3 ms·
> The fediverse needs this as well: just plop a binary on your VPS or homeserver and you're running. Such lean and simple servers are being worked on, but Masto
by mschuster91 4y ago
> The fediverse needs this as well: just plop a binary on your VPS or homeserver and you're running. Such lean and simple servers are being worked on, but Mastodon itself is a huge, slow and hairy beast.
Even if you get the tech stack solved to an easily deployable package: The problem is you still need to invest immense amounts of time on moderation. Some of that responsibility is enforced legally (e.g. CSAM, warez, US COPPA, EU GDPR, German NetzDG), some of it socially (e.g. kicking Nazis, conspiracy spreaders or other forms of hate speech out), some of it by the federation system (e.g. kicking spammers out) and some of it you need to do to keep your community healthy (e.g. kick general trolls and creeps out). If your instance allows adult material, gambling or games, you'll need to moderate your instance as well in some jurisdictions. And you'll need someone always available to support police, court and secret service requests.
Maintaining a service that hosts user-generated content is a thankless nightmare, and no matter what you do it is a huge liability. In the end, either you make your users pay for it in cash (subscription fees, patreon/gofundme/paypal donations), with their data (advertising) or you'll eventually burn out (such as the author of the blog entry).
Oh, and add on top of all of that the constant dealing with abuse: 4chan edgelords DDoS'ing your instance "for the lulz", random skiddies constantly running exploit scans against your server (which additionally means you have to have someone 24/7 to upgrade software in the case of a 0-day), people reporting your server / IP to blocklists to get you booted off the net... then you have to take care of hardware maintenance itself, making backups, testing backups. It's a full time job essentially, requiring an awful lot of time, money and connections (e.g. lawyers).
- Nemo_bis 4y agoDon't forget TERREG. Every website needs to have a person on-call 24/7 to answer potential requests from law enforcement anywhere in the EU to remove stuff they don't like. https://wikimedia.brussels/antiterrorists-in-a-bike-shed-policy-and-politics-of-terreg/ https://wikimedia.brussels/antiterrorists-in-a-bike-shed-pol...
- egypturnash 4y agoI run an instance and I really have none of these problems. Keeping open applications off solves a lot of them, you have to ask me for an invitation and I’m not going to give you one if I think you’re going to be a problem. There’s a Patreon for it that pays the server bills despite it only being a few hundred users. My users even say thanks for running the place now and then. Running a small node of The People’s Glorious Social Network is a very different task than what you are outlining.
- mschuster91 4y agoYeah, but what point does a social network have if most of the instances are closed off to "unknowns" due to the abuse potential? The few that have open registration still have to do the workload I described => most of the users will flock to these centralized sites that somehow have to deal with the effort required.
- egypturnash 4y agoIt's a place for me and my friends to talk, with connections to other places. A quiet little backwater. That's good enough for me to keep running it.
- afavour 4y ago> Keeping open applications off solves a lot of them, you have to ask me for an invitation But that simply doesn't scale to the level of services like Twitter. You might argue, and I would agree with you, that maybe we'd be better off without services that are too large to moderate in any meaningful way, but we are where we are. An invitation-only Mastodon network is not a viable alternative to Twitter.
- arcatech 4y agoBut it’s federated. You can have an invite only network that still federated with the rest of the network.
- berkes 4y ago> An invitation-only Mastodon network It's not the network that is invitation-only. Just some servers on that network that are. The network itself is entirely permission-less.
- everybodyknows 4y ago> you have to ask me for an invitation and I’m not going to give you one if I think you’re going to be a problem. How do you vet applicants? Depending on the theme of the site, this seems like it might range from easy (gardening, cooking, ...) to excruciating (politics, medical).
- berkes 4y agoYou are right: managing a server is hard work. Thankless moderation mostly. But that is even more reason to take away the additional work of keeping a large and convoluted rails-codebase up-to-date, running and performing. Also, part of why moderation is such a giant task, is that in the fediverse, servers (instances) tend to be big. Huge even. It's far easier to manage a server that hosts your ten friends, or the 30 members of your alumni-club, or the 42 members at the local hackerspace than a server with 2000+ random users. Another reason why lowering the barrier to the technical part of managing a server must be lowered.