2 ms·
This is a really good article. I think a significant insight missing from it is that corporations, states, wars, and the like are also alternate reality games
by kragen 4y ago
This is a really good article.
I think a significant insight missing from it is that corporations, states, wars, and the like are also alternate reality games — as was the cultural wasteland of mass-media-manufactured consent whose loss it mourns. Not just the genesis of revolutions, but also their aftermath.
It does glance at this idea but doesn't seriously engage with it:
> the bygone era of mass media was not a golden age of truth, … But what matters here is that… [i]n an age of alternate realities, narratives do not converge.
Is that really what matters? Is it even a new phenomenon, or a process that was ever interrupted? I don't think that, in the bygone era of mass media, the narrative peddled on NBC converged with that of Iran's Guardian Council or Pravda; nor did Joe McCarthy's narrative ever converge with that of the Port Huron Statement. And there are times, like the murder of Kitty Genovese, where the narrative did converge, but it converged on utter falsehood.
If this doesn't convince you, reread the article carefully, thinking about how well or poorly each thing it says about modern alternate reality games applies to the historical persecution of Communists in the US, anti-Communists in the USSR and PRC, or heretics in the Spanish Inquisition. You will find it an uncomfortably tight fit.
To me it seems more important to be able to coexist with people with different beliefs, people who aren't playing the same alternate reality game you are. Lacking that ability, dissent yields mass bloodshed, so polities ruthlessly suppress dissent in order to survive, condemning themselves to self-defeating delusion. We have centuries of practice developing institutions (that is to say, alternate reality games) that can survive dissent: liberalism, capitalism, academia, pacifism, Gandhian nonviolent resistance, parliamentary procedure, and now free software and Wikipedia. Other cultures have other institutions I'm unfamiliar with.
All of them are under immense stress from the internet revolution, and it's anybody's guess how that will shake out.