might even say we haven't learned that lesson, despite the prevalence of such tools.
- chaps 4y agoAnd maybe we also underappreciate apocalyptic nuclear war for the eradication of human hunger. Just because something works to solve a problem, doesn't mean it should be used.
- legitster 4y ago> Just because something works to solve a problem, doesn't mean it should be used. Sure. I can agree on principle. But I want to call out anyone willing to throw a stone on this but then have ever complained about bad UX.
- teawrecks 4y agoI believe myself to be a pretty security conscious person, and I hate webdev as much as the next system programmer, but even I don't see anything fundamentally wrong with what papa johns is doing here. I chose to use their website. Any interaction with the site should be assumed to be input that they are allowed to take and use how they want. If I don't want these inputs to be sent, it's my responsibility to configure my browser to 1) tell me it's happening, 2) block the site from seeing those inputs or 3) just shut everything like that off (disable js). Browsers sandbox websites for a reason, whatever I put into the sandbox is my own responsibility, and whatever happens in that sandbox is allowed.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thenoblesquid 4y agoI started working for a company that was using this tracking technology. Struck me as an invasion of privacy, so I discontinued their of the tool. There are other solutions out there for getting useful into on sticking points, crawl depth, etc. that don't expose individual user behavior.
- spdustin 4y agoBrowsers need an obvious visual indicator (with accessible fallback for users of assistive technology) when the browser determines that event handlers are capturing this data to be sent to a third party. In fact, there have been studies [0][1][2] (with [0] funded twice by DARPA to the tune of $2.26 million) suggesting that mouse movements and typing patterns can be used as a form of biometric ID. Who will be the first state to include this type of data, collected at scale, in their definition of “biometric identifiers?” For example, Illinois’ “Biometric Information Privacy Act (BIPA)” [3] currently defines biometric identifiers as “a retina or iris scan, fingerprint, voiceprint, or scan of hand or face geometry.” BIPA allows a private right of action (rather than empowering only a state Attorney General to pursue violations, like Texas’ “Capture or Use Biometric Identifier Act (CUBI)” [4]. That private right of action has led to a number of successful class-action suits against large social networks, such as Facebook [5] and TikTok [6]. My wife and I both got a >$300 check from the Facebook suit. The TikTok suit is currently being appealed. [0]: https://phys.org/news/2013-11-iowa-state-keyboard-mouse-mobile.html https://phys.org/news/2013-11-iowa-state-keyboard-mouse-mobi... [1]: https://doi.org/10.1109/SP46214.2022.9833612 https://doi.org/10.1109/SP46214.2022.9833612 [2]: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ins.2012.02.066 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ins.2012.02.066 [3]: https://www.ilga.gov/legislation/ilcs/ilcs3.asp?ActID=3004&ChapterID=57 https://www.ilga.gov/legislation/ilcs/ilcs3.asp?ActID=3004&C... [4]: https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/BC/htm/BC.503.htm https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/BC/htm/BC.503.htm [5]: https://www.facebookbipaclassaction.com https://www.facebookbipaclassaction.com [6]: https://www.tiktokdataprivacysettlement.com https://www.tiktokdataprivacysettlement.com