6 ms·
I still dont understand why people keep talking about "House". When 90% of area that needs urgent "housing" are in needs of Tower Blocks / High Rise Residential
by ksec 4y ago
I still dont understand why people keep talking about "House". When 90% of area that needs urgent "housing" are in needs of Tower Blocks / High Rise Residential Buildings. We Need to find a way to quickly and cost effectively build a lot of mid to high quality apartments. Better heat isolation. Network Pipes ready rather than relying on WiFi.
Note: Yes, I know zoning and planning etc are still the biggest hurdle.
- lnsru 4y agoBecause house is cool and has integrated comfort. No neighbors, no useless administration. Building tall buildings is not a rocket science. Look at Burj Khalifa‘s construction: clever designed crane, lots of rebar and extremely powerful concrete pumps. And it’s really fast. One year to build enough space for thousands of people.
- ksec 4y ago>And it’s really fast. One year to build enough space for thousands of people. Building Tall building isn't Rocket Science, but building them fast, high quality ( comparatively speaking ) and cheap has not been done yet. And one year to build space enough for thousands of people is not my definition of fast. At least building "On Site".
- smusamashah 4y agoFrom what I have found watching this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1eIxUuuJX7Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1eIxUuuJX7Y and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HXZ_0wOY96E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HXZ_0wOY96E is that very tall buildings are cool only for the very rich but they are not very liveable. Burj Khalifa does not have a severage system. Trucks are used to take the human waste away every single day from burj khalifa.
- pasabagi 4y agoMmmm, there are a few examples of prefab high-rises that have gone up in weeks or months. I guess high-quality is something of a shifting bar, but if you prefab all the pieces, build them at volume, and have enough demand to justify that volume, it's been done before. That's how all the plattenbau (ugly commie concrete towerblocks went up in eastern europe) got done. I figure the problem is basically politics. Liberal democracies typically do planning by asking 'stakeholders' (e.g. business owners, home owners, etc) what they think about proposals. Since you're asking the stakeholders in an asset class whether or not you should build more of their asset, usually nearby, the answer is usually a lawsuit.
- ksec 4y agoDo you have any links on that? Most of the reference I found, Pre-Fabs only works for about 10-15 Floor buildings.
- pasabagi 4y agoIt's kind of a genre: watch like, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AhLk7L1B_fE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AhLk7L1B_fE, and you can see a bunch of others in suggested links. From what I gather, a industrial-scale air-conditioning unit company basically broke the space open, since they were essentially doing large scale prefab construction already. Just think about it from first principles. You can build large structures out of prefabricated parts, and if you design the parts sufficiently well, it's possible to fit them together fast. The problems are stuff like weight (transport costs start to dominate), volume (if there's not enough demand for skyscrapers, you don't want to be sitting on a skyscraper factory), etc. In East China, they have a lot of structural advantages: a huge, hugely dense population, a government that loves big construction projects, a massive housing market, a great deal of experience in doing civic infrastructure fast, etc.
- ethanbond 4y agoThere must’ve been years and years of design work behind the Burj Khalifa, no?
- extra88 4y agoShould have taken more than one year so they wouldn't have to haul away sewage by truck. https://inhabitat.com/the-incredible-story-of-how-the-burj-khalifas-poop-is-trucked-out-of-town/ https://inhabitat.com/the-incredible-story-of-how-the-burj-k...
- badpun 4y agoBecause Americans regard living in anything other than a detached house as a failure.
- JohnJamesRambo 4y agoWell would you want to share a wall and roof with most Americans?
- mym1990 4y ago
- CyberDildonics 4y agoWhat would possess someone to say this? You think there is something different about americans or that americans don't live in apartments?
- JohnJamesRambo 4y agoI just go to Walmart often. And the wonderful solitude and quiet of my old house in a dying town contrasts sharply with my college years living in apartments.
- bumby 4y agoI do think there is something different that leads Americans to desire homes and consider apartment living a failure. Some of it is the rhetoric about owning a home being part of the American Dream. Some of it is about the nature of the US housing market being a such an avenue to wealth (Americans have a disproportionate amount of their wealth wrapped up in their home). Some of it may be the individualistic mindset.
- fragmede 4y agoAmerican apartments in general are shoddily constructed and thus are a lower quality of living. There's no getting around that. Walls that are paper thin with no insulation so you can listen in on your neighbor's phone calls. Poorly done ceilings/floors so the upstairs neighbors' kids running around wakes you up in the morning. Single pane glass so heating/cooling bill is expensive, and the sounds of the street are audible throughout the day (you never want to live above a bus stop). Neighbors from all walks of life, which can be a nightmare if those walks of life include drug dealers and addicts and domestic violence, with norecourse from the police. No elevators up to the fifth floor. No trash pickup for large items. Shite public transportation and no good parking options. Horrible corporate landlord management company to contend with. I would love to live in an apartment complex in, say, Sweden, but there's a huge cultural component to apartment living in America that would have to change before it matches apartment living elsewhere. Even if building codes changed tonight it would still wouldn't address the issues of city design/public transportation that hurt the very notion of living that tightly together to begin with. It's just not at all convenient to live in an apartment complex that's miles away from the nearest public transportation hub or even a strip mall.
- bilsbie 4y agoEvery time I’ve lived in an apartment or condo the whole building smelled like trash. They need a better solution for managing waste disposal instead of a stinky room on every floor.
- lloydatkinson 4y agoI thought the universal solution was a chute for rubbish to be thrown down ultimately landing in an external bin outside the bottom of the building?
- orangepanda 4y agoThe universal solution is also great for spreading fire. In many places the trash chute violates fire code
- sidewndr46 4y agoI never really gave this much thought as I never lived in a building that uses a chute. But it does make sense. You can build a large building, but it usually has many firestops in it. When wiring crosses a firestop, it must be sealed up to some standards. Ventilation systems are kept isolated across firestops as well. Anything that could encourage a spread is forbidden. In contrast, a fire chute is basically a giant convection tower that should spread smoke and heat across all the higher floors of a building immediately.
- mywittyname 4y agoIt's possible to apply the same fire solutions used for elevators and stair wells to garbage chutes. Build them separately out of cinder block towers and use UL rated doors.
- sidewndr46 4y agoWhile you are right, that is easily circumvented by someone propping the chute door open.
- mjmahone17 4y agoIn the US even zoning to allow 5 story, 25 foot wide row homes to be built everywhere residential housing is allowed would make it easier to develop a lot of housing quickly and cheaply. It’s cheaper to build 1,000 units all at once than 2 units at a time, and if you can fit 500+ units on 500 feet of street frontage, you don’t need to buy a square mile of land in order to build a profitable development.
- sidewndr46 4y agoWhere I live, you can basically only build houses. There is the random lot here and there that somehow got zoned for a duplex. So people focus on building houses because that is all you can build.
- Entinel 4y agoYou say you know that zoning is the biggest hurdle but it's literally the answer to your question. Most zoning in America is for single family homes or large apartments.
- sholladay 4y agoI’ve had some pretty bad experiences living in mid size apartment buildings. Everything from a drugged out neighbor causing a fire, to bed bugs coming through the wall from a slob next door, to someone nearly stealing my car until I shouted at them from four floors up, to landlords who wouldn’t fix leaks for weeks/months after I left a voicemail on their high priority line, to dreadful indoor temperatures because the thermostat controls are overridden by time-of-year policies and heating/cooling is disabled. All this in Boston, at nearly $2,000 per month for a single bedroom, in the mid 2010s. Conceptually, I’m on board with apartment buildings. I would like to think that the future looks more like Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood than the one that I lived in. But the people who evangelize high rise buildings must be either paying for a ritzy place or never actually lived in one.
- skyyler 4y agoI think the general idea is that living in a high rise is better than sleeping in your car or on the street...
- mywittyname 4y agoWe can't have density without multi-family units. And density is what's required to make housing affordable in medium-size or larger cities. > must be either paying for a ritzy place Yes, a compromise for a more pleasant place to live is price. But a side-effect of more affordable housing is that nicer places also get cheaper. Another compromise to get a nicer place to live for the same price is to move to less desirable location.
- imapeopleperson 4y agoIf a nice place is becoming cheaper, it’s also probably becoming less nice.
- skyyler 4y agoIs that true though? Or is it just something that your monkey brain feels?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]