4 ms·
Quite simply there are multiple factors at play here. Do you force 2FA on almost everyone and reduce hostile account takeovers to negligible? Do you allow for n
by renewiltord 4y ago
Quite simply there are multiple factors at play here. Do you force 2FA on almost everyone and reduce hostile account takeovers to negligible? Do you allow for no 2FA and permit the homeless use case?
I think Google faced a trolley problem and made the right decision. You need a different tool "homeless mail" for them.
It's Gmail. You don't have to use it. There's a lot of mail providers out there.
Whatever, if this guy won't set it up I will. I'll stick a 20 msg / hr, 100 / day limit on it and call it a nice anti-spam day.
- lazyasciiart 4y agoMany people exist and use email before becoming homeless. When that email is gmail - they actually do have to use it when they become homeless!
- renewiltord 4y agoI think if you trolley-problem this you'll still end up with Google's choice being the right one.
- lazyasciiart 4y agoI did and I don’t. Absolutely depends on the value and risk weighting you give to homeless people needing their email, of course.
- samdcbu 4y agoBased on Google documentation you can still turn off 2fa, so we are weighing the account security of the hundreds of millions of users who would never turn on 2fa but really should, versus the people who lose their 2FA verification method and are locked out of their account. Maybe the harm of not being able to login is worse than having your identity stolen but whose to say.
- Longlius 4y agoYou don't solve a trolley problem. The entire point is that it's unresolvable from most ethical paradigms other than naïve utilitarianism (which is why it exists - to mock that way of thinking).
- renewiltord 4y agoThat's exactly the point here as well - well, without mocking the utilitarianism. It is natural that a corporation optimizes to its customers within the envelope of regulatory constraints.